Kia kaha Sarah Dowie

Written By: - Date published: 8:23 am, July 30th, 2020 - 17 comments
Categories: Deep stuff, national, Parliament, Politics - Tags:

Sarah Dowie, National’s Invercargill MP gave her valedictory speech yesterday and it was a very, very good speech.  She was frank and to the point and spoke from the heart.

She is clearly happy to be going.  From Hansard:

When I started my parliamentary career, I would have done anything to make it to the caucus room. The drive was immeasurable. I would have clawed at the windows or walked across hot coals to get in. It was on that premise of motivation that I ran my campaigns and worked with gusto in Parliament and in my community. On leaving, I have the same level of intensity: I could claw at the windows or walk across hot coals to get out.

Her comments on caucus unity and on Labour’s paid parental leave policy were interesting.

There’s a lot to be said for being in an MMP environment. Equally, there’s a lot to be said for being a backbench MP in a stable Rt Hon Sir John Key Government, where discipline was almost a monotheistic religion. In the House, the whips would regularly blow their whistles, and we would head over the metaphorical trenches to present our views in the first, second, and third readings. Sometimes National’s position on issues would stick in one’s craw, none so much for me as voting against Sue Moroney’s paid parental leave member’s bill on the basis of fiscal prudency, only to later campaign on it in the 2017 election. I remember being nervous about speaking, because of my views, and, of course, Labour were in full rampage. Their tongues cracked against our skin like electricity.

My speech was a little more moderate than most. Mr Speaker said to me afterward that he couldn’t tell whether I was supporting the bill or not.

…

Paid parental leave, including having workable conditions governing it, resonates. I am, of course, before a politician, first and foremost a mother, and it just goes to show what happens when a bit of common sense gets injected into parliamentary debate. I thank Iain Lees-Galloway for picking it up.

She spoke about the camaraderie that exists between politicians of all sides.

It’s easy to get embroiled in domestic politics, but when we go overseas, party colours go out the window. I came to realise this more so in 2017 while travelling with Peeni Henare from Labour on a trip that will forever remain with me: the 100th commemoration of the Battle of Passchendaele. It had extra significance for me. My great-great-uncle died at Passchendaele and was awarded a VC for his efforts. Peeni joined me in visiting his grave, and from there the raw, visceral emotion continued to build. Passchendaele is unreal. I have never felt emotion like it. It wasn’t just sorrow or pride; whatever it was sat in your gut for days and manifested in the physical and, of course, tears. The services were so powerful you could literally feel the spirits of the dead rising.

She was frank about Jami-Lee Ross:

According to the more experienced politician, everyone has an annus horribilis. Mine hit full peak in January 2019, and I didn’t think my personal life was too out of the ordinary until my name scrolled across The AM Show‘s newsreel, bumping Brexit as the lead story. While it’s clear I had made some poor choices, the fact that a press gallery reporter was live providing analysis brought the whole sorry affair to a new level. In my eyes, it can only be described as comical. She was maniacal, could hardly get her words out, and she didn’t have the nous to work out the difference between a complaint, investigation, charge, and proceedings. What followed was worse: a litany of diatribe from even the so-called reputable outlets. At best, some comments could be called wide of the mark. Others were just downright lies. In hindsight, I question whether I should have sued some publications.

…

Compared with recent events where media analysis lasted only a couple of news cycles, the speculation and rubbish continued for me for weeks on end. One woman said to me recently, “Sarah, you were absolutely trashed in the media in 2019, and yet these other MPs experience a couple of media cycles of scrutiny and hide behind mental health issues for their bad behaviour.” The antithesis is the hypocrisy of the media calling for a clean up of politicians. Yes, we are representatives and should take responsibility for poor behaviour, but we are not elected as angels. We too are human and make mistakes, just as journalists do and have. But when a predator is able to manipulate the media for his agenda and the media is directly party to it, it is the media fraternity that needs to audit themselves as to their ethics and their conscious peddling of sexism and patriarchy. If it takes me to be New Zealand’s scarlet woman to highlight this, then so be it.

All in all it was an impressive speech and offered a fascinating and complex insight into Parliamentary life.  It also adds some context to recent debate about morality and politics.

Kia kaha Sarah Dowie.

17 comments on “Kia kaha Sarah Dowie ”

  • Comments are now closed

  1. Incognito 1
    30 July 2020 at 9:04 am

    Thank you.

