On Freedom

Written By: Steve Pierson - Date published: 6:51 am, July 5th, 2008 - 122 comments
Categories: greens, labour, progressives, Social issues, workers' rights - Tags:

It is time for the Left to take back the language of freedom. At its heart freedom, power for the ordinary person, is what the Left is about.

– Freedom from unemployment,
– Freedom from crappy wages that mean you have to work 60 hours a week to make ends meet,
– Freedom from having to bow to the boss’s demands and risking your job if you demand fair treatment,
– Freedom from big businesses being allowed to pollute our water, our land, our air,
– Freedom from the fear that getting sick will mean you lose your income and need to borrow to pay for treatment,
– Freedom from having your opportunities determined by the education your parents can afford to buy,
– Freedom from the social pressures that see the fate of those at the bottom of the heap repeated by their children.
– Freedom from having our schools, our hospitals, our public assets owned by foreign banks who only want to make a profit out of us.

That’s real freedom; that’s what the Left stands for. Politicians of the Left should be proud to say it.

122 comments on “On Freedom ”

Comments are now closed

pinetree 1

5 July 2008 at 7:21 am

I’m having a Hayek moment…
AndrewE 2

5 July 2008 at 7:29 am

I’d agree with most of those principles but then I’m a nasty centrist. 🙂

I think the last one is not necessary myself as sometimes the private sector (with SLAs) can normally do things more efficiently.
travellerev 3

5 July 2008 at 8:01 am

Way to go Standardistas.

Captcha: change contrast, Sometimes I feel this gizmo is trying to tell us something. LOL
Monty 4

5 July 2008 at 8:16 am

Good work – also please add some other freedoms those on the right want for all people.
Freedom from nanny State
Freedom from over taxation
Freedom from smears and personal attacks
Freedom of choice in workplace insurance providers
Freedom to choose school for children
Freedom to select most appropriate health provider
Freedom to live is a safe community (especially South Auckland)
Freedom to enjoy security of supply from electricity companies
Freedom to be able to individually negotiate a wage that reflects your particular skill set instead of getting lumped in with underperformers
Freedom to have you voice heard in election year.
Monty 5

5 July 2008 at 8:18 am

why am I on moderation this time?

[lprent: not sure – there has be a lot of it this morning. But almost all of them were ‘lists’. I suspect that the anti-spam code is looking at the lists and saying “thats suspicious”.]
Blar 6

5 July 2008 at 8:51 am

The “ordinary person” vs the straw man of the “boss/business/big business” line is nasty, divisive politics no different from the Iwi/Kiwi style of politics sold by Crosby Textor.

Anyway, on the substance (I use the term loosely) of your post, essentially all you’ve done is list a bunch of negative freedoms in a creepy sort of way. The thing is, all of your freedoms necessitate the intervention of the state to enforce an economic or social order. I think conceivably you are promoting a form of freedom within that social order but that is essentially freedom only within that order, not the freedom to change it. It’s a false sort of state-defined freedom at the expense of another group – the ‘boss’ – that makes me feel a bit uncomfortable.

I just don’t think it’s right to making people slaves of the state is a reasonable response to a perception that people are slaves of some ill-defined social elite.
MikeE 7

5 July 2008 at 9:42 am

One thinks that you don’t actually understand the cost of freedom at all.

Just what the **** is “Freedom from unemployment”

There is no such thing as “Freedom” from unemployment, what you are actually saying is “Someone MUST be forced to provide me a job” regardless of whether I add value to their organisation.

This adds to noones freedom whatsoever, but does impose an obligation on somone.

The same goes with every example you give, none of which increase freedoms, all of which impose obligations.

good on you for a fine example of orwelliean doublespeak however. Big Brother commends you.
Inventory2 8

5 July 2008 at 10:12 am

Work 60 hours a week to make ends meet – sheesh – Mrs Inventory and I do that every week; in fact for her, it’s more like 75 hours – and we OWN the business!! And we actually pay ourselves well below “market” rates so that we can pay our teachers and support staff at above “consenting parties” rates in our industry. But then again, I’m just a rightie, so WTF would I know??!!
Ari 9

5 July 2008 at 10:14 am

I think you forgot a lot of freedom TO statements.

Specifically the ones that centre around the freedom to be yourself.
Shaun 10

5 July 2008 at 10:17 am

I’m genuinely interested – could you tell me how the state taking half of my money and regulating almost every aspect of my life makes me “free” – I really can’t see it. Thanks!
Lew 11

5 July 2008 at 10:26 am

Steve: Bravo. You’ve given voice to a bunch of ideals with which few reasonable people can easily disagree. I have several critiques.

This notional world you describe is not in fact `real freedom’ as you claim – together these negative freedoms broadly constitute societal risk from want and fear, and are therefore only the beginning of freedom. I quoted Arendt on this blog a week or two ago on this topic, and I’ll do so again:

“All these liberties, to which we might add our own claims to be free from want and fear, are of course essentially negative; they are the results of liberation but they are by no means the actual content of freedom’ (from On Revolution).

Blar’s observation that these freedoms are negative is correct, as is MikeE’s – that freedoms or rights are defined by the obligations they place on others. These two broad lines of attack both stem from the fact that by constructing freedoms as negative you cede orthodoxy to those who oppose you. By refusing to cede orthodoxy both arguments can be won.

Citing a bunch of negative freedoms and framing the person or group who is notionally preventing those freedoms from being exercised marginalises your position. Marginalising one’s position is useful for fomenting a revolutionary mindset in your polity, but I think that to do so in the strong liberal and social democracy we have in NZ would do more harm than good to your cause. To prevent your message and your principles from being discredited as extremist backlash, it’s important to frame them as positives: freedom to work, as opposed to freedom from unemployment. These definitions should work together with the negative definitions: the two sets are mutually inclusive.

Blar: “The “ordinary person’ vs the straw man of the “boss/business/big business’ line is nasty, divisive politics no different from the Iwi/Kiwi style of politics sold by Crosby Textor.”

Partly true: it is a wedge, but all it is is the same wedge used in a different point in society: instead of being used to separate `hard-working kiwis’ from those who, by exemption, clearly aren’t hard-working, (or the `wealth generators’ from the … what … `wealth destroyers’? – etc.) it separates those who by and large do the work from those who require that it be done. As far as logical separations go, this is a much less arbitrary split: this split progresses along normative lines based on occupation: there are by necessity more `ordinary people’ than there are `bosses’, whereas `hard-working kiwi’ is so nebulous a term it can be used to make the split between almost any two groups the splitter wants to separate.

MikeE: “good on you for a fine example of orwelliean doublespeak”

Steve redefined a bunch of terminology. Your rebuttal smear is a nice example of the propaganda machine well at work: `Orwellian doublespeak’ is characterised by redefinition of terms to include a logical contradiction. None of the above contain one, because it’s not at all axiomatic that nobody should ever be obliged to provide something for someone. You frame this as compulsion, whereas in fact there is a duty to care for one’s fellow woman incumbent upon everyone in society. You believe in society, don’t you?

You have a nice safe essentialist position of believing your terminology is inherently the Truth. However, this is not science, or mathematics, or religion: there is no definitive Truth – in these cases, Truth is defined by usage.

L
Brett Dale 12

5 July 2008 at 10:32 am

Freedom to eat what you like.

Freedom to drink what you like.

Freedom to drive the car you like.

Freedom to watch/read/listen material what you like.

Freedom to own a gun.

Freedom to buy shares and sell them to who you want to

Freedom to Hire/Fire who you want if you own a business

Freedom to say what you want for/against a political party

Freedom to speak out against the impact of manmade climate change

Freedom not to worry about your socalled global footprint

Freedom from higher taxes.

Freedom to make your own decisions and live by them

Freedom to walk the streets with law abiding people

Freedom to say what you like, without the fear of some jackass getting offended

Freedom to play sport against what country you like

Freedom to live your life with as little as government interfernce as possible.

All right wing values.
Karl Rohde 13

5 July 2008 at 10:33 am

Unfortunately Labour is not a left wing party; nor do they understand the business model of New Zealand. 75% of the labour caucus have never even been employed by a traditional business.

The reality is 20% of the workforce are employed by businesses that have less than 10 staff. That excludes the sole-trader who makes up a further 15% on the NZ workforce.

These are the businesses and sole traders make up nearly 90% of the enterprises in New Zealand.

They are the businesses being hampered by and persecuted by “baby and the bathwater” bureaucratic policy that increase the owners working hours. They are the ones that keep the economy ticking along.

Most businesses owners that run these businesses are not rich. They are just making a living; and getting on with life.

When the far left understand that in NZ, these businesses owners are not the enemy, then we will see some adequate and sensible policy that does not just target a mere 1% of the enterprises in NZ.
Principessa 14

5 July 2008 at 10:44 am

The Freedom to work in a smokefree environment and not contract lung cancer from second hand smoke.
Ed 15

5 July 2008 at 10:47 am

Some of the Freedoms above are fairly basic freedoms – freedom from want – the freedom from starvation, freedom from being homeless etc. In a society that (at least currently) provides that these can be reasonably taken for granted – even if disaster strikes, we have indeed moved to also be concerned about other freedoms. I believe that the freedom to develop according to abilities and skills and personal hard work, regardless of the financial position of your family, is important. Most New Zealanders do not like the arrogance of privilege; we see ourselves as egalitarian and not a class society; we do not want some jobs reserved to those who attended an expensive school, or who have inherited wealth.
Karl Rohde 16

5 July 2008 at 10:48 am

And for those that think I am being melodramatic about “businesses being hampered by and persecuted” I suggest you go down to your local district court on “I.R.D. prosecution days”.

You will see average men and women with a fear in their eyes like you will seldom see. These are guys who have lawn mowing rounds – their accounts are scrawled onto rough paper stuck in their back pocket. Or the home-worker doing sewing who didn’t realize she had to pay her own tax because she just though she was doing a few home jobs for pocket money. The business owner who got behind on tax because his accountant gave him the wrong advice. The business owner being bankrupted because I.R.D. felt they came ahead of putting a roof over his head.

The fear from these people being treated like scum by the bureaucratic engine can be tasted. (now that is a bit melodramatic)

The left, right and all parties need to understand that these people are not the enemy. Just because someone is in business does not mean they are taking advantage of someone else or are rich pricks or are less worthy of ACC or hardship grants when it goes horribly wrong.

We are a nation of small business, and everyone needs to respect that. Hard left (or right) policies do not work for these businesses.
vto 17

5 July 2008 at 10:49 am

Classic.

Love the long list of Brett Dale’s freedoms and Karl Rohdes post. Both spot on.

FFS, wouldn’t we all love to be free from the restrictions and fate of life on planet earth. Don’t think its just one part of society that gets squashed by life – that would be quite naive.

Gotta watch out for idealogoues like you Mr Pierson. Its people with passions (obsessions) like that who crush so much when they get too near the reins of power.
Clunking Fist 18

5 July 2008 at 10:57 am

Gosh, well that’s that sorted then.
higherstandard 19

5 July 2008 at 11:02 am

Ed your comment intrigues me

“Most New Zealanders do not like the arrogance of privilege; we see ourselves as egalitarian and not a class society; we do not want some jobs reserved to those who attended an expensive school, or who have inherited wealth.”

Can you expand and let us know what you’re alluding to.
dad4justice 20

5 July 2008 at 11:26 am

How can you have “freedom” in New Zealand when you have various government departments actively progressing unlawful gender discrimination?
Blar 21

5 July 2008 at 11:29 am

Partly true: it is a wedge, but all it is is the same wedge used in a different point in society: instead of being used to separate `hard-working kiwis’ from those who, by exemption, clearly aren’t hard-working, (or the `wealth generators’ from the what `wealth destroyers’? – etc.) it separates those who by and large do the work from those who require that it be done

This is a very nebulous area. What about so called mum and dad share holders in public companies? What about people whose Kiwisaver programmes involve investment in companies? These groups of people clearly requiring work to be done in order to receive a dividend but aren’t exactly a social elite. Steve’s post is based on a bizzare 19th century view of the world.
rave 22

5 July 2008 at 11:45 am

So it comes down to greed or need defining freedom.
Greed says I want, need says our wants.
Greed says my freedom, need says our freedom.
Greed says my choice, my rights. Need says our choice, our rights.
Greed says private ownership, need says collective ownership.
Greed says private responsibility, need says collective responsibility.
Greed says the individual is sovereign, need says the people are sovereign.
Greed says market, need says society.
Greed will destroy the planet, need saves the planet.
Greed is self-serving, self-defeating, need is humanity-serving and surviving.
Greed is boring, tiresome, stupid; need is alive, challenging, wise.
outofbed 23

5 July 2008 at 11:55 am

In the words of an old Redgum song “meet your needs not your greeds”
Karl Rohde 24

5 July 2008 at 11:56 am

greed:
excessive desire to acquire or possess more (especially more material wealth) than one needs or deserves

need:
A condition of poverty or misfortune

Amazing how words can be used.

Saying anyone who wants a little bit of individuality or niceties of life is greedy (which rave, your text strongly lends itself to) is very Protestant and completely unrealistic.

Ice Cream is not “needed” – lets get rid of it, it’s just making some shareholders rich. Pity about the several hundred people who just lost their job; guess they better go out and work the land to live like good Protestants – don’t forget the hair-shirts.

The balance between need and greed is not black and white, history has proven this time and again.
The PC Avenger 25

5 July 2008 at 12:01 pm

Monty and Brett, most of the values and freedoms you cite are, at best, incongruent with the actions of right wing governments, politicians, political pundits and the supporters of the former.
Snelly Boy 26

5 July 2008 at 12:02 pm

Didn’t anyone else notice the irony of yesterday’s trucking protest.

A nationwide protest that despite one’s personal thoughts about its motives, everyone has been universal about their right to freedom of speech.

But hello. I thought due to the EFA we were in the grips of Mugabe like supression of any dissenting voice.

Perhaps the Road Transport Forum is in fact in breach of the EFA advocating a non-vote for Labour? Imagine the squeals from those sad, miserable individuals from the right if this had been an anti-National protest?

The RTF certainly would have ‘spent’ more than $120k yesterday Are they registered as a third party?
santi 27

5 July 2008 at 12:03 pm

Above all: Freedom from socialism!
Felix 28

5 July 2008 at 12:16 pm

Brett, I really, really hope you haven’t exercised your “freedom to own a gun”.
Felix 29

5 July 2008 at 12:21 pm

Inventory2,

The validity of your comment hinges entirely on the phrase “to make ends meet”.

Pc Avenger,

Don’t tell them that, they’ve worked so hard to become right-wingers…
Brett Dale 30

5 July 2008 at 12:22 pm

Nope, I would never own a gun, but if someone wants to buy one, if should their be right, just like if the hippies want to smoke dope or if people want to take party pills, then that is their right.
monkey-boy 31

5 July 2008 at 12:26 pm

Snelly the only irony I noticed was that a blog (This one) which purports to support the Labour movement was opposed to the industrial action on the basis that it was probably a right-wing plot, while a right wing blog which is supposed to be the stomping ground of ‘rich-pricks’ and nasty capitalists was largely supportive of an industrial action by the truckies on the basis that ordinary folk are sick of being taxed to the hilt.
Again, wouldn’t it be ironic that on a post about ‘Freedom’ on a blog about “The Labour Movement’ that anyone would advocate that a political protest undergo prosecution by the state because it might have the audacity to criticise the government?
Who should be fined, or put in jail first would you suggest?
vto 32

5 July 2008 at 12:30 pm

what about the right to own a mini nuclear device?
Bill 33

5 July 2008 at 12:37 pm

There is an easy tried and tested way around the negativities of Steve’s post. It is true that if the freedoms are to be provided by the state then a degree of thralldom is implied.

Workers co-operatives address some of the objections voiced in comments. When the workers co-ops or collectives are tied into housing collectives then all the objections become addressed.

I lived in such a scenario. 12 adults + children. 20 houses. 1 business. Average hours involved in renumerative work…about 8 hours per week.

This was adequate to pay off the mortgages and provide for material comfort.

Legally, we were (nominal) shareholders. There was no vertical division of labour.

We controlled all aspects of the business and our social environment. Our limitations were those imposed by the overarching legal oconstraints of the nation state and our own imaginations.

Nobody was unemployed. All work had value attached. For example, if one person doing childcare or domestic work allowed others to contribute to the business side of things, it was fully acknowledged.

Crappy wages were not paid. In fact, no wages were paid. We decided collectively how business profits were spent. (x% reinvestment, x% for building maintainence and so on.) Personal monies were taken from whatever was left after all expenditures were covered. (The only personal expenditure needed was for social activity…seeing a band, going to pictures or whatever)

There was no boss. We were all ‘the boss’.

Big business polluting the environment? Okay. We had no control over that…only our own waste. We had our own sewerage treatment and tended towards non polluting behaviour.

No loss of income through sickness or injury.

No loss of opportunity because of lack of money. (You didn’t ‘buy’ your way in to the collective.)

Economically determined social pressures negated.

Schools and hospitals were out side our control as were a number of factors, but where practical we had the wherewithal to determine our own social/work environment and at least ameliorate the effects of some of those factors we could not control.

We had some trading arrangements with other collectives and managed to achieve, in a sea of conventional business practice, a large degree of autonomy and self empowerment.

In an environment where most business/ social activity followed the collective model, the state as we know it and experience it would become irrelevant and disappear. Big business…the global corporates…could not exist. They rely on strict hierarchy which is the exact opposite of worker cooperation.

It’s all mind set. We can have freedoms. The state cannot provide them. Anything given by the state can be taken away by the state. But when we give ourselves the freedom….
Lew 34

5 July 2008 at 12:37 pm

Brett Dale: “Freedom to (lots of things)”

Brett, this is the single most lucid comment I’ve seen from you.

There’s one problem, though:

“All right wing values.”

No. They’re all Libertarian values. Ask any Libertarian whether they consider themselves a right-winger: most will reject the paradigm outright; a few will make a qualified agreement.

It’s OK, though – while you’ve mistakenly engaged in a left-right ideological debate, these are all laudable (even if some are arguable trivial) freedoms, and although many of them are posited on the Libertarian idea of `I’ll do what I like and the rest of you be damned’ they’re all arguable.

Now – if you’d like to argue ’em, I’m sure a few people on here have strong views on what’s wrong with libertarianism.

L
higherstandard 35

5 July 2008 at 12:38 pm

vto – I’m open to the idea as long as the fallout is minimal and it’s detonated in very close proximity to parliament.
Lew 36

5 July 2008 at 12:41 pm

Blar: “This is a very nebulous area. What about so called mum and dad share holders in public companies? What about people whose Kiwisaver programmes involve investment in companies? These groups of people clearly requiring work to be done in order to receive a dividend but aren’t exactly a social elite.”

I don’t see how any of Steve’s freedoms impinge upon this in practice.

“Steve’s post is based on a bizzare 19th century view of the world.”

Now here’s a valid point of debate. Do you have any arguments to support it, or are we to take it at face value? Like Brett’s Libertarianism thing above, I’m sure there are a few people here who’ll argue that the fundamental distinction between capital and labour which Marx identified in the C19th still broadly holds true today.

L
Lew 37

5 July 2008 at 12:42 pm

HS, I never picked you as an anarchist!

L
higherstandard 38

5 July 2008 at 12:49 pm

Lew channeling a colleague in Wellington……..

“A nuclear device on the Ministry of Health would have too much fallout for the good people of Wellington, but it would make me feel a lot better. I used to sit in the offices of the Cancer Society, which overlook the Ministry of Health, and imagine the effect of setting up a mortar or a heavy machine gun and traversing through the health department. It made me so happy but I must not even think these things.”

http://www.stuff.co.nz/sundaystartimes/4455535a20455.html
bill brown 39

5 July 2008 at 12:49 pm

Brett Dale

Why didn’t you save all that typing and instead write:

Freedom to steal from others to gain advantage?

Basically that’s all you said through a whole lot of examples.
higherstandard 40

5 July 2008 at 12:53 pm

Bill

If you’re that twisted you could ask the same question of SP.
vto 41

5 July 2008 at 12:58 pm

Freedom to roam over any land you want, provided no harm caused to those who live in the particular locality.
Lew 42

5 July 2008 at 12:58 pm

Bill: “I lived in such a scenario.”

You use the past tense. Why did you leave?

L
Bill 43

5 July 2008 at 1:04 pm

I sometimes ask myself that question.

I thought there would be a reasonable number of similar scenarios in NZ, so I came here.

I was wrong.
vto 44

5 July 2008 at 1:04 pm

freedom to restrict.

(sorry fullas and fullesses, bit bored in this snow storm)

[lprent: the freedom to moderate ? Damn I need to find the devil smiley 8) ]
higherstandard 45

5 July 2008 at 1:12 pm

Lynn

Apparently >:)

http://elouai.com/yahoo_smiley.php

vto agreed weather is cak although sun has just come out up here.
vto 46

5 July 2008 at 1:17 pm

ha ha, they are one and the same Iprent. High five.

HS Snow on the lawn and not letting up here. And we are by the beach.

Freedom to splash in puddles sounds like the one. Later.
Edosan 47

5 July 2008 at 1:23 pm

Freedom from unemployment?

And here I am always striving for freedom from employment.

Guess I’m out of touch.
lprent 48

5 July 2008 at 1:23 pm

Try this

http://www.thestandard.org.nz/?page_id=2417

It hangs off the FAQ page
infused 49

5 July 2008 at 1:34 pm

Thanks Karl Rohde. You’re on to it. As a business owner myself, I agree with everything you’ve said. We aren’t rich, and I spend around 60-80hrs a week and most weekends working in or on my business.
Peter Cresswell 50

5 July 2008 at 1:35 pm

“At its heart freedom, power for the ordinary person, is what the Left is about…”

Steve, at its heart, your litany of so called ‘freedoms’ are nothing but a call for freedom from the demands of reality. Which, as Bill says, above, us just the freedom to steal from others.

Have you ever read the Declaration of Independence?

Have you ever understood what the rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of property and happiness really mean?

Do you care?
travellerev 51

5 July 2008 at 1:38 pm

Rave
I really liked your post so I hope you don’t mind if I put it on my blog. It’s poetry.
Peter Cresswell 52

5 July 2008 at 1:39 pm

Contrast “freedom from” with “freedom to.”

“Freedom from want” is not equal to “freedom to pursue one’s own happiness.”

The former requires enslaving others to provide one’s sustenance.

The latter simply requires that you each recognise the other’s moral space to pursue their own values.

It is this real freedom — the freedom to be oneself, to pursue one’s own ends, within one’s own moral space — that the left truly despises.

The only thing the left has done with the language of freedom is to pervert it.
Bill 53

5 July 2008 at 1:56 pm

Peter
the real freedom to be one’s self (a misogynist and a rapist), to pursue one’s own ends (rape), within one’s own moral space (no moral qualms with rape)!?

Morality is a social construction. Individualism sits at odds with the reality that we are social animals living within constraints of our society. The norms developed by society are not always positive, but individualism is never positive and can too easily be entirely negative.

Freedom (if it is to mean anything at all beyond the exercise of power) must be negotiated and be accountable to the larger social context within which it exists.

Oh…unless you want to have the freedom to flap your arms and fly off a building, the freedom to breath under water and so on.
Bill 54

5 July 2008 at 2:00 pm

And the ‘pursuit of property’? That’s got nothing to do with substantive freedom. That really is a licence for theft!

You pursue property at whose expense? That land. Who used it, lived off of it? They had no concept of ownership so you have the right to ship them out and own it?

Or maybe exterminate them in the name of property rights, of civilised progress.
monkey-boy 55

5 July 2008 at 2:08 pm

Why is it that anarchists only use teabags?

Because proper tea is theft!

They can take our land, but they can’t take our FREEEEEEEEDOMMMM!!!!

sorry, thought we were doing ‘Braveheart’.
Doug 56

5 July 2008 at 2:10 pm

Over Ten Thousand in people in Botany Downs crying out for freedom from crime. Hope Helen takes note would be the largest demonstration in years may be all time.
jbc 57

5 July 2008 at 2:10 pm

Steve, your list of freedoms is not a list of freedoms. You need to find a better word because freedom does not make sense in those cases.

Start with the first one: Freedom from unemployment. Can’t see how freedom has anything to do with that. “Freedom from employment” would be closer to making sense.

Freedom from unemployment basically means someone must be forced to employ you.

If I have more work than I can do and decide to hire someone then I would like the freedom to choose whoever is best for the job. That might turn out to be nobody. Similarly, if I have already hired someone and they turn out to not have the capacity to do the job (despite saying so in an interview) then I would like the freedom to let them go look for something else.
J 58

5 July 2008 at 3:39 pm

I agree with freedom from being unemployed. A work for the dole scheme would do wonders for the work ethic of those on the benefit. They could be engaged in minor gardening duties, befriending and helping the elderly, painting over graffiti and other community orientated services which are currently lacking.

And excellent idea
Felix 59

5 July 2008 at 4:20 pm

jbc,

Government policy can result in an increase in unemployment (as we saw in the late 80s/early 90s) or a decrease (as we’ve seen more recently).

Therefore a policy (or set of policies) which involve driving unemployment up in order to put downward pressure on wages and cripple the bargaining power of workers could certainly be framed as impacting your right to be free from unemployment. The inverse is also true.

Can you give an example of the scenario you describe in which someone (presumably the gummint) forces you to employ someone against your will? One which is relevant in a contemporary setting? I’m having trouble making much sense of that to be honest.
jbc 60

5 July 2008 at 4:21 pm

Lew: I’m sure there are a few people here who’ll argue that the fundamental distinction between capital and labour which Marx identified in the C19th still broadly holds true today.

Sorry to crash in on this, but this comment got me thinking. Is the capital/labour distinction as relevent today as it was 100+ years ago?

I have many acquantainces who don’t fit that distinction – and I think that that situation is becoming more and more common.

For these people (call them small businesses) the only capital they need is what is between their ears. No land and no factories. They can work from home or gather with a few similar people and rent a small office.

A lot of tradespeople are in a similar situation albeit they might need a small amount of capital in their tools and utility vehicle.

I think a lot of the arguments of the left ignore small business and self-employed – or they pretend they do not exist because they do not fit their world view (workers shackled in coal mines, shipyards, cotton factories).

Sure, there are still some classic examples of the capital/labour distinction however I’d argue that overall it is no longer black and white. Those who stick with that mindset are dinosaurs.
Edosan 61

5 July 2008 at 4:24 pm

I think we could safely patch this up by saying ‘freedom from unemployment should you choose to be employed’. Since choice does seem to be a rather essential part of freedom i thought it was implied, but perhaps not.

Needless to say, i don’t agree with compulsory work for the dole schemes.
Robinsod 62

5 July 2008 at 4:27 pm

Sure, there are still some classic examples of the capital/labour distinction however I’d argue that overall it is no longer black and white. Those who stick with that mindset are dinosaurs.

jbc – I think you’ll find the vast majority of New Zealanders earn their living by supplying their labour to someone else – generally someone who owns the means of production. I suspect you have fallen into the trap of mistakenly extrapolating your own experiences across the whole population. To be fair, you have been encouraged to do so by a twenty five year campaign of neoliberal “entrepreneurial nation” rhetoric.
Karl Rohde 63

5 July 2008 at 4:32 pm

I think both left and right has lost it’s way in the modern world.

You can have “individual” goals and aspirations without causing society to be neglected. They are not mutually exclusive.

Wanting a nice car, nice house or an annual holiday is not nor should it be considered in any way a crime against the better good. Wanting a nice piece of artwork doesn’t make you selfish, despite it costing you $25,000.

The fact that someone has positioned themselves and made decisions to obtain certain material gains does not make them a monster.

An ACC system that excludes self-employed. A revenue collection service that treats small business with disdain but allows big business absolute leniency. A health system where you have to pay $21 for a 3 year old because you live in a “rich” area.

These are all under a so called progressive government for the people. That is monstrous.

It smacks way too much of Animal Farm. In a true socialist regime, everyone is equal. You pay your tax, you get the same benefits as everyone else. Don’t say we can’t afford it. It just requires efficiency in government.
Robinsod 64

5 July 2008 at 4:42 pm

Yes Karl – efficiency in government. Strange that nobody has actually produced any hard evidence of how that efficiency could be achieved.

I suggest you read animal farm (it shouldn’t be too hard even for you) if you think it’s an apt metaphor for a system to look after the less fortunate in society. Really mate if you’re going to try to make literary allusions you should stick to books you’ve actually read though I’m not sure how “rich dad, poor dad” or any of the other self-improvement bullshit you read would have any value to the conversations here…
jbc 65

5 July 2008 at 4:59 pm

Felix,

We may be more in agreement than you think. My argument is not about the sentiment of the post, but simply that ‘freedom from unemployment’ doesn’t make sense to me. Employment requires at least two people: employer and employee. Both have to be willing.

Someone above made a distasteful remark about freedom to rape in an attempt to discredit the meaning of the word in another post. Of course freedom to rape is not about freedom at all – when you look at both sides. Same goes for (un)employment.

Freedom to seek employment. I can understand that.
Freedom to employ. I can understand that too.

I’m not just trying to be pedantic. Freedom is good. Freedom is something that I argue about (but usually confined to software, patents, etc)
Karl Rohde 66

5 July 2008 at 5:14 pm

I have read Animal Farm, many times. It is a statement of what happens in a socialist society when through human nature some people have higher status that others due to need or responsibility despite best intentions.

My father was in the merchant navy at the age if 14 and never finished school. My mother was a blacksmiths daughter and worked in a bakery during the second world war in occupied Denmark. I am obviously from a very privileged background. None of my 6 other siblings nor I have been to university, or have had free tertiary education. When my parents got their first house, it was a shack with paper lining.

I could not read until I was nearly 8 – but the first book I read from cover to cover after remedial reading classes was…. The Lord of The Rings. Not a small feat for someone who could not read 12 months earlier.

I may only have fifth form English, but I am still capable of reading and understanding. In fact, I currently know about 20 languages if you include the various computer programming languages I have learnt over the years, and am currently teaching myself Spanish.

As the adverts say… know me before you judge me.

And as for “any hard evidence of how that efficiency could be achieved.” I suggest you read “The Yellow Brick Road”. Works for corporates, NoPs, NoGs, Governments Depts, SOEs and pretty much every else.

And on the matter of freedom:

Freedom
the right to enjoy all the privileges or special rights of citizenship, membership, etc., in a community or the like.
jbc 67

5 July 2008 at 5:17 pm

‘sod: you miss my point. Sure, most people supply labour to someone else. I do too. I also have a shareholding in my company and sign my own pay cheques. So am I capital or labour?

Sometimes “owning the means of production” is as simple as buying a secondhand PC.

I think you’ll find a hell of a lot of people in NZ work for, or own, a small business. I don’t have the stats handy but I’m pretty sure that the employment landscape today isn’t quite the same as it was in the time of Das Kapital.

I’m not spouting propaganda, just speaking from my own encounters.
bill brown 68

5 July 2008 at 5:22 pm

When my parents got their first house, it was a shack with paper lining.

Luxury. We used to have to get out of the lake at six o’clock in the morning, clean the lake, eat a handful of ‘ot gravel, work twenty hour day at mill for tuppence a month, come home, and Dad would thrash us to sleep with a broken bottle, if we were lucky!
Bill 69

5 July 2008 at 5:25 pm

Seems to me that the Marxist analysis of class misses out on one very important class; the managerial or co-ordinator class. These guys get well renumerated; do not own any means of production and essentially maintain the status quo that rewards them so well.

As for small business owners. I do have some sympathy for some, though not all, of them.

The market is geared to benefit big business and that means that conventional small businesses will be disadvantaged on a range of fronts.

So why follow convention when setting up a business? There are other business set up models.

Having set yourself up in the conventional way and slaved your guts out for the first year or more to stay afloat, it is not legitimate to then use that experience as an excuse to shaft future employees – as many do.

‘You’ could have used a more equitable set up model for your business and avoided or lessened the effects of the stresses many small business owners experience in the initial stages (extraordinary long hours, bugger all financial return, worry over consequences of failure such as loss of house etc, struggling with new skill sets such as IRD reporting, H&S compliance etc etc)

That ‘you’ didn’t is nobody’s fault but your own. Looking to exercise any ‘god complex’ resulting from having survived the trials outlined above and somehow expecting the freedom to act as judge and jury on your employees is not legitimate.
outofbed 70

5 July 2008 at 5:28 pm

and you try telling the kids of today that………..
Bill 71

5 July 2008 at 5:34 pm

jbc
I was discrediting the idiotic notion of individualism masquerading as freedom…not freedom.

An obvious if distasteful illustration to highlight a distasteful concept perhaps
Karl Rohde 72

5 July 2008 at 5:37 pm

“I think you’ll find a hell of a lot of people in NZ work for, or own, a small business.”

Try 90% of all 290000 enterprises in NZ have less than 10 staff or are considered sole traders – that essentially means 290,000 people of a workforce of 1.8 million are self employed and 300,000 people are employed by these enterprises. (2006 stats)

That is not a small percentage. Are they all “rich pricks” as some misinformed so called lefties seem to think. Do they all treat their staff like shit. Nope. They are just the same as the cobbler, the wainwright, the blacksmith, the farrier of 300 years ago.