  2. Treetop 2
    30 July 2020 at 9:10 am

    For me Dowie will be remembered for her relationship with JLR. That love bombing and gaslighting goes on between MPs and that there is an ugly side to this affecting your career, your mental health and possibly ending a committed relationship outside of parliament.

    I do have empathy for MPs who are degraded by their peers and when they need to take timeout for their mental health or when they know that being a politician is no longer for them.

    Those MPs exiting are about to start a new chapter in their life. I do hope that they contribute from the outside to improve, fix and change society for the better.

  3. Tiger Mountain 3
    30 July 2020 at 9:50 am

    There has long been a phenomenon of certain MPs after a year or two in Parliament, obviously being in the “wrong” party. I would not necessarily go that far for Ms Dowie, but she reveals some nice instincts in her speech.

    These “misfits”–human enough Nats, supporting policy that can cause harm to the vulnerable, seem to come particularly from the provinces. “We’re blue around here mate” where every experience reinforces entitled toryism to young people growing up. Employment, school BOTs, sports, service clubs, business associations, and Local Government, regularly operate on a reactionary network of NZ National Party linkages.

    I am generalising, but if she had been raised in an urban Electorate, Sarah Dowie might well have been a Labour or Green MP.

  4. Ad 4
    30 July 2020 at 10:24 am

    The best year in decades to drive a stake through Narional's electoral heart

    Let's make the most of their weeping weakness.

  5. Enough is Enough 5
    30 July 2020 at 10:54 am

    The way Sarah was victimised by the media (or more specifically one member of the media who wanted to sensationalise a very tough part of her life) was a disgrace.

    Brilliant valedictory

  6. Stuart Munro 6
    30 July 2020 at 11:03 am

    But I have spoke

    with one that saw him die: who did report

    that very frankly he confess'd his treasons

    Implored your highness' pardon and set forth

    a deep repentance: nothing in his life

    became him like the leaving it.

    The Scottish Play Act 1 scene 4

  7. aj 7
    30 July 2020 at 12:43 pm

    Let's not gild the lily. She knew JLR was married yet formed a relationship with him. So I'm not placing her too high on any pedestal despite her take on history.

    • Red Blooded One 7.1
      30 July 2020 at 1:49 pm

      Agreed. Certainly a sorry state all round but after witnessing her nastiness on Breakfast TV for years before she was found out to be in her words "A Scarlet Woman" my sympathies don't lie too deep. If it suits her brand to play the victim, so be it.

  8. Anker 8
    30 July 2020 at 2:40 pm

    Incline to agree Aj. I can’t help remember the text she sent to Jami-Lee…..I be no doubt he was manipulative etc, but telling someone they deserve to die, or words to that effect isn’t good. Many of us been in bad relationships and suffered, but don’t respond like that

  9. Jum 9
    30 July 2020 at 3:02 pm

    I'm still waiting to hear from the 15 women that popped up to bring down ross, then suddenly disappeared. At least the exploiter of them – bennett has gone – ahh, the hypocrisy of wearing white in parliament last night, when the heart is charcoal.

    Bridges just sits there grinning from his new moral seat while everyone else's bridges burn.

  10. Robert Guyton 10
    30 July 2020 at 3:21 pm

    Dowie idolised Key. She was besties with Todd Barclay. She fell for JLR.

    Dowie calls the Southland women who are critical of her, "the witches".

    I dunno…

    • solkta 10.1
      30 July 2020 at 4:05 pm

      yeh it no fly for me.

      • observer 10.1.1
        30 July 2020 at 5:07 pm

        I'm happy to go with the judgement of Labour MPs like Kiri Allan, Clare Curran, Grant Robertson etc, who have all publicly expressed their support and admiration for Dowie's speech. To say nothing of the other Labour MPs mentioned in the speech.

        I guess it comes down to their daily experience of working with an MP from another party, versus our blog reckons.

  11. George 11
    30 July 2020 at 3:30 pm

    I am confused by the Dowie speech. Can someone explain it to me? She had an affair with said ex Nat. All hell broke loose…she told him to go ahead and die…more hell was unleashed. And she is a victim amongst all the drama that has ensued…which reporter..what happened?

  12. Sabine 12
    30 July 2020 at 8:58 pm

    so

    what did she achieve for her electorate?

  13. peter sim 13
    1 August 2020 at 7:44 pm

    The hallowed media, of course, do not need morality, justice, fairness. Only headlines, to sell advertising. How very enlightening and uplifting. Sigh.

The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.