The only difference is these working class people of old focused on bettering their craft, improving their lot in life. They had skills. Their society saw them as valuable not a scourge.

Capitalism in it’s purest form is not bad, in the same way as Socialism in it’s purest form is not bad.

The problem is people. Let’s get rid of them. They are just cluttering up the world anyway! Actually – why not just focus on business owners. All leave now.

Lets see how long the “underdog” survives and how quickly new owners appear. NZ would then truly see what poverty and hardship was.
santi 73

5 July 2008 at 5:43 pm

Bill, your attempt failed miserably, ergo, you didn’t discredit anything at all.

Individualism is still the most powerful force driving human beings, to the dismay of the left (socialists and totalitarians of all colours).

Don’t try to rewrite history. It’s a futile effort.

[lprent: I’ll check moderation. I suspect you’re still in the file, but you shouldn’t be (at present)]
Bill 74

5 July 2008 at 5:52 pm

Karl
Unlike cash strapped or unskilled workers, ‘successful’ business owners (ie, those who have made a mint) can go anywhere they want and waltz through immigration policies no sweat.

Which would be a nice freedom…freedom of movement of people. Ah. but that would impact on corporate profit margins. So we can forget that one too.
Karl Rohde 75

5 July 2008 at 5:53 pm

Before anyone corrects me – when referencing Animal Farm I actually meant it is a statement on Communism. Although it still applies to socialism to a large degree.
Bill 76

5 July 2008 at 5:55 pm

santi, individualism is a political ideology predicated on the absurd notion that society does not exist!
Karl Rohde 77

5 July 2008 at 6:06 pm

The ultimate goal of socialism is to have a workforce that is not disenfranchised from the means of production.

The easiest method for this is to have a small business “model” where the employer (leader/manager) and employee have a close relationship. Co-operatives still need leaders/managers, someone to take “ownership”. Leaders tend to work longer and have more responsibility.

Most business owners in NZ barely make ends met. They work hard and they have good relationships with their workers. The only ones we seem to hear about are the exceptions.

Unfortunately the attitude of current socialist orientated government and most of the people who run down small business owners (predominately so call socialists) seem to forget this.

Leadership implies more responsibility. By very nature (long before industrialism) more responsibility granted you more privilege.

There is only one nations in the modern world that tried not having a hierarchy. It’s called Anarchy. It lasted a matter of months in Spain. No one took ownership, there was no direction and they were unable to gain ground because they were disorganized.

Funny enough the other direction didn’t work either. Fascism has never been sustainable either.
Karl Rohde 78

5 July 2008 at 6:19 pm

Oops…
Bill 79

5 July 2008 at 6:22 pm

“Co-operatives still need leader, leaders tend to work longer and have more responsibility.”

This is fundamentally untrue.

If one person has essential skills in a collective that no-one else possesses, then the collective is doomed. Apart from the resulting skewed social dynamics, what if that person dies? That is why collectives have a commitment to skill sharing.

Responsibility is collective and is easily maintained by a simple rule of thumb…Is what I am proposing to do going to impact on others?. If so, then I must communicate with those people and that collective determines whether the action goes ahead.

Your comment about Spain is also wrong. What about the swathes of industry and sections of community in Argentina, Venezuela and other South American countries being run autonomously? It is true that it may all come to an end at the point of a gun as in Spain.

But even then, there will remain the pockets of worker run enterprises and resident run housing collectives( not uncommon throughout Europe)…some with quite long histories. And that, in spite of an overwhelmingly hostile environment to such ideas and practices
Felix 80

5 July 2008 at 7:13 pm

jbc,

I think I see where you’re coming from.

I too found the original post a little clumsy in that all the examples were stated in negative which can easily lead to absurd conclusions, even when agreeing with the sentiment as you put it.
Karl Rohde 81

5 July 2008 at 7:47 pm

Hmmm… neither Argentina or Venezuela are anarchies. What is your point?

Your statement of co-ops indicates leadership is not necessary.

Fundamentally wrong.

I am talking about lack of leadership, not socialist ideals. Anarchism is the most extreme socialist position. Guess what… Libertarian is pretty close on the other side. Both wish the removal of state and leadership.

Co-Ops do need leadership, as does society and anything the produces or nurtures anything.

Co-Op A and Co-Op B both need 200 bushels of grain to survive the winter. Neither have reserves as last couple of seasons were bad. This year, winter looks to be early and harsh.

Co-Op A is based on consensus – they have no leadership, and make decision based on group decisions. Co-Op B has a leader, someone who was both accepted and willing to take the role.

The bottom line for both Co-Ops is they need food or they will not survive the winter.

I will keep you posted on which Co-Op survives the winter with the least attrition.

To have 10, 20, 200, 10,000 people working all to the same goal long term can only be achieved through leadership. Take away leadership and society is reduced to anarchy.

“If one person has essential skills in a collective that no-one else possesses, then the collective is doomed.”

This is fundamentally untrue. Everyone has skills that are unique. Some can read the weather, some are handy with a bow and can hunt, some can produce wonderful crafts for the betterment of all. Some of these skills can not be taught. A co-op needs diverse skills to survive. Everyone can’t know everything – and if you try, no one would survive. They need organization to achieve goals and make the most of their unique skills. That requires leadership.

Leadership can not be taught, you are either a leader or you are not. Without some form of leadership, society can not survive.
Draco TB 82

5 July 2008 at 8:37 pm

Capitalism in it’s purest form is not bad, in the same way as Socialism in it’s purest form is not bad.

IMO:
Capitalism in its purest form is one person owning everything. I’m pretty sure you can see how this would be bad. There certainly wouldn’t be any freedom.

Socialism in it’s purest form is everyone have having equal opportunity. This would, of course, bring about the greatest freedom as everyone would be able to choose what they want to do to produce value and have access to the resources and the support to do it. It falls down in that we live in a finite world with finite resources (Yes, this is also an argument against our present system).

Take away leadership and society is reduced to anarchy.

No it’s not – it’s reduced to democracy.
Bill 83

5 July 2008 at 8:44 pm

“Your statement of co-ops indicates leadership is not necessary.”

Nope. A leader is not necessary. Neither is a leader desirable. Leadership is not necessarily embodied within a single individual and is therefore different to talk of leaders.

” Anarchism is the most extreme socialist position. Guess what Libertarian is pretty close on the other side. Both wish the removal of state and leadership.”

Libertarian IS anarchism! Right Wing theories which appropriate the term libertarianism do not wish to see the removal of the state. The right wing wants to minimise the social aspects of the state (welfare and other programmes)and emphasise the controlling aspects (police, army etc). It’s the only way that free market ideology can survive….by means of oppression.

“To have 10, 20, 200, 10,000 people working all to the same goal long term can only be achieved through leadership. Take away leadership and society is reduced to anarchy.”

Everyone having the same goal? How horribly homogeneous and stunting. Authoritarianism writ large. Some broad goals will be naturally held in common…health, well being etc

But I think you misunderstand the fundamentals of anarchy. In pop culture it is equated with chaos; a nonsense. An anarchist society is the most highly organised and inclusive of all socio/political entities.

” A co-op needs diverse skills to survive. Everyone can’t know everything – and if you try, no one would survive. They need organization to achieve goals and make the most of their unique skills. That requires leadership.”

Absolutely agree with you here. And the ‘leadership of ideas’ and inclusion of individuals in decision processes ensures the organisational wherewithal. You do realise you are advocating anarchy?

“Leadership can not be taught, you are either a leader or you are not. Without some form of leadership, society can not survive.”

Oh dear. Then you lose it again by confounding leaders with leadership. But if the opposite of leadership is subservience and subservience can be overcome ( which it can), where does that leave your concept of leadership? Shared by all perhaps? So leadership, but not embodied within an individual leader. Welcome to the far left ;0)
Karl Rohde 84

5 July 2008 at 8:46 pm

Democracy is the authorized leadership of one or more individuals. Take away leadership and you have anarchy.
RedLogix 85

5 July 2008 at 8:53 pm

Alternatively Draco, you might want to consider democracy as a mechanism that allows the ordinary people the ability to hold leadership to account.

Besides the term leadership is a code word for political authority and power. There is nothing innately wrong with power. It is a tool. The question throughout history has been, to what purpose is power being used?

Is power being used for the benefit of the whole of society, to maximise opportunity for everyone, or just a privileged few at the top of the social hierarchy?

Is power being used wisely for achieve sustainable long-term goals, or is it being used for short-term gratifiation?

Is power being used to in the spirit of service and humility, or to further and agenda rooted in personal ambition and self-aggrandisation?

Is power being used openly and transparently, or are the real motives hidden and opaque?

Age old questions. Still worth asking.
Bill 86

5 July 2008 at 8:55 pm

Democracy is the right to have meaningful input in decisions that are likely to affect you. Leaders (authorised or otherwise)are the short path to Authoritarianism/ Totalitarianism. Take away leaders and you have a chance of meaningful democracy
Draco TB 87

5 July 2008 at 9:08 pm

Democracy is the authorized leadership of one or more individuals.

Government of the people, for the people, by the people. Doesn’t say anything about leaders.
The reality is that there are many forms of democracy. Our representative democracy is just one of those forms and not necessarily the best.

Take away leadership and you have anarchy.

After reading Bill’s posts I think I’ll go for the anarchy thanx. Anything that allows me to have responsibility for myself and my community instead of having some ‘leaders’ tell me what to do has got to be an improvement over the effective slavery that is the capitalist system.
Ari 88

5 July 2008 at 9:16 pm

“Freedom to drive the car you like.”
What’s stopping you, minimum safety standards? Labels that inform consumers about energy efficiency?

“Freedom to watch/read/listen material what you like.”
Actually, the Right tends to be a lot more keen on censorship than the Left, especially if it’s in the name of Community Decency and other trojan horses. I think this one ought to be an ideal aspired to by both.

“Freedom to Hire/Fire who you want if you own a business”
I notice the word fairly is missing before hire/fire. You do not have a right to make unfair business decisions that are not related to the merits of the people involved. You largely have the right to make strictly business-related decisions, but there’s some quality-of-life checks thrown in: You have to pay at least the minimum wage, you have to meet health and safety guidelines, you have to offer certain amounts of leave, and so on. I don’t think those are too much to ask.

“Freedom to speak out against the impact of manmade climate change

Freedom not to worry about your socalled global footprint”
Right, the freedom to be a hypocrite. Not one of my favourites- if you’re going to speak up about climate change, you need to do SOMETHING to reduce your contribution to it.

This is why the principle of opportunity is so important – if you have the “freedom” not to worry about your own global footprint, or resource use – then if you take more resources than the average amount available per person, you’re necessarily limiting someone else’s opportunity to use those resources. That’s hardly consistent with allowing people to achieve their own success. If we don’t end up using all of the world’s resources at exactly the rate they’ll replenish- so what? More for our kids.

“Freedom from higher taxes.”
Freedom from public services, too, apparently. 😉 If you’re a capitalist, you can’t both demand more performance from the State and less taxes, unless you want the entire Parliamentary term spent busting inefficiency- which trust me, is boring, and tends to axe or downsize valuable programs along with reducing waste.

“Freedom to make your own decisions and live by them”
I think this is a principle the Left and Right both agree with, even if their agreement doesn’t overlap very well. The Left tends to get this better on social issues, and when they don’t take a page from the right-libertarians, the Right tends to do okay on economic issues. Unfortunately, National is neo-liberal and Act is libertarian, so the party of economic freedom in New Zealand is actually a bit of a tie between the Progressives (who are the REAL centre party in New Zealand, fyi) and Labour.

“Freedom to say what you like, without the fear of some jackass getting offended”
…Protecting you from others being offended is not freedom of speech. Freedom of speech also includes the responsibility of coping with nonviolent opposition. It’s not the Government’s job to stop you from having to deal with the consequences of your actions.

Saying anyone who wants a little bit of individuality or niceties of life is greedy (which rave, your text strongly lends itself to) is very Protestant and completely unrealistic.

I would say individuality- and I don’t mean the consumerist type- is a need, not a want, for that very reason. I don’t mind niceties- so long as people are leaving enough for other people to try and get some, too. 🙂

The former requires enslaving others to provide one’s sustenance.

The latter simply requires that you each recognise the other’s moral space to pursue their own values.

Freedom requires equality. Equality requires equal access to the necessities of life. This necessitates the community working together to provide that to everyone. It’s not so much slavery as common decency. Either everyone is equally free, or nobody is free enough.

Not giving bread to a starving man when you have plenty is only slightly different to chaining him up and stopping him from eating.

I agree with freedom from being unemployed. A work for the dole scheme would do wonders for the work ethic of those on the benefit. They could be engaged in minor gardening duties, befriending and helping the elderly, painting over graffiti and other community orientated services which are currently lacking.

And excellent idea

Sure, I’m with you in principle, at least for those on benefits that aren’t designed for people who can’t work. While WINZ generally does a good job of trying to get people into work, I think they undervalue getting people some experience first in a few cases, and there are people who just have difficulty with formal employment that this could really help. Will we be paying them the minimum wage though now that we require them to work? 😉

Trying to get people to work for say, the sickness benefit would be laughable, and if you’re setting DPB mothers in your sights here, you should think again.

‘sod: you miss my point. Sure, most people supply labour to someone else. I do too. I also have a shareholding in my company and sign my own pay cheques. So am I capital or labour?

Sometimes “owning the means of production’ is as simple as buying a secondhand PC.

I think you’ll find a hell of a lot of people in NZ work for, or own, a small business. I don’t have the stats handy but I’m pretty sure that the employment landscape today isn’t quite the same as it was in the time of Das Kapital.

I’m not spouting propaganda, just speaking from my own encounters.

Let me put it this way- if you knew someone was going to take care of it, and you’d be able to get it back before you really needed it, would you lend them your hammer? That’s basically the premise of eliminating capital. Everyone should be able to get what they need to work- and that is actually FACILITATED by removing capital ownership- because when one person runs out of ways to use a tool, or a computer, or a factory, another person can start using it. Essentially, the idea is to destroy ownership, not destroy property- but for that to happen, you need an excess of property compared to your population. You need to be a sparsely populated society, or you need to be very resource efficient, or you need to take more than your fair share of resources. 1&3 are currently the only possible ways for that to work.

I certainly agree that stopping people from using hammers at all would be ridiculous. But that is a strawman, even in the case of the most extremist revolutionary communist.

Seems to me that the Marxist analysis of class misses out on one very important class; the managerial or co-ordinator class. These guys get well renumerated; do not own any means of production and essentially maintain the status quo that rewards them so well.

Yeah, I think so too. That said, there’s still room for managers in a Marxist society- it’s just nobody is contractually obliged to listen to them, so they have to be persuasive too, instead of merely getting the job done.
libertyscott 89

5 July 2008 at 9:51 pm

Bill said “but individualism is never positive and can too easily be entirely negative”

Of course not, indeed the high prophets of that view were never entirely negative were they? Take:
– Hitler
– Stalin
– Mao
– Pol Pot
– Kim Il Sung and Kim Jong Il
– Mussolini
– Lenin
– Ceausescu

If individuals have no rights then there are no rights. Morality has a rational basis in reality, in that individual freedom is fundamentally necessary for human beings to live, grow, flourish and realise their potential. The greatest real limit on this are the parasitical desires of others to take from them, to assault, threaten, murder and rape.

The freedoms talked about on this post ARE freedoms from reality – freedoms from the fact that if you want food, someone has to produce it, someone has to apply their minds to the resources they have to acquire or produce and distribute it.

Human beings cannot survive on instinct alone, they must use their brains to seek out, produce and trade for food, shelter, clothing, warmth and the like – the idea that we have a right to that, is the idea we have a right to not bother applying our brains and bodies to achieve those bogus “rights”.

After all, if everyone woke up tomorrow and decided not to go to work and demanded their rights to everything listed above, nothing would happen – everything would fall apart. However a society where rights consisted of everyone controlling their own bodies and property and being able to enforce contracts, torts and other basic rights surrounding the boundaries between the relationships of people – would simply be free for people to flourish and choose to do as they wish, whilst respecting the rights of others to do the same.

From that of course the benevolence of human beings can also flourish, with the compassion and generosity of those willing to give their time and money to help others.
Bill 90

5 July 2008 at 10:27 pm

libertyscott
your being an ass. From the comment where you chopped a segment of a sentence……..Freedom (if it is to mean anything at all beyond the exercise of power) must be negotiated and be accountable to the larger social context within which it exists.

So there goes your Pol Pot, Hitler, Lenin, Pinochet et al.

And ‘individualism’ too, which is inherently selfish and will not negotiate or be accountable. As soon as it does the results are individual freedoms:not ‘individualism’.

And one quick look at the world today is evidence enough that compassion and generosity are treated as liabilities not attributes that attract reward; they happen in spite of the world view you support, not because of.
Karl Rohde 91

5 July 2008 at 11:04 pm

“Government of the people, for the people, by the people.”

The Gettysburg Address was an interesting speech. Pity you show zero understanding of it and use it for your misguided personal mantra.

Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.

Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated, can long endure. We are met on a great battle-field of that war. We have come to dedicate a portion of that field, as a final resting place for those who here gave their lives that that nation might live. It is altogether fitting and proper that we should do this.

But, in a larger sense, we can not dedicate — we can not consecrate — we can not hallow — this ground. The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here. It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us — that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion — that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain — that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom — and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.

I am quite disgusted that you used it out of context.

A government by it’s very nature indicates leadership. The Gettysburg Address does not detract or exclude leadership, nor alienate the power of the people unless the people allow it to.

In fact, this was a founding statement for the powers of democracy, free speech and individual direction. It was a statement that slavery was not OK, that the right of all men (and women – that came later) were free to choose their own direction in life, and that the state or other individuals had little say in their life unless they chose to allow it.

The fact that you used this Draco TB, in your context, is somewhat insulting to all the men and women who have died fighting for freedom and democracy.

Without some form of leadership, elected by the people, you can not weather the storms, you can not have law, you can not have order, you can not put food on the table and you can not have a community who honors and respects each other.

Even the Bible and Koran teach this, even Buddhism teaches this.

The only two modern proponents of not having leadership are Libertarianism and Anarchism, and at face value Taoist beliefs.

The only reason Taoist fits this category is the belief that you act on what you have direct and immediate influence over and let everything else wash over you. Like the primo advert… go with the flow.

I don’t often get insulted, but Draco TB, you have actually managed it.

Abraham Lincoln for all his faults was a great leader, and died for it. Your misuse of his speech and his intent for his speech shows your complete ignorance.

And “anarchism” is as far left as you can get Bill… best check your research. In fact it goes almost full circle to the right, but it is definitely Left.

When I was in my late teens someone once told me that to learn, you need to forget everything you have been taught and learn how to learn.

It became obvious one time when I was 48 hours from bankruptcy. The mindset that there is only one way to do things is what holds back society and the individual.

We can label things left, right, middle, Christian, Islam, Hindi, Marxist, Stalinist, anarchist, libertarianism, Protestant or even Jedi. It makes no difference.

We have to look at what mistakes that have gone before and try to use what knowledge we have now. Focus on the individual’s strengths, and be aware of their weaknesses. Work on the betterment of the community and through that strengthen the community.

Until we get past our political and socio economic labels we can never be the best we can be while ensuring the community can be the best we can be.

The Gettysburg Address was solidarity against slavery, bastion of democratic leadership and you are now using it as an argument against leadership.

Shame on you I say.

Without leadership, strong leadership, America would be enslaved still, Europe would be under the Fascist regime and NZ and Australia would be speaking Japanese.

Leaders are powerful, but they can also be evil or misdirected. But their power is given by the people. It is the people who allow a corrupt leader, not a corrupt leader who takes advantage of the people.

Without leadership we would flounder, we would become disenfranchised. We would become the exact society that the people arguing against leadership seek to avoid.
ak 92

5 July 2008 at 11:40 pm

FREEDOM! LIBERTE! LIBRE! AMANDLA!

The ultimate, supercharged sound-bites of the ages – infused with and born of the suffering of countless millions oppressed for millenia – single words that resonate with terrifying power. The power of inspiration, ambition and deliverance from aeons of unspeakable misery: the unifying, clarion, rallying scream of last resort, assertion of humanity, and call to arms that has curdled the blood of the exploiting strata and their despotic enforcers forever.

Nice post Steve and you’re dead right – “FREEDOM!” not only belongs to the Left, it is its essential and abiding raison d’etre: for without an oppressor, “freedom” has no meaning. Without the despots, dictators, colonisers, tyrants, torturers, Trujillos, Montenegros, Pinochets and Sheriffs of Nottingham, there could be no mass aspiration for the incredible social progress and deliverance from misery that we enjoy today – from the grinding satanic mills to Hel’s genial kitsch-inn.

The Right recognise the power of the inevitable progression: power is, after all, their very own raison d’etre, and hence their earnest attempts at appropriation of the concept, most succinctly epitomised by the the early anti-abolitionists’ grotesque call for the “Freedom to use slaves”. So-called “Libertarianism” is merely the pitiful, moribund remnant of the same doomed and desperate attempted hi-jack of history’s most potent symbol.

I read somewhere today (opposable thumb blog) that Ryman Healthcare (Resthome moguls) had delivered to shareholders a billion dollars in 5 years, while their workers average $13/hr. And John Key has $50million in his silk pocket while 17,000 kids die of hunger every day. Plenty of freedoms to fight for yet brothers and sisters – who’s ya hero, Judas or Jesus?
Draco TB 93

6 July 2008 at 2:40 am

Without some form of leadership, elected by the people, you can not weather the storms, you can not have law, you can not have order, you can not put food on the table and you can not have a community who honors and respects each other.

Yes, actually, we can. We don’t need people to tell us what to do. All we need is the agreement to do it. Such agreement comes from community discussion and participation. That’s why it’s called participatory democracy.

The mindset that there is only one way to do things is what holds back society and the individual.

As you say, the mindset that there is only one way to do things is what holds us back. But it is this mindset that you’ve been spouting this entire thread. It’s also the mindset that was enforced several centuries ago, the mindset of kings and queens. Capitalism itself is just a small advance on it as it maintains the same hierarchical system as the aristocracy that it replaced. We’ve actually grown out of that paradigm, have been doing so for the last few centuries, and it needs to be replaced. We evolve and things change. Some people don’t like those changes though and try to stop them – they’re called conservatives.

Captcha: but Richmond – Yes, even Bill Gates has moved on.
Felix 94

6 July 2008 at 3:44 am

Without leadership, strong leadership, America would be enslaved still, Europe would be under the Fascist regime and NZ and Australia would be speaking Japanese.

Do I even need to point out the incredible dishonesty of this statement?

Really??
jbc 95

6 July 2008 at 4:28 am

Draco TB: you type your message on a capitalist computer while sitting in capitalist comfort.

I guess you can say for capitalism what Churchill said for democracy: “Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.”

Capitalism sucks, but everything else sucks more.

Capitalism is fundamentally about private property. It means that the fruits of your labour are yours to exchange for anything you deem to be of equal value agreed with the party that you wish to trade with. If you have only cows then you can exchange for fruit and vegetables at the market. Markets have existed for thousands of years and are a natural result of the concept of possessions and the desire to exchange them.

Capitalism has best captured the instincts of human nature to progress with positive reinforcement in whole populations.

All other schemes that have been tried on large populations have failed to feed themselves (without enforced labour). My own guess is that without capitalism the personal motivation is removed from a big part of the populace.

If you want to break it down into sins then I guess it is better to foster greed than sloth.

Sure, you can get a bunch of like-minded people together and share your efforts – but this is rather artificial. Try to make it work with a true cross-section of any population and I dare say the results would be not so harmonious. Eventually someone will want to push or bargain with the non-performers and dissenters. If they opt for bargaining then the seeds of capitalism are planted.
djp 96

6 July 2008 at 8:49 am

sorry steve, this sounds more like the communist manifesto then anything to do with freedom

you should read the US declaration of independence
RedLogix 97

6 July 2008 at 8:53 am

jbc,

So if your capitalism is so wonderful, how come it keeps failing?

Have you not noticed the spectacular crisis in the global fiscal machine?

Have you not noticed how resources are being stretched to the limit and prices are rising?

Have you not noticed that markets are dismal failures at delivering things like education, health and infrastructure?

Have you not noticed that capitalism while delivering a limited and variable degree of prosperity to the world, has concentrated much of it into the control of a very few uber-rich elite, an elite largely hidden and unnaccountable to the rest of us. (Fully half of the assets in the world are controlled by fewer than 100 people.)

Does this mean that I want to demolish all trading markets and impose rule by regulation? Of course not. It simply means that on their own the notions of private property and trading markets are effective and useful tools, but are not a whole and sufficient answer. This is why throughout history all political systems have sought to moderate the action of the markets by various means.Many such attempts have been failures in themselves. They have either distorted the markets, over regulated it, or been captured by vested interests in ways that have been counter-productive, but at the same time there is no such thing as a free market… markets are always limited and managed to meet the political imperatives of the day.

As I posted above; the real question is; what purposes are being served? Political power will always exist, it is a tool just as the market is. And like all tools it can be both used and misused.

The great paradox of ‘freedom’ is that it is not to be found in absolute personal liberty. Nor is it found in absolute collective sovereignty. Genuine, authentic freedom is rooted in moral equality, equity of opportunity and socially just outcomes.
Brett Dale 98

6 July 2008 at 9:40 am

Freedom’s just another word for “nothing left to lose”
Pascal's bookie 99

6 July 2008 at 9:47 am

djp

http://www.ushistory.org/Declaration/document/index.htm

Declaration Of Independence. Great enlightenment left wing document. (if you want to quibble about this remember that the left right dichotomy dates from that century, and is to do with a persons postion vis a vis reform of the monarchist system.)

Sod all in there about property rights, certainly as libertarians understand them. There is a little bit about taxes, but the problem they had was that the King was levying taxes without representation from the taxed. That was their gripe. He was not allowing his subjects representation or input into their governance. They were not opposed to taxes per se. Indeed they felt that the governemnts sole purpose is to promote and protect the well being of it’s citizens, and that the King was not doing this.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. â€” That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, â€” That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.

Nothing in there about absolute property rights. Governments have a duty to set conditions in society such as that all (or as many as possible) of the people are unrestricted in their pursuit of happiness. This could easily include Steve’s list. The founders of the US were very careful to talk about frameworks and goals, and leave policy detail to actual governments. They deliberatly established what today we would call a living document. One that lays out certain defining principles, the application of which will change as society changes.

What do you think they would think about, for example, the idea of a natural rate of unemployment that should be targetted by the government to prevent inflation? How does that square with the natural rights listed in the DOI?

The American founders were smart guys. they knew that property rights are a construct, that ideas about how those rights are constructed are utilitarian.

A claim of ownership is essentially a negative claim against another persons natural right to use the ‘property’. Justifiable in many cases on utilitarian grounds, or in many cases moral grounds, but to raise it up to an absolute right is stupid. That’s why no libertarian society has ever really been attempted. Unlike social democratic systems which developed in the 1930’s and have seen the biggest and most widespread explosion of wealth and health in human history. Yay social democracy!

I’m still waiting for all the Lib’s to run off and start their utopian little hideaway. I promise that if they do so, and if it works, and if those of us that are left behind all start to starve and atrophy because the great and the good have left us, then I will not only listen to their ranting egotistical blather, I will try not to laugh so much.

But they seem to more interested in whinging about things than actually doing stuff. So . meh.
Ari 100

6 July 2008 at 9:47 am

The freedoms talked about on this post ARE freedoms from reality – freedoms from the fact that if you want food, someone has to produce it, someone has to apply their minds to the resources they have to acquire or produce and distribute it.

… More like they’re based on the principle that the economy should provide what people need before it moves on to providing what people want.

Why should we have people speculating for millions of dollars when they could spare a just a few first and feed the hungry? How is not giving a really, really small portion of your income to make sure everyone has the basic necessities of life unfair? Don’t you think they have some responsibility to allow their fellow people the same opportunities they had- even if those people live in a different part of the world, or didn’t get the chance to make choices as well as the rich?

Without leadership, strong leadership, America would be enslaved still, Europe would be under the Fascist regime and NZ and Australia would be speaking Japanese.

Hah. Leadership is implied in a democratic model, sure, but it is never explicitely stated as a leadership of one, or that any authority actually leaves the people during democratic elections. Our Prime Ministers are the caretakers of our country, not its elite. They have had authority delegated to them to leave New Zealand in a better condition than they recieved it, or at least dampen the impact of any large problems that come up during their term.

I disagree that we necessarily need centralised leadership to thrive, however, and especially disagree with the concept a powerful central executive authority. Democracy generally functions best when the most local decision-maker practical executes the law. (although there are good reasons to centralise legalislative authority, especially in a country as small as New Zealand) Now, strong moral conviction, national-level goals, and persuasive representatives? Sure. But those don’t necessarily need to be united in one charismatic leader. In fact, many of the totalitarian dictators and autocrats whose damage has been infamous were charismatic leaders in the sense you seem to be proposing- familiar examples would be Adolf Hitler, Robert Mugabe and George W. Bush- all who started out by fixing similar “problems” for their country, but then refusing to let go of the power they had gained by doing so, and used their supporters to bully, intimidate, and oppress the rest of the population to different degrees. (note: Hitler was a totalitarian, Mugabe and Bush are merely autocrats. All three of them have various elements of (neo)facism in their politics, relying heavily on national identity, shared religion, shared enemies, external threats, etc… to justify their extreme power)

Just because someone has the power to wield your nation like a fist doesn’t necessarily make it the best course of action.
Richard Hurst 101

6 July 2008 at 10:23 am

I see there is some remarkable Left wing extremism appearing in the comments section here. Geez and people talk about the kiwiblog right….sigh.

“A claim of ownership is essentially a negative claim against another persons natural right to use the â€˜property’..”

So private property rights don’t exist! Yippy! Lets all become like Africa and Zimbabwe! Right I’m off to do some serious looting!
On the way I might set fire to the homes of some people less well off than myself because they’ve got no private property rights to stop me and I’m bigger and stronger than they are! Alright anarchy!

see ya!
higherstandard 102

6 July 2008 at 10:55 am

Ari

George W Bush, Adolf Hitler and Robert Mugabe …..totalitarian dictators and autocrats……. ?

While George is a turd I don’t quite think he’s in the same class as Adolf and Mad old Bob Mugabe.

Oh and RedLogix ….(Fully half of the assets in the world are controlled by fewer than 100 people.) got a link for that sounds fascinating.
Ari 103

6 July 2008 at 11:34 am

HS- Keeping prisoners without habeas corpus in defiance of the rules of the Geneva Convention, anti-socialist and nationalistic political tactics, wholesale violation of the constitution in favour of expansion of the president’s executive authority whenever it comes to fighting terrorism, the first president to actually “line-item veto” laws so that they can only be interpretted the way he wishes, and attempting to pass a law providing retroactive immunity for telecom companies that participating in his program of warrantless domestic spying?

I think that qualifies him as an autocrat who wants to centralise government control around the Presidency. Even if you disagree that he’s an autocrat in absolute terms, he is by far the closest that a modern democracy has gotten to an autocrat while still maintaining a democratic framework.

(fyi, this is one of the reasons that although I’m a Republican, I don’t support an executive presidency in any shape way or form)

edit: Oh, and Richard Hurst?

So private property rights don’t exist! Yippy! Lets all become like Africa and Zimbabwe! Right I’m off to do some serious looting!

I think there’s a happy medium where you can deal with the problems that come about from capital property rights without destroying the concept of ownership or property altogether. “How do you deal with property?” is one of those key questions for leftists, to the point where you can place someone’s left-wing ideology with remarkable accuracy by how they answer it. 🙂
Pascal's bookie 104

6 July 2008 at 12:10 pm

So private property rights don’t exist!

Never said that Dick. I said that property rights are constructed rights. That fairly directly impies that they exist. The point is that they are not rights that would exist without some form of government. They are not natural rights. If the only rights that we had were rights that we have by way of our nature, then life would be nasty brutish and short. Just as you allude to.

Our natural right to go around doing whatever the hell we feel like is constrained by a whole bunch of other constructed rights, both moral and legal. The benefit of these negative rights that constrain our natural rights is that our lives are less brutal nasty and short. These rights may or may not include property rights in some form or another.

Did you not read the sentence after the one you quoted:

“A claim of ownership is essentially a negative claim against another persons natural right to use the â€˜property’. Justifiable in many cases on utilitarian grounds, or in many cases moral grounds, but to raise it up to an absolute right is stupid. ”

You sure slayed that strawman but good though Dick.
Karl Rohde 105

6 July 2008 at 12:23 pm

Yes, actually, we can. We don’t need people to tell us what to do. All we need is the agreement to do it. Such agreement comes from community discussion and participation. That’s why it’s called participatory democracy.

Unfortunately the Co-Op who spent their time trying to decide on what to do about the shortage of food through their participatory democracy died.

The other Co-Op, while suffering great attrition survived the winter. They were able to focus resources, apply people’s specialist skills effectively. They also came across during their search for food a group of frozen bodies huddled around an extinguished fire that had run out of fuel (guess they were too busy talking on who should go out to get the wood).

Being pragmatic, the elected leader decided to ask the people what do with the bodies, and after a vote; they carved up some of the bodies and used them for an additional food supply to see out the rest of winter.

All we need is the agreement to do it.

In a crisis, you need leadership; it’s human nature. The alternative is anarchy.

Re: Felix
Do I even need to point out the incredible dishonesty of this statement?

Hmmm… so; how exactly would New Zealand have defended itself from an organized military force using participatory democracy?

By the time they sorted out what to do; they would have been running around like headless chooks as they were shot dead.

I’ll say it again; you need leadership so everyone is pulling the same way. By very nature we are individuals. We have different levels of skill, intelligence and aptitude. Some things can be taught; some are natural and can not be taught.

Without a cohesive common direction, nothing would ever get done; and you would have anarchy.

Anarchy is the furtherest left you can get; and it won’t work.
Pascal's bookie 106

6 July 2008 at 12:37 pm

Ari, good stuff re Bush.

One minor quibble about the ‘line-item-veto’ though. It’s actually worse than that. What Bush is doing is using ‘signing statements’ that he attaches to the legislation as he signs it into law. These statements say that the president will interpret the law in such a way as not to limit his behaviour, no matter what the law says.

If he was vetoing the relevent lines that would be one thing, but he is in fact signing the lines into law, and just saying that he won’t obey them. A claim essentially that the law does not apply to the President, err, monarch.

Did you see the stuff last week about the torture slides used for instructing gitmo staff? Lifted directly from a document detailing Chinese methods for eliciting false confessions, (though they changed the heading that said exactly that).
Details and links here

Yeehaa.
lprent 107

6 July 2008 at 12:41 pm

I see there is some remarkable Left wing extremism appearing in the comments section here.

We get the full spectrum. They just have to be prepared for argument rather than simply making assertions.
Felix 108

6 July 2008 at 1:20 pm

Ok Karl, just for you: The 3 brutal and oppressive regimes you alluded to all provide examples of very “strong leadership”. The incredible dishonesty of your position is that you seem to be willing to espouse the virtues of “strong leadership” when talking about their defeat but are (amazingly) unable to acknowledge the central and enabling role of “strong leadership” in their very establishment and flourishing.

Your story about the two co-ops is hilarious by the way. I’ve got another one for you:

Once upon a time there were three orange monkeys and three pink monkeys. Each monkey was given 2 bananas for lunch. What do you think happened at lunchtime? Let’s see!

Well, after lunchtime we see that the orange monkeys are happily resting in the shade, having eaten their bananas. The pink monkeys are still hungry because they threw their bananas at each other and wasted them!

What does this show? Not a fucking thing of course – just like your story, it’s just a bunch of shit someone made up. Do you think we’re all five years old and in sunday school?

I really, really hope your comments here are actually some kind of satire, cleverly poking fun at semi-retarded historically illiterate hard-of-thinking right wing idiots. If not they’re just very, very sad.
Swampy 109

6 July 2008 at 3:12 pm

The so called “freedoms” are very wishy washy and depend on taking away other freedoms that are much more important.

How about
– Freedom to send your children to any school you please without financial penalty.
– Freedom to receive healthcare from any provider without added cost.
– Freedom from anti competitive monopolistic behaviour by the government.
– Freedom to start up your own business without bureacrats imposing huge costs and form filling requirements.
jbc 110

6 July 2008 at 5:24 pm

RedLogix:
So if your capitalism is so wonderful, how come it keeps failing?

Notice I said capitalism sucks. It’s certainly not perfect.

Have you not noticed the spectacular crisis in the global fiscal machine?

Been watching and expecting it for years. I believe the worst is yet to come. What bugs me most is that the architects of the crisis and the conmen who profited from it are not the only ones who will suffer.

But it has not blinded me. I just hope that this time the lesson results in some changes. I wouldn’t bet on it though.

Like the drunk driver with 20 prior convictions – we still forgive them and give them their keys back in a few months…
Robinsod 111

6 July 2008 at 5:32 pm

Like the drunk driver with 20 prior convictions – we still forgive them and give them their keys back in a few months

Forgive??? We buy them a new car to replace the one they wrote off and then apologise for our families getting in the way of their swerving:

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=axlw8G3iaFLo&refer=home
Draco TB 112

6 July 2008 at 5:37 pm

Unfortunately the Co-Op who spent their time trying to decide on what to do about the shortage of food through their participatory democracy died.

What really happened went like this:

The democratic Co-op decided, during a meeting that took a single night, how many houses were needed to shelter the co-op and the food they would need. These needs were voluntarily met by those willing to do them. At the end of the meeting the Weather-Watcher stood up and said “I have been watching the winds and the clouds and believe that this winter will be long and hard and that we will need to put more stores aside to survive”. The co-op knew the Weather-Watcher – he could neither gather or build but he knew the weather and if he said that the winter would be long and hard then it would be best to listen to him. To this the gatherers said “It is simple enough to gather a little more grain each day but we will need somewhere to store it.” to which the builders replied that such storage would be built (Friendly competition between the builders resulted in two silos being built both of which the gatherers were more than happy to fill).

Over the long winter the democratic co-op most of their time singing Kum-baiya and drinking Wild Grain Mead (The surplus grain gathered had to be put to some use) in the town hall that the builders had built in their spare time while teaching some of the younger co-op members how to build. Not only was there no attrition but a couple of children were born which, everyone agreed, was a good excuse to drink more mead.

Near the end of the winter the gatherers cam across a small group that hadn’t weathered the winter so well. One of them, fatter and well clothed compared to the rest, called himself the ‘leader’ went on at some length about about what ‘he’ had done to keep ‘his’ group alive over winter. Most of which seemed to be getting someone else to do the actual work while he did nothing. The group, seeing how much better off the democratic group was, left the leader wholesale when offered a place. The leader, seeing the loss of his authority, left in a huff while mumbling something about loyalty, individualism and property rights.

Nobody really knows what became of this ‘leader’ although a few years later a rough camp in the woods with a single skeleton was found. Some of the items there were identified from people who were once part of the leaders group as belonging to the leader.
Bill 113

6 July 2008 at 6:01 pm

Best laugh this weekend Thankyou Draco ;0)
jbc 114

6 July 2008 at 6:02 pm

‘sod: wasn’t sure if you were writing literally or metaphorically there for a second… 🙂 Such is the state of things.

But yes, what you point to is what bugs me too. I can understand the rationale behind propping up retail banks/finance – but where to draw the line. I would not want to be anywhere near that mess.

Perhaps we’ll see more of this. If enough of them end up behind bars then… lessons learned.
Bill 115

6 July 2008 at 6:09 pm

BTW A wee thought for the ‘righties’. Since ‘individualism’ is all about the inalienable right of the individual to follow their own moral compass, how the hell is it that you all tend to want ‘lock em up and throw away the key’ solutions to crime?

In a world of ‘individualism’ there cannot logically be any crime. And if you are an aspiring ‘individualist’ in today’s world then you obviously cannot recognise crime…criminals are just being ‘individualists’ with an inalienable right to act as they do.

Any answers?
jbc 116

6 July 2008 at 8:55 pm

Well Bill, that’s some ‘individualist’ straw man you’ve drawn there. I can’t say I’ve heard anyone allude to anything resembling that.

The closest would be those who regard criminals as the real victims. But then the people that think this way are not individualists – quite the opposite.

I think if you want to draw the mythical ‘individualist’ stereotype a little more accurately then here are some pointers:

1. They believe they are individually responsible for their own actions – and should be held to account for them.
2. They believe in their own individual safety and that of others.
3. They believe in individual (personal) property.

So putting those together I guess that they consider actions against persons and property to be a crime is fairly logical. But then again; this is just a straw man. Set it alight if you wish.

In a world of â€˜individualism’ there cannot logically be any crime

Curious to know where that idea came from. Sounds pretty crackpot to me.
Karl Rohde 117

6 July 2008 at 10:34 pm

In political philosophy, the individualist theory of government holds that the state should take a merely defensive role by protecting the liberty of each individual to act as he or she wishes as long he or she does not infringe on the same liberty of another.

So criminals don’t fit this criteria. They, by there very nature, have breeched the very basis of individualist society.

Essentially a criminal is part of a counter-culture, which will always occur regardless of your social and political infrastructure.
Bill 118

6 July 2008 at 11:42 pm

JCB, it was stated by Peter…”It is this real freedom â€” the freedom to be oneself, to pursue one’s own ends, within one’s own moral space…”

ANyway, you say;
1. They believe they are individually responsible for their own actions – and should be held to account for them.

Held to account by who? Themselves, or society? Can’t be society since individualism denies the existence of society and therefore any role for it.

2. They believe in their own individual safety and that of others.

Believing in your safety can be a terrible delusion depending on the circumstances.

3. They believe in individual (personal) property.

Which in the real world has meant and means the right to lay claim to lands and resources. With, as history shows, the backing of state supplied armed force of course.

.
r0b 119

7 July 2008 at 1:41 am

Karl / Wikipedia: In political philosophy, the individualist theory of government holds that the state should take a merely defensive role by protecting the liberty of each individual to act as he or she wishes as long he or she does not infringe on the same liberty of another.

So Karl, when you steal intellectual property by quoting without attribution from Wikipedia, should the government take a defensive role and lock you up? Or does your law apply only to those that steal a loaf of bread…

Pity you didn’t carry on from Wikipedia – here’s what it says a bit later on: For example, individualists oppose democratic systems unless constitutional protections exist that do not allow individual liberty to be diminished by the interests of the majority. So can we take it from this that you oppose democracy in NZ Karl?
Ben R 120

7 July 2008 at 2:23 pm

“Why should we have people speculating for millions of dollars when they could spare a just a few first and feed the hungry?”

That is going to be increasingly difficult Ari as Sub-Saharan Africa’s population doubles or more to between 1.5 and 2 billion by 2050. Unless the Catholic Church changes their message, or aid agencies help improve education about contraception use, there are going to be more and more hungry..

“A parallel factor at work is fecundity, equal to or higher than 5 children per woman. This is two to three times higher as in the rest of the world, an important factor being that four out of five African women live in countries where there is little access to contraception. Indeed less than 20% of women use modern contraceptive methods, as against 60% or more in Latin America and Asia. The fact that the use of contraception is progressing very slowly contributes to the strong population growth…

The prime effect of this exceptional, continuing population growth in Sub-Saharan Africa is its role as a major handicap to economic and social development of most of the region’s countries. The conclusion from the research is that if the African nations want to take up the double challenge of their demographic transition and reduction of their poverty, development policies must be completely rethought. It is by the adoption and implementation of policies hinged on combined actionsinvolving education, prevention of mortality, equitable access to health care and to family planningthat changes bringing advances and improved living standards could be generated in Sub-Saharan Africa.”

http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2008-01/idrp-sat010808.php
Richard Hurst 121

8 July 2008 at 1:15 pm

From reading the explanations and backtracking that Ari (and PB?) have done I assume they both accept private property rights DO exist. Well there’s a relief!
Damn, now I’m going to have to return all that stuff I looted yesterday! Bugger I’ll have to pay for those houses I burnt down as well and go to court.
Why? Because absolute private property rights for everyone are real and are the plank on which our civilization functions and survives.

Absolute private property rights protect people in law from having their rights abused by others, whether that’s individuals acting alone against someone else, or the ‘group’ in the grip of a charismatic megalomaniac leader or collectivist ideology who wants to destroy the private property rights of selected individuals.
What’s yours is not mine, and mine isn’t yours unless I want to voluntary help you/me, we have exchanged value for value or I have agreed that contributing some my property to the ‘group’ in some way helps me.
E.g. Tax used to pay for roads or the education of others kids etc. The trick with that is striking the balance via the democratic system and the freedom to be left alone by the â€˜group’ as much as is practically possible or as much as an individual wishes.

Oh.. have to stop the police have arrived to arrest me for my previous looting etc. I was planning on using the comments on this blog as my defense, but since you’ve made clear property rights exists I’m buggered now 🙂
Pascal's bookie 122

8 July 2008 at 4:03 pm

Richard. Fair enough.

We appear to agree about the utility of property rights (why it’s useful to have them), and the fact that they are rights defined by law, and constructed through a political process.

We probably disagree about what sort of property rights a society should ideally construct. Probably not by much, given the range of options that have been tried throughout history (stalinism, tribalism, monarchism, feudalsim, fascism, unbridled capitalism, capitalism with some bridles on, etc).

But that’s ok, it’s a different discussion.

I think some confusion may have arisen, seeing you accused me of not believing that property rights exist.

1/ ‘absolutely having private property rights’. True in any society that I think think of, (though how those rights are defined obviously varies).

and

2/ ‘having absolute private property rights’. Not sure what this would mean. If I own a gun I can do whatever I like with it?

No need to apologise for accusing me of backtracking, (if that’s what you did?).

If you need a witness at court, just ask. 😉

Comments are now closed

Articles RSS

CommentsOpinions

FeedsPartyGovtMedia

Dance Magic

Well, I've been there, sitting in that same chairWhispering that same prayer half a million timesIt's a lie, though buried in disciplesOne page of the Bible isn't worth a lifeThere's nothing wrong with youIt's true, it's trueThere's something wrong with the villageWith the villageSomething wrong with the villageSongwriters: Andrew Jackson ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

8 hours ago
Government Forces Universities to Enforce “Free Speech” While Limiting Universities&#821...

ACT would like to dictate what universities can and can’t say. We knew it was coming. It was outlined in the coalition agreement and has become part of Seymour’s strategy of “emphasising public funding” to prevent people from opposing him and his views—something he also uses to try and de-platform ...

Sapphi’s SubstackBy Sapphi

9 hours ago
Fact brief – Are we heading into an ‘ice age’?

Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park from the Gigafact team in collaboration with members from our team. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Are we heading ...

Skeptical Science

21 hours ago
As Our Power Lessens: Published

So the Solstice has arrived – Summer in this part of the world, Winter for the Northern Hemisphere. And with it, the publication my new Norse dark-fantasy piece, As Our Power Lessens at Eternal Haunted Summer: https://eternalhauntedsummer.com/issues/winter-solstice-2024/as-our-power-lessens/ As previously noted, this one is very ‘wyrd’, and Northern Theory of Courage. ...

A Phuulish FellowBy strda221

1 day ago
By Any Other Name.

The Natural Choice: As a starter for ten percent of the Party Vote, “saving the planet” is a very respectable objective. Young voters, in particular, raised on the dire (if unheeded) warnings of climate scientists, and the irrefutable evidence of devastating weather events linked to global warming, vote Green. After ...

Bowalley Road

1 day ago
Bernard’s last Saturday Soliloquy for 2024

The Government cancelled 60% of Kāinga Ora’s new builds next year, even though the land for them was already bought, the consents were consented and there are builders unemployed all over the place. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāMōrena. Long stories short, the six things that mattered in Aotearoa’s political ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

1 day ago
Bernard’s Picks ‘n’ Mixes for Saturday, December 21

Photo by CHUTTERSNAP on UnsplashEvery morning I get up at 3am to go around the traps of news sites in Aotearoa and globally. I pick out the top ones from my point of view and have been putting them into my Dawn Chorus email, which goes out with a podcast. ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

1 day ago
2024 OIA stats

Over on Kikorangi Newsroom's Marc Daalder has published his annual OIA stats. So I thought I'd do mine: 82 OIA requests sent in 2024 7 posts based on those requests 20 average working days to receive a response Ministry of Justice was my most-requested entity, ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

2 days ago
Climate Change: A perverse incentive

The government published its first Biennial Transparency Report under the Paris Agreement yesterday, and the media has correctly noted that it is missing any plan to actually meet our target. While it hypes domestic emissions reductions so far - which have been good, but will likely get worse thanks to ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

2 days ago
Economic Bulletin December 2024

Welcome to the December 2024 Economic Bulletin. We have two monthly features in this edition. In the first, we discuss what the Half Year Economic and Fiscal Update from Treasury and the Budget Policy Statement from the Minister of Finance tell us about the fiscal position and what to ...

NZCTUBy Jack McDonald

2 days ago
NZCTU make submission in opposition to Treaty Principles Bill

The NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi have submitted against the controversial Treaty Principles Bill, slamming the Bill as a breach of Te Tiriti o Waitangi and an attack on tino rangatiratanga and the collective rights of Tangata Whenua. “This Bill seeks to legislate for Te Tiriti o Waitangi principles that are ...

NZCTUBy Jack McDonald

2 days ago
ZB’s Power Couple

I don't knowHow to say what's got to be saidI don't know if it's black or whiteThere's others see it redI don't get the answers rightI'll leave that to youIs this love out of fashionOr is it the time of yearAre these words distraction?To the words you want to hearSongwriters: ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

2 days ago
Austerity thumps GDP most since 1991

Our economy has experienced its worst recession since 1991. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāMōrena. Long stories short, the six things that matter in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Friday, December 20 in The Kākā’s Dawn Chorus podcast above and the daily Pick ‘n’ Mix below ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

2 days ago
Weekly Roundup 20-December-2024

Twas the Friday before Christmas and all through the week we’ve been collecting stories for our final roundup of the year. As we start to wind down for the year we hope you all have a safe and happy Christmas and new year. If you’re travelling please be safe on ...

Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland

2 days ago
The Hoon around the year to December 20, 2024

The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the year’s news with: on climate. Her book of the year was Tim Winton’s cli-fi novel Juice and she also mentioned Mike Joy’s memoir The Fight for Fresh Water. ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

3 days ago
The baby-boomers’ last gasp

The Government can head off to the holidays, entitled to assure itself that it has done more or less what it said it would do. The campaign last year promised to “get New Zealand back on track.” When you look at the basic promises—to trim back Government expenditure, toughen up ...

PolitikBy Richard Harman

3 days ago
Skeptical Science New Research for Week #51 2024

Open access notables An intensification of surface Earth’s energy imbalance since the late 20th century, Li et al., Communications Earth & Environment: Tracking the energy balance of the Earth system is a key method for studying the contribution of human activities to climate change. However, accurately estimating the surface energy balance ...

Skeptical Science

3 days ago
Join us at 5pm for 2024’s last Hoon

Photo by Mauricio Fanfa on UnsplashKia oraCome and join us for our weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar with paying subscribers to The Kākā for an hour at 5 pm today.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream for our chat about the week’s news with myself , plus regular guests and , ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

3 days ago
Christmas Gifts: Ageing Boomers, Laurie & Les, Talk Politics.

“Like you said, I’m an unreconstructed socialist. Everybody deserves to get something for Christmas.”“ONE OF THOSE had better be for me!” Hannah grinned, fascinated, as Laurie made his way, gingerly, to the bar, his arms full of gift-wrapped packages.“Of course!”, beamed Laurie. Depositing his armful on the bar-top and selecting ...

Bowalley Road

3 days ago
GDP Figures No Christmas Present for New Zealand

Data released by Statistics New Zealand today showed a significant slowdown in the economy over the past six months, with GDP falling by 1% in September, and 1.1% in June said CTU Economist Craig Renney. “The data shows that the size of the economy in GDP terms is now smaller ...

NZCTUBy Stella Whitfield

3 days ago
Cheeseburgers and Stunt Monkeys

One last thing before I quitI never wanted any moreThan I could fit into my headI still remember every single word you saidAnd all the shit that somehow came along with itStill, there's one thing that comforts meSince I was always caged and now I'm freeSongwriters: David Grohl / Georg ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

3 days ago
MSD rejecting 220 pleas for food grants each day

Sparse offerings outside a Te Kauwhata church. Meanwhile, the Government is cutting spending in ways that make thousands of hungry children even hungrier, while also cutting funding for the charities that help them. It’s also doing that while winding back new building of affordable housing that would allow parents to ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

3 days ago
The Wing Parties’ Economic Policies.

It is difficult to make sense of the Luxon Coalition Government’s economic management.This end-of-year review about the state of economic management – the state of the economy was last week – is not going to cover the National Party contribution. Frankly, like every other careful observer, I cannot make up ...

PunditBy Brian Easton

3 days ago
Back on Track

This morning I awoke to the lovely news that we are firmly back on track, that is if the scale was reversed.NZ ranks low in global economic comparisonsNew Zealand's economy has been ranked 33rd out of 37 in an international comparison of which have done best in 2024.Economies were ranked ...

Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tūī

3 days ago
Book Review: How Big Things Get Done

This is a guest post by George Weeks, reviewing a book called How Big Things Get Done by Bent Flyvbjerg and Dan Gardner Want to know how to do something big? Ask someone who has done it before! Professor Bent Flyvbjerg has spent his career studying megaprojects. In 2023, ...

Greater AucklandBy Guest Post

3 days ago
Gordon Campbell On Why We Can’t Survive Two More Years Of This

Remember those silent movies where the heroine is tied to the railway tracks or going over the waterfall in a barrel? Finance Minister Nicola Willis seems intent on portraying herself as that damsel in distress. According to Willis, this country’s current economic problems have all been caused by the spending ...

WerewolfBy ScoopEditor

4 days ago
Dragging our way towards the finish line, the end of this year can’t come soon enough for many…

Similar to the cuts and the austerity drive imposed by Ruth Richardson in the 1990’s, an era which to all intents and purposes we’ve largely fiddled around the edges with fixing in the time since – over, to be fair, several administrations – whilst trying our best it seems to ...

exhALANtBy exhalantblog

4 days ago
Handling Democracy.

String-Pulling in the Dark: For the democratic process to be meaningful it must also be public. WITH TRUST AND CONFIDENCE in New Zealand’s politicians and journalists steadily declining, restoring those virtues poses a daunting challenge. Just how daunting is made clear by comparing the way politicians and journalists treated New Zealanders ...

Bowalley Road

4 days ago
Open letter to the Minister of Dwindling Finances

Dear Nicola Willis, thank you for letting us know in so many words that the swingeing austerity hasn't worked.By in so many words I mean the bit where you said, Here is a sea of red ink in which we are drowning after twelve months of savage cost cutting and ...

More Than A FeildingBy David Slack

4 days ago
Open Government: The joke ends

The Open Government Partnership is a multilateral organisation committed to advancing open government. Countries which join are supposed to co-create regular action plans with civil society, committing to making verifiable improvements in transparency, accountability, participation, or technology and innovation for the above. And they're held to account through an Independent ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

4 days ago
An unusual sort of press conference

Today I tuned into something strange: a press conference that didn’t make my stomach churn or the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end. Which was strange, because it was about the torture of children. It was the announcement by Erica Stanford — on her own, unusually ...

Sapphi’s SubstackBy Sapphi

4 days ago
This substack has talked about this government’s seeming corruption & pro-corporate issues...

This is a must watch, and puts on brilliant and practical display the implications and mechanics of fast-track law corruption and weakness.CLICK HERE: LINK TO WATCH VIDEO Our news media as it is set up is simply not equipped to deal with the brazen disinformation and corruption under this right wing ...

Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tūī

4 days ago
NZCTU: Minister needs to listen to the evidence on engineered stone ban

NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi Acting Secretary Erin Polaczuk is welcoming the announcement from Minister of Workplace Relations and Safety Brooke van Velden that she is opening consultation on engineered stone and is calling on her to listen to the evidence and implement a total ban of the product. “We need ...

NZCTUBy Stella Whitfield

4 days ago
Wednesday 18 December

The Government has announced a 1.5% increase in the minimum wage from 1 April 2025, well below forecast inflation of 2.5%. Unions have reacted strongly and denounced it as a real terms cut. PSA and the CTU are opposing a new round of staff cuts at WorkSafe, which they say ...

NZCTUBy Jack McDonald

4 days ago
Can the government change its mind on the ferries?

The decision to unilaterally repudiate the contract for new Cook Strait ferries is beginning to look like one of the stupidest decisions a New Zealand government ever made. While cancelling the ferries and their associated port infrastructure may have made this year's books look good, it means higher costs later, ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

4 days ago
Notes from Afar: Will Luxon Attend Waitangi Day? And Opposition Calls Out Nicola Willis for “C...

Hi there! I’ve been overseas recently, looking after a situation with a family member. So apologies if there any less than focused posts! Vanuatu has just had a significant 7.3 earthquake. Two MFAT staff are unaccounted for with local fatalities.It’s always sad to hear of such things happening.I think of ...

Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tūī

4 days ago
Member’s morning

Today is a special member's morning, scheduled to make up for the government's theft of member's days throughout the year. First up was the first reading of Greg Fleming's Crimes (Increased Penalties for Slavery Offences) Amendment Bill, which was passed unanimously. Currently the House is debating the third reading of ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

4 days ago
Going Backwards

We're going backwardsIgnoring the realitiesGoing backwardsAre you counting all the casualties?We are not there yetWhere we need to beWe are still in debtTo our insanitiesSongwriter: Martin Gore Read more ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

4 days ago
Blaming Treasury & Labour, Willis looks for even more Austerity

Willis blamed Treasury for changing its productivity assumptions and Labour’s spending increases since Covid for the worsening Budget outlook. Photo: Getty ImagesMōrena. Long stories short, the six things that matter in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, December 18 in The Kākā’s Dawn Chorus podcast above ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

4 days ago
December-24 AT Board Meeting

Today the Auckland Transport board meet for the last time this year. For those interested (and with time to spare), you can follow along via this MS Teams link from 10am. I’ve taken a quick look through the agenda items to see what I think the most interesting aspects are. ...

Greater AucklandBy Matt L

4 days ago
The Making of a Mental Health Rockstar

Hi,If you’re a New Zealander — you know who Mike King is. He is the face of New Zealand’s battle against mental health problems. He can be loud and brash. He raises, and is entrusted with, a lot of cash. Last year his “I Am Hope” charity reported a revenue ...

David FarrierBy David Farrier

4 days ago
It could have been worse

Probably about the only consolation available from yesterday’s unveiling of the Half-Yearly Economic and Fiscal Update (HYEFU) is that it could have been worse. Though Finance Minister Nicola Willis has tightened the screws on future government spending, she has resisted the calls from hard-line academics, fiscal purists and fiscal hawks ...

PolitikBy Richard Harman

5 days ago
The Deep Divisions of Local Government

The right have a stupid saying that is only occasionally true:When is democracy not democracy? When it hasn’t been voted on.While not true in regards to branches of government such as the judiciary, it’s a philosophy that probably should apply to recently-elected local government councillors. Nevertheless, this concept seemed to ...

Sapphi’s SubstackBy Sapphi

5 days ago
Willis’ austerity strategy just isn’t working

Long story short: the Government’s austerity policy has driven the economy into a deeper and longer recession that means it will have to borrow $20 billion more over the next four years than it expected just six months ago. Treasury’s latest forecasts show the National-ACT-NZ First Government’s fiscal strategy of ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

5 days ago
Sabin 33 #7 – Are solar projects hurting farmers and rural communities?

On November 1, 2024 we announced the publication of 33 rebuttals based on the report "Rebutting 33 False Claims About Solar, Wind, and Electric Vehicles" written by Matthew Eisenson, Jacob Elkin, Andy Fitch, Matthew Ard, Kaya Sittinger & Samuel Lavine and published by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia ...

Skeptical Science

5 days ago
Join us for a pop-up Hoon at 5pm on HYEFU

Come and join myself and CTU Chief Economist for a pop-up ‘Hoon’ webinar on the Government’s Half Yearly Economic and Fiscal Update (HYEFU) with paying subscribers to The Kākā for 30 minutes at 5 pm today.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream to watch our chat. Don’t worry if ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

5 days ago
‘Ideas Worth Saving’: A Call for Papers

Some years ago, I found myself pondering the power of literature to endure. Or at least the power of some of it to endure, while the rest vanishes in mere decades: https://phuulishfellow.wordpress.com/2019/08/07/look-on-my-works-ye-mighty-and-despair-the-literary-future/. I have similarly had fun with the subject in some of my short stories, such as Another Alexandria ...

A Phuulish FellowBy strda221

5 days ago
Corrections is torturing prisoners again

In 1998, in the wake of the Paremoremo Prison riot, the Department of Corrections established the "Behaviour Management Regime". Prisoners were locked in their cells for 22 or 23 hours a day, with no fresh air, no exercise, no social contact, no entertainment, and in some cases no clothes and ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

5 days ago
HYEFU and BPS data shows New Zealand is way off track

New data released by the Treasury shows that the economic policies of this Government have made things worse in the year since they took office, said NZCTU Economist Craig Renney. “Our fiscal indicators are all heading in the wrong direction – with higher levels of debt, a higher deficit, and ...

NZCTUBy Jack McDonald

5 days ago
“Better economic management”

At the 2023 election, National basically ran on a platform of being better economic managers. So how'd that turn out for us? In just one year, they've fucked us for two full political terms: The government's books are set to remain deeply in the red for the near term ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

5 days ago
Shameless, clueless

AUSTERITYText within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedMy spreadsheet insists This pain leads straight to glory (File not found) Read more ...

More Than A FeildingBy David Slack

5 days ago
Minimum wage ‘increase’ is an effective cut

The NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi are saying that the Government should do the right thing and deliver minimum wage increases that don’t see workers fall further behind, in response to today’s announcement that the minimum wage will only be increased by 1.5%, well short of forecast inflation. “With inflation forecast ...

NZCTUBy Jack McDonald

5 days ago
Crazy ’bout a Sharp-dressed Man

Oh, I weptFor daysFilled my eyesWith silly tearsOh, yeaBut I don'tCare no moreI don't care ifMy eyes get soreSongwriters: Paul Rodgers / Paul Kossoff. Read more ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

5 days ago
How much should you worry about a collapse of the Atlantic conveyor belt?

This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Bob Henson In this aerial view, fingers of meltwater flow from the melting Isunnguata Sermia glacier descending from the Greenland Ice Sheet on July 11, 2024, near Kangerlussuaq, Greenland. According to the Programme for Monitoring of the Greenland Ice Sheet (PROMICE), the ...

Skeptical Science

5 days ago
8% ACT Party Creates One Ring To Rule Them All

In August, I wrote an article about David Seymour 1 with a video of his testimony, to warn that there were grave dangers to his Ministry of Regulation:David Seymour's Ministry of Slush Hides Far Greater RisksWhy Seymour's exorbitant waste of taxpayers' money could be the least of concernThe money for Seymour ...

Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tūī

5 days ago
When austerity worsens public debt & cuts GDP

Willis is expected to have to reveal the bitter fiscal fruits of her austerity strategy in the HYEFU later today. Photo: Lynn Grieveson/TheKakaMōrena. Long stories short, the six things that matter in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Tuesday, December 17 in The Kākā’s Dawn Chorus podcast ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

5 days ago
Govt to double number of toll roads

On Friday the government announced it would double the number of toll roads in New Zealand as well as make a few other changes to how toll roads are used in the country. The real issue though is not that tolling is being used but the suggestion it will make ...

Greater AucklandBy Matt L

5 days ago
Luxon’s pre-emptive strike

The Prime Minister yesterday engaged in what looked like a pre-emptive strike designed to counter what is likely to be a series of depressing economic statistics expected before the end of the week. He opened his weekly post-Cabinet press conference with a recitation of the Government’s achievements. “It certainly has ...

PolitikBy Richard Harman

6 days ago
Gordon Campbell On The Coalition’s Empty Gestures, And Abortion Refusal As The New Slavery

This whooping cough story from south Auckland is a good example of the coalition government’s approach to social need – spend money on urging people to get vaccinated but only after you’ve cut the funding to where they could get vaccinated. This has been the case all year with public ...

WerewolfBy ScoopEditor

6 days ago
More public service contempt of parliament

Back in 2023 the New Zealand Council for Civil Liberties raised concerns about the inherent conflict of interest involved in public service agencies supporting parliamentary select committees. Our parliament is run on a shoestring, so depends on the public service for advice. But public service agencies work for Ministers, not ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

6 days ago
If There Is A God

And if there is a GodI know he likes to rockHe likes his loud guitarsHis spiders from MarsAnd if there is a GodI know he's watching meHe likes what he seesBut there's trouble on the breezeSongwriter: William Patrick Corgan Read more ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

6 days ago
A Lipstick Government

Here’s a quick round up of today’s political news:1. MORE FOOD BANKS, CHARITIES, DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTERS AND YOUTH SOCIAL SERVICES SET TO CLOSE OR SCALE BACK AROUND THE COUNTRY AS GOVT CUTS FUNDINGSome of Auckland's largest foodbanks are warning they may need to close or significantly reduce food parcels after ...

Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tūī

6 days ago
NZCTU open letter to Treasury on undue restrictions on restricted briefings

Iain Rennie, CNZMSecretary and Chief Executive to the TreasuryDear Secretary, Undue restrictions on restricted briefings This week, the Treasury barred representatives from four organisations, including the New Zealand Council of Trade Unions Te Kauae Kaimahi, from attending the restricted briefing for the Half-Year Economic and Fiscal Update. We had been ...

NZCTUBy Jack McDonald

6 days ago
Why you won’t hear me advocate for electric cars

This is a guest post by Tim Adriaansen, a community, climate, and accessibility advocate. I won’t shut up about climate breakdown, and whenever possible I try to shift the focus of a climate conversation towards solutions. But you’ll almost never hear me give more than a passing nod to ...

Greater AucklandBy Guest Post

6 days ago
Coalition forced to back down on tolling Pahiatua track

A grassroots backlash has forced a backdown from Brown, but he is still eyeing up plenty of tolls for other new roads. And the pressure is on Willis to ramp up the Government’s austerity strategy. Photo: Getty ImagesMōrena. Long stories short, the six things that matter in Aotearoa’s political economy ...

The KakaBy Bernard Hickey

6 days ago
Thank You

Hi all,I'm pretty overwhelmed by all your messages and emails today; thank you so very much.As much as my newsletter this morning was about money, and we all need to earn money, it was mostly about world domination if I'm honest. 😉I really hate what’s happening to our country, and ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

7 days ago
2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #50

A listing of 23 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, December 8, 2024 thru Sat, December 14, 2024. Listing by Category Like last week's summary this one contains the list of articles twice: based on categories and based on ...

Skeptical Science

7 days ago
Making Gravy

I started writing this morning about Hobson’s Pledge, examining the claims they and their supporters make, basically ripping into them. But I kept getting notifications coming through, and not good ones.Each time I looked up, there was another un-subscription message, and I felt a bit sicker at the thought of ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

1 week ago
Nothing here but the shadows

Once, long before there was Harry and Meghan and Dodi and all those episodes of The Crown, they came to spend some time with us, Charles and Diana. Was there anyone in the world more glamorous than the Princess of Wales?Dazzled as everyone was by their company, the leader of ...

More Than A FeildingBy David Slack

1 week ago
The United Right: the FSU’s Continued Efforts to Undermine Academia

The collective right have a problem.The entire foundation for their world view is antiscientific. Their preferred economic strategies have been disproven. Their whole neoliberal model faces accusations of corporate corruption and worsening inequality. Climate change not only definitely exists, its rapid progression demands an immediate and expensive response in order ...

Sapphi’s SubstackBy Sapphi

1 week ago
Showing the Americans how to do it

Just ten days ago, South Korea's president attempted a self-coup, declaring martial law and attempting to have opposition MPs murdered or arrested in an effort to seize unconstrained power. The attempt was rapidly defeated by the national assembly voting it down and the people flooding the streets to defend democracy. ...

No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant

1 week ago
2 Men, 1 Haircut

Hi,“What I love about New Zealanders is that sometimes you use these expressions that as Americans we have no idea what those things mean!"I am watching a 30-something year old American ramble on about how different New Zealanders are to Americans. It’s his podcast, and this man is doing a ...

David FarrierBy David Farrier

1 week ago
Chris Penk’s Hate Parade

What Chris Penk has granted holocaust-denier and equal-opportunity-bigot Candace Owens is not “freedom of speech”. It’s not even really freedom of movement, though that technically is the right she has been granted. What he has given her is permission to perform. Freedom of SpeechIn New Zealand, the right to freedom ...

Sapphi’s SubstackBy Sapphi

1 week ago
Tell me a story

All those tears on your cheeksJust like deja vu flow nowWhen grandmother speaksSo tell me a story (I'll tell you a story)Spell it out, I can't hear (What do you want to hear?)Why you wear black in the morning?Why there's smoke in the air? Songwriter: Greg Johnson.Mōrena all ☀️Something a ...

Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel

1 week ago
As Our Power Lessens: Accepted

2024 is now officially my best-ever year for short stories. My 1,850-word dark fantasy piece, As Our Power Lessens, has been accepted for the upcoming solstice edition of Eternal Haunted Summer (https://eternalhauntedsummer.com/), thereby making that six published short stories for the calendar year. As always, see the Bibliography page for ...

A Phuulish FellowBy strda221

1 week ago

National’s Greatest Misses 2023-4

National has only been in power for a year, but everywhere you look, its choices are taking New Zealand a long way backwards. In no particular order, here are the National Government's Top 50 Greatest Misses of its first year in power. ...

Labour Blog

2 days ago
Release: Minister’s plan for tertiary sector a backwards step

Returning to the model that was failing for most polytechnics and Institutes of Technology is not the answer. ...

Labour Blog

2 days ago
Release: National buries 1019 planned homes

It’s been revealed that National has cancelled 60 percent of its housing projects planned before mid-2025 amidst housing woes. ...

Labour Blog

2 days ago
Release: Rule-Czar bill a right-wing power grab

The Government is quietly undertaking consultation on the dangerous Regulatory Standards Bill over the Christmas period to avoid too much attention. ...

Labour Blog

2 days ago
Release: Why not both? Luxon shuns Waitangi celebrations

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon is running away from problems of his own creation, with his decision not to go to Waitangi. ...

Labour Blog

3 days ago
Govt’s ‘free speech’ legislation stokes fear, not freedom

The Government’s planned changes to the freedom of speech obligations of universities is little more than a front for stoking the political fires of disinformation and fear, placing teachers and students in the crosshairs. ...

Greens

3 days ago
Release: Nicola Willis spirals country deeper into recession

The economy shrank 1% this quarter and New Zealand has tumbled into the depths of a recession of Nicola Willis’ making. ...

Labour Blog

3 days ago
Release: Hikes for company directors but not ordinary Kiwis

Working people are going backwards while company directors are being given huge pay hikes. ...

Labour Blog

4 days ago
ECE no place to cut corners

The Ministry of Regulation’s report into Early Childhood Education (ECE) in Aotearoa raises serious concerns about the possibility of lowering qualification requirements, undermining quality and risking worse outcomes for tamariki, whānau, and kaiako. ...

Greens

4 days ago
Release: Strengthening Justice Services for New Zealanders

A Bill to modernise the role of Justices of the Peace (JP), ensuring they remain active in their communities and connected with other JPs, has been put into the ballot. ...

Labour Blog

4 days ago
Release: Labour will continue fight against destructive projects

Labour will continue to fight unsustainable and destructive projects that are able to leap-frog environment protection under National’s Fast-track Approvals Bill. ...

Labour Blog

5 days ago
Green Government will revoke dodgy fast-track projects

The Green Party has warned that a Green Government will revoke the consents of companies who override environmental protections as part of Fast-Track legislation being passed today. ...

Greens

5 days ago
Government for the wealthy keeps pushing austerity

The Green Party says the Half Year Economic and Fiscal Update shows how the Government is failing to address the massive social and infrastructure deficits our country faces. ...

Greens

5 days ago
Release: Visa changes let migrant workers be paid less

The Government’s latest move to reduce the earnings of migrant workers will not only hurt migrants but it will drive down the wages of Kiwi workers. ...

Labour Blog

5 days ago
Release: Nightmare before Christmas for Nicola Willis

With more debt and a larger deficit, Nicola Willis’ reputation is in tatters after her failure to return the Government’s books to surplus. ...

Labour Blog

5 days ago
Warning to Fast-Track Applicants – ‘Exploit the Whenua, Face the Consequences’

Te Pāti Māori has this morning issued a stern warning to Fast-Track applicants with interests in mining, pledging to hold them accountable through retrospective liability and to immediately revoke Fast-Track consents under a future Te Pāti Māori government. This warning comes ahead of today’s third reading of the Fast-Track Approvals ...

Māori Party

5 days ago
Release: Govt cuts wages for lowest paid NZers… again

For the second year running, the government has effectively cut wages for the lowest paid workers in New Zealand. ...

Labour Blog

5 days ago
Govt’s miserly 1.5% minimum wage will take workers backwards

The Government’s announcement today of a 1.5 per cent increase to minimum wage is another blow for workers, with inflation projected to exceed the increase, meaning it’s a real terms pay reduction for many. ...

Greens

5 days ago
Release: Govt shirking responsibility for rate hikes

All the Government has achieved from its announcement today is to continue to push responsibility back on councils for its own lack of action to help bring down skyrocketing rates. ...

Labour Blog

5 days ago
Luxon’s ‘localism’ strikes again

The Government has used its final post-Cabinet press conference of the year to punch down on local government without offering any credible solutions to the issues our councils are facing. ...

Greens

6 days ago
Release: Govt breaks promise on EV chargers

The Government has failed to keep its promise to ‘super charge’ the EV network, delivering just 292 chargers - less than half of the 670 chargers needed to meet its target. ...

Labour Blog

6 days ago
Greens call for end to subsidies for Methanex

The Green Party is calling for the Government to stop subsidising the largest user of the country’s gas supplies, Methanex, following a report highlighting the multi-national’s disproportionate influence on energy prices in Aotearoa. ...

Greens

6 days ago
Govt child poverty targets allow for increase in poverty

The Green Party is appalled with the Government’s new child poverty targets that are based on a new ‘persistent poverty’ measure that could be met even with an increase in child poverty. ...

Greens

1 week ago
Release: Four weeks annual leave under threat

The Government’s attack on workers continues with news it is scrapping work on the Holidays Act. ...

Labour Blog

1 week ago
Govt’s emissions plan for measly 1% reduction

New independent analysis has revealed that the Government’s Emissions Reduction Plan (ERP) will reduce emissions by a measly 1 per cent by 2030, failing to set us up for the future and meeting upcoming targets. ...

Greens

1 week ago
Greens stand in solidarity with Whakaata Māori on sad day

The loss of 27 kaimahi at Whakaata Māori and the end of its daily news bulletin is a sad day for Māori media and another step backwards for Te Tiriti o Waitangi justice. ...

Greens

1 week ago
Sanctions regime to create more hardship for families

Yesterday the Government passed cruel legislation through first reading to establish a new beneficiary sanction regime that will ultimately mean more households cannot afford the basic essentials. ...

Greens

1 week ago
Govt gifts renters housing anxiety for Christmas

Today's passing of the Government's Residential Tenancies Amendment Bill–which allows landlords to end tenancies with no reason–ignores the voice of the people and leaves renters in limbo ahead of the festive season. ...

Greens

1 week ago
Release: National Party urged to support modern slavery legislation

Labour is urging the Prime Minister to walk the talk and support legislation combating modern slavery. ...

Labour Blog

1 week ago
Release: Labour has lost confidence in the Speaker

The Speaker of the New Zealand Parliament made an unprecedented decision on the government amendment to the Fast Track Approvals Bill last night. ...

Labour Blog

1 week ago
One year on, still no progress on new ferries

Today’s announcement from the Government on its plan for new ferries throws more uncertainty on the future of the country’s rail network. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago
Release: Nicola Willis’ smaller ferries will cost more

After wasting a year, Nicola Willis has delivered a worse deal for the Cook Strait ferries that will end up being more expensive and take longer to arrive. ...

Labour Blog

2 weeks ago
Bill to sanction unlawful occupation of Palestine

Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick has today launched a Member’s Bill to sanction Israel for its unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, as the All Out For Gaza rally reaches Parliament. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago
Release: Labour fully supports greyhound racing ban

The Government has done the right thing in moving to ban greyhound racing. ...

Labour Blog

2 weeks ago
Greyhound racing industry ban marks new era for animal welfare

After years of advocacy, the Green Party is very happy to hear the Government has listened to our collective voices and announced the closure of the greyhound racing industry, by 1 August 2026. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago
Rangatahi voices must be centred in Government’s Relationship and Sexuality Education refresh

In response to a new report from ERO, the Government has acknowledged the urgent need for consistency across the curriculum for Relationship and Sexuality Education (RSE) in schools. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago
Govt introduces archaic anti-worker legislation

The Green Party is appalled at the Government introducing legislation that will make it easier to penalise workers fighting for better pay and conditions. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago
Winston Peters – Kinleith Mill Speech

Thank you for the invitation to speak with you tonight on behalf of the political party I belong to - which is New Zealand First. As we have heard before this evening the Kinleith Mill is proposing to reduce operations by focusing on pulp and discontinuing “lossmaking paper production”. They say that they are currently consulting on the plan to permanently shut ...

NZ First Press Release

2 weeks ago
Swarbrick calls on Auckland Mayor to end delay of revival of St James Theatre

Auckland Central MP, Chlöe Swarbrick, has written to Mayor Wayne Brown requesting he stop the unnecessary delays on St James Theatre’s restoration. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago
He Ara Anamata: Greens launch Emissions Reduction Plan

Today, the Green Party of Aotearoa proudly unveils its new Emissions Reduction Plan–He Ara Anamata–a blueprint reimagining our collective future. ...

Greens

2 weeks ago

Internationally-trained doctors jump at chance to boost health workforce

Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says Health New Zealand will move swiftly to support dozens of internationally-trained doctors already in New Zealand on their journey to employment here, after a tripling of sought-after examination places. “The Medical Council has delivered great news for hardworking overseas doctors who want to contribute ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

9 hours ago
PM appoints business leader to APEC Business Advisory Council

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has appointed Sarah Ottrey to the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC). “At my first APEC Summit in Lima, I experienced firsthand the role that ABAC plays in guaranteeing political leaders hear the voice of business,” Mr Luxon says. “New Zealand’s ABAC representatives are very well respected and ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
New intelligence oversight appointments

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has announced four appointments to New Zealand’s intelligence oversight functions. The Honourable Robert Dobson KC has been appointed Chief Commissioner of Intelligence Warrants, and the Honourable Brendan Brown KC has been appointed as a Commissioner of Intelligence Warrants. The appointments of Hon Robert Dobson and Hon ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
New housing developments able to progress more quickly

Improvements in the average time it takes to process survey and title applications means housing developments can progress more quickly, Minister for Land Information Chris Penk says. “The government is resolutely focused on improving the building and construction pipeline,” Mr Penk says. “Applications to issue titles and subdivide land are ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
Actions to speed up air travel delivering results

The Government’s measures to reduce airport wait times, and better transparency around flight disruptions is delivering encouraging early results for passengers ahead of the busy summer period, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “Improving the efficiency of air travel is a priority for the Government to give passengers a smoother, more reliable ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
Ending contracted emergency housing in Rotorua

The Government today announced the intended closure of the Apollo Hotel as Contracted Emergency Housing (CEH) in Rotorua, Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka says. This follows a 30 per cent reduction in the number of households in CEH in Rotorua since National came into Government. “Our focus is on ending CEH in the Whakarewarewa area starting ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
Vocational education and training decisions support return to regions

The Government will reshape vocational education and training to return decision making to regions and enable greater industry input into work-based learning Tertiary Education and Skills Minister, Penny Simmonds says. “The redesigned system will better meet the needs of learners, industry, and the economy. It includes re-establishing regional polytechnics that ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
Reducing the environmental impact of synthetic refrigerants

The Government is taking action to better manage synthetic refrigerants and reduce emissions caused by greenhouse gases found in heating and cooling products, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds says. “Regulations will be drafted to support a product stewardship scheme for synthetic refrigerants, Ms. Simmonds says. “Synthetic refrigerants are found in a ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
Ngāruawāhia section of Waikato Expressway back to 4 lanes for Christmas

People travelling on State Highway 1 north of Hamilton will be relieved that remedial works and safety improvements on the Ngāruawāhia section of the Waikato Expressway were finished today, with all lanes now open to traffic, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.“I would like to acknowledge the patience of road users ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

2 days ago
Appointments to the ENZ board

Tertiary Education and Skills Minister, Penny Simmonds, has announced a new appointment to the board of Education New Zealand (ENZ). Dr Erik Lithander has been appointed as a new member of the ENZ board for a three-year term until 30 January 2028. “I would like to welcome Dr Erik Lithander to the ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Government to celebrate Waitangi Day around NZ

The Government will have senior representatives at Waitangi Day events around the country, including at the Waitangi Treaty Grounds, but next year Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has chosen to take part in celebrations elsewhere. “It has always been my intention to celebrate Waitangi Day around the country with different ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
More gangs added to Gangs Act list

Two more criminal gangs will be subject to the raft of laws passed by the Coalition Government that give Police more powers to disrupt gang activity, and the intimidation they impose in our communities, Police Minister Mark Mitchell says. Following an Order passed by Cabinet, from 3 February 2025 the ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Judicial appointment announced

Attorney-General Judith Collins today announced the appointment of Justice Christian Whata as a Judge of the Court of Appeal. Justice Whata’s appointment as a Judge of the Court of Appeal will take effect on 1 August 2025 and fill a vacancy created by the retirement of Hon Justice David Goddard on ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
GDP data highlights importance of growth

The latest economic figures highlight the importance of the steps the Government has taken to restore respect for taxpayers’ money and drive economic growth, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. Data released today by Stats NZ shows Gross Domestic Product fell 1 per cent in the September quarter. “Treasury and most ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Strengthening Free Speech in Universities

Tertiary Education and Skills Minister Penny Simmonds and Associate Minister of Education David Seymour today announced legislation changes to strengthen freedom of speech obligations on universities. “Freedom of speech is fundamental to the concept of academic freedom and there is concern that universities seem to be taking a more risk-averse ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Launch of Emergency Cellular Priority Service

Police Minister, Mark Mitchell, and Internal Affairs Minister, Brooke van Velden, today launched a further Public Safety Network cellular service that alongside last year’s Cellular Roaming roll-out, puts globally-leading cellular communications capability into the hands of our emergency responders. The Public Safety Network’s new Cellular Priority service means Police, Wellington ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Minister reopens Mangamuka Gorge

State Highway 1 through the Mangamuka Gorge has officially reopened today, providing a critical link for Northlanders and offering much-needed relief ahead of the busy summer period, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.“The Mangamuka Gorge is a vital route for Northland, carrying around 1,300 vehicles per day and connecting the Far ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Funding confirmed for second Ashburton Bridge

The Government has welcomed decisions by the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) and Ashburton District Council confirming funding to boost resilience in the Canterbury region, with construction on a second Ashburton Bridge expected to begin in 2026, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “Delivering a second Ashburton Bridge to improve resilience and ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Government boosts support for avian influenza response

The Government is backing the response into high pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) in Otago, Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard says. “Cabinet has approved new funding of $20 million to enable MPI to meet unbudgeted ongoing expenses associated with the H7N6 response including rigorous scientific testing of samples at the enhanced PC3 ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

3 days ago
Levelling the playing field for media advertising

Legislation that will repeal all advertising restrictions for broadcasters on Sundays and public holidays has passed through first reading in Parliament today, Media Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “As a growing share of audiences get their news and entertainment from streaming services, these restrictions have become increasingly redundant. New Zealand on ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Inspector-General of Defence appointed

Today the House agreed to Brendan Horsley being appointed Inspector-General of Defence, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “Mr Horsley’s experience will be invaluable in overseeing the establishment of the new office and its support networks. “He is currently Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, having held that role since June 2020. ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Fire and Emergency New Zealand final levy rates confirmed

Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says the Government has agreed to the final regulations for the levy on insurance contracts that will fund Fire and Emergency New Zealand from July 2026. “Earlier this year the Government agreed to a 2.2 percent increase to the rate of levy. Fire ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
More AML relief on the way for Kiwi businesses

The Government is delivering regulatory relief for New Zealand businesses through changes to the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act. “The Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Amendment Bill, which was introduced today, is the second Bill – the other being the Statutes Amendment Bill - that ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Hawke’s Bay Expressway moving at pace

Transport Minister Simeon Brown has welcomed further progress on the Hawke’s Bay Expressway Road of National Significance (RoNS), with the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) Board approving funding for the detailed design of Stage 1, paving the way for main works construction to begin in late 2025.“The Government is moving at ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Government seeks partnerships to plant trees on Crown-owned-land

The Government today released a request for information (RFI) to seeking interest in partnerships to plant trees on Crown-owned land with low farming and conservation value (excluding National Parks) Forestry Minister Todd McClay announced. “Planting trees on Crown-owned land will drive economic growth by creating more forestry jobs in our regions, providing more wood ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Wide ranging legislation to make justice system more efficient

Court timeliness, access to justice, and improving the quality of existing regulation are the focus of a series of law changes introduced to Parliament today by Associate Minister of Justice Nicole McKee. The three Bills in the Regulatory Systems (Justice) Amendment Bill package each improve a different part of the ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Diverse skills in community trust appointments

A total of 41 appointments and reappointments have been made to the 12 community trusts around New Zealand that serve their regions, Associate Finance Minister Shane Jones says. “These trusts, and the communities they serve from the Far North to the deep south, will benefit from the rich experience, knowledge, ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Torture redress for survivors of the Lake Alice Unit

The Government has confirmed how it will provide redress to survivors who were tortured at the Lake Alice Psychiatric Hospital Child and Adolescent Unit (the Lake Alice Unit). “The Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care found that many of the 362 children who went through the Lake Alice Unit between 1972 and ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
A busy year in the House

It has been a busy, productive year in the House as the coalition Government works hard to get New Zealand back on track, Leader of the House Chris Bishop says. “This Government promised to rebuild the economy, restore law and order and reduce the cost of living. Our record this ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Consultation opens on working with engineered stone

“Accelerated silicosis is an emerging occupational disease caused by unsafe work such as engineered stone benchtops. I am running a standalone consultation on engineered stone to understand what the industry is currently doing to manage the risks, and whether further regulatory intervention is needed,” says Workplace Relations and Safety Minister ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Greater reporting on Treaty settlement commitments

Mehemea he pai mō te tangata, mahia – if it’s good for the people, get on with it. Enhanced reporting on the public sector’s delivery of Treaty settlement commitments will help improve outcomes for Māori and all New Zealanders, Māori Crown Relations Minister Tama Potaka says. Compiled together for the ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
New appointments to the Charities Registration Board

Mr Roger Holmes Miller and Ms Tarita Hutchinson have been appointed to the Charities Registration Board, Community and Voluntary Sector Minister Louise Upston says. “I would like to welcome the new members joining the Charities Registration Board. “The appointment of Ms Hutchinson and Mr Miller will strengthen the Board’s capacity ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Building consent processing times improve

More building consent and code compliance applications are being processed within the statutory timeframe since the Government required councils to submit quarterly data, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says. “In the midst of a housing shortage we need to look at every step of the build process for efficiencies ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Faster access to support through Innovation Fund

Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey is proud to announce the first three recipients of the Government’s $10 million Mental Health and Addiction Community Sector Innovation Fund which will enable more Kiwis faster access to mental health and addiction support. “This fund is part of the Government’s commitment to investing in ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
New Zealand to assist Vanuatu on earthquake response

New Zealand is providing Vanuatu assistance following yesterday's devastating earthquake, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says. "Vanuatu is a member of our Pacific family and we are supporting it in this time of acute need," Mr Peters says. "Our thoughts are with the people of Vanuatu, and we will be ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Government takes steps to reduce card fees for Kiwis

The Government welcomes the Commerce Commission’s plan to reduce card fees for Kiwis by an estimated $260 million a year, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly says.“The Government is relentlessly focused on reducing the cost of living, so Kiwis can keep more of their hard-earned income and live a ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

4 days ago
Review recommends ECE regulation shakeup

Regulation Minister David Seymour has welcomed the Early Childhood Education (ECE) regulatory review report, the first major report from the Ministry for Regulation. The report makes 15 recommendations to modernise and simplify regulations across ECE so services can get on with what they do best – providing safe, high-quality care ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

5 days ago
Offshore Renewable Energy Bill passes first reading

The Government‘s Offshore Renewable Energy Bill to create a new regulatory regime that will enable firms to construct offshore wind generation has passed its first reading in Parliament, Energy Minister Simeon Brown says.“New Zealand currently does not have a regulatory regime for offshore renewable energy as the previous government failed ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

5 days ago
Local Government (Water Services) Bill passes first reading

Legislation to enable new water service delivery models that will drive critical investment in infrastructure has passed its first reading in Parliament, marking a significant step towards the delivery of Local Water Done Well, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown and Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly say.“Councils and voters ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

5 days ago
Gene Technology Bill passes first reading

New Zealand is one step closer to reaping the benefits of gene technology with the passing of the first reading of the Gene Technology Bill, Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins says. "This legislation will end New Zealand's near 30-year ban on gene technology outside the lab and is ...

BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz

5 days ago

Signs of the hīkoi: More than just ‘words on cardboard’

The placards seen at the Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti conveyed "huge kōrero with immediacy", expert says: "People know the power of the word." ...

Radio NZ – political

5 hours ago
A final Ode to .. King Luxon

Cosmic CatastropheThe year draws to a close.King Luxon has grown tired of the long eveningsListening to the dreary squabbling of his Triumvirate.He strolls up to the top floor of the PalaceTo consult with his Astronomer Royal.The Royal Telescope scans the skies,And King Luxon stares up into the heavensFrom the terrestrial ...

NewsroomBy Victor Billot

12 hours ago
A hater and an enthusiast review The Royal Free by Carl Shuker

Spinoff editor Mad Chapman and books editor Claire Mabey debate Carl Shuker’s new novel about… an editor. Claire: Hello Mad, you just finished The Royal Free – overall impressions? Mad: Hi Claire, I literally just put the book down and I would have to say my immediate impression is ...

The SpinoffBy Claire Mabey

14 hours ago
Survive to 25 (December, that is)

Christmas and its buildup are often lonely, hard and full of unreasonable expectations. Here’s how to make it to Jesus’s birthday and find the little bit of joy we all deserve. Have you found this year relentless? Has the latest Apple update “fucked up your life”? Have you lost two ...

The SpinoffBy Anna Rawhiti-Connell

14 hours ago
All I want for Christmas is modern day slavery legislation

Despite overwhelming public and corporate support, the government has stalled progress on a modern day slavery law. That puts us behind other countries – and makes Christmas a time of tragedy rather than joy, argues Shanti Mathias. Picture the scene on Christmas Day. Everyone replete with nice things to eat, ...

The SpinoffBy Shanti Mathias

14 hours ago
Israeli-American historian describes attacks on Gaza as ‘war of annihilation’

Asia Pacific Report “It looks like Hiroshima. It looks like Germany at the end of World War Two,” says an Israeli-American historian and professor of holocaust and genocide studies at Brown University about the horrifying reality of Gaza. Professor Omer Bartov, has described Israel’s ongoing war on Gaza as an ...

Evening ReportBy Asia Pacific Report

17 hours ago
NZ govt plans to make ‘heavy handed’ change to free speech rules for universities

The New Zealand government coalition is tweaking university regulations to curb what it says is an increasingly “risk-averse approach” to free speech. The proposed changes will set clear expectations on how universities should approach freedom of speech issues. Each university will then have to adopt a “freedom of speech statement” ...

Evening ReportBy Asia Pacific Report

17 hours ago
Caitlin Johnstone: Where does the aggression really begin?

Report by Dr David Robie – Café Pacific. – COMMENTARY: By Caitlin Johnstone New York prosecutors have charged Luigi Mangione with “murder as an act of terrorism” in his alleged shooting of health insurance CEO Brian Thompson earlier this month. This news comes out at the same time as ...

Evening ReportBy David Robie

20 hours ago
OECD Report Highlights That More Is Needed

This report reflects that gap in our dealings overseas, and it shows that legislators, the public sector and businesses need to walk the talk. ...

Scoop politics

1 day ago
Government quietly scraps waste minimisation policies

The government has quietly cancelled plans to improve recycling and roll out a kerbside food scraps composting scheme. ...

Radio NZ – political

1 day ago
MEAA welcomes News MAP funding ‘leg up’ for Australian journalism

Pacific Media Watch The union for Australian journalists has welcomed the delivery by the federal government of more than $150 million to support the sustainability of public interest journalism over the next four years. Combined with the announcement of the revamped News Bargaining Initiative, this could result in up to ...

Evening ReportBy Asia Pacific Report

1 day ago
Transmission Gully partnership breakdown will not hurt future public-private partnerships, Infrastru...

The roads partnership unravelled under a confidential settlement this week, meaning NZTA will now finish off what it had said was incomplete work. ...

Radio NZ – political

1 day ago
Funding cuts to charity particularly felt over Christmas period

The number of people seeking help from Lifeline is expected to increase by 10 to 20 percent over Christmas. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Nelson Hospital conditions ‘unbearable’ – staff

One worker says the building is decrepit and falling down around them. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
The Secret Diary of .. Luxon at Xmas

MONDAY“Merry Xmas, and praise the Lord,” said Sheriff Luxon, and smiled for the camera. There was a flash of smoke when the shutter pressed down on the magnesium powder. The sheriff had arranged for a photographer from the Dodge Gazette to attend a ceremony where he handed out food parcels to ...

NewsroomBy Steve Braunias

2 days ago
Stand by for cricket’s Smash Palace

It’s a little under two months since the White Ferns shocked the cricketing world, deservedly taking home the T20 World Cup. Since then the trophy has had a tour around the country, five of the squad have played in the WBBL in Australia while most others have returned to domestic ...

NewsroomBy Aiden McLaughlin

2 days ago
Early-onset dementia under the microscope

Comment: If we say the word ‘dementia’, many will picture an older person struggling to remember the names of their loved ones, maybe a grandparent living out their final years in an aged care facility. Dementia can also occur in people younger than 65, but it can take time before ...

NewsroomBy Shruti Sharma and Dr Brigid Ryan

2 days ago
Keeping the pirates at bay: Should the Australian ‘Blocking Order’ case prompt a discussion in N...

Piracy is a reality of modern life – but copyright law has struggled to play catch-up for as long as the entertainment industry has existed. As far back as 1988, the House of Lords criticised copyright law’s conflict with the reality of human behaviour in the context of burning cassette ...

NewsroomBy Tania Goatley and Oscar Zambuto

2 days ago
‘We were as famous as Tom Cruise’: Craig Parker on 90s Shortland St fandom

As he makes a surprise return to Shortland Street, actor Craig Parker takes us through his life in television. Craig Parker has been a fixture on television in Aotearoa for nearly four decades. He had starring roles in iconic local series like Gloss, Mercy Peak and Diplomatic Immunity, featured in ...

The SpinoffBy My Life in TV

2 days ago
‘I prioritise the mission, not my health’: Adam McGrath’s perfect weekend playlist

The Ōtautahi musician shares the 10 tracks he loves to spin, including the folk classic that cured him of a ‘case of the give-ups’. When singer-songwriter Adam McGrath returns to Kumeu’s Auckland Folk Festival from January 24-27, he’s not planning on simply idling his way through – he wants the late ...

The SpinoffBy Weekend playlist

2 days ago
The rescue dog bringing joy to Christchurch retirement homes

Alex Casey spends an afternoon on the job with River, the rescue dog on a mission to spread joy to Ōtautahi rest homes. Almost everyone says it is never enough time. But River the rescue dog, a jet black huntaway border collie cross, has to keep a tight pace to ...

The SpinoffBy Alex Casey

2 days ago
Fiji pro-Palestine nativity scene exposes Gaza as ‘hell on earth’ at Christmas

Asia Pacific Report Fiji activists have recreated the nativity scene at a solidarity for Palestine gathering in Fiji’s capital Suva just days before Christmas. The Fiji Women’s Crisis Centre and Fijians for Palestine Solidarity Network recreated the scene at the FWCC compound — a baby Jesus figurine lies amidst the ...

Evening ReportBy Asia Pacific Report

2 days ago
Vanuatu quake: ‘Our shop was flattened like a deck of cards’

By 1News Pacific correspondent Barbara Dreaver and 1News reporters A number of Kiwis have been successfully evacuated from Vanuatu after a devastating earthquake shook the Pacific island nation earlier this week. The death toll was still unclear, though at least 14 people were killed according to an earlier statement from ...

Evening ReportBy Asia Pacific Report

2 days ago
How diplomats have broken the law in NZ – and what happened next

A handful of foreign diplomats have misbehaved during their time here - and not all of them have been brought to justice. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Swim schools report sinking enrolments as downturn deepens

Being able to swim is often considered a life skill, but tough economic times are forcing many families to pull their children out of lessons. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
‘There will be deaths because of this’ – Warning over Health NZ IT cuts

A West Coast IT worker is warning patients will die as Health New Zealand aims to slash its data and digital staff. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Polytech sales possible but unlikely when Te Pūkenga disestablished – minister

In a surprise move, the sale of polytechnics will be on the table when the national institute of technology Te Pūkenga is disestablished. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Parliament’s final sitting day an insight into party factions

On Parliament's last day of the year, there was a rare glimpse of the factions within the major parties. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Former Labour MP, North Shore mayor Ann Hartley dies

Former Labour MP and mayor of Auckland's North Shore City Ann Hartley has died. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
The closest thing Australian cartooning had to a prophet: the sometimes celebrated, sometimes contro...

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Richard Scully, Professor in Modern History, University of New England Bunker. Image courtesy of Michael Leunig, CC BY-NC-SA Michael Leunig – who died in the early hours of Thursday December 19, surrounded by “his children, loved ones, and sunflowers” – was the ...

Evening ReportBy The Conversation

2 days ago
Labour moves Speaker from the ‘nice’ to ‘naughty’ list

Last week's fights with the Speaker over the Fast Track schedule may have changed the tone in Parliament. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Govt ends pilot programme for Māori and Pacific, sparking outrage

The Government announced the end of the programme that allowed Māori and Pacific people to acess bowel cancer screening at 50-years-old. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
Parliament fits an extra morning into final sitting day

The House - On Parliament's last day of the year, there was the rare occurrence of a personal (conscience) vote on selling booze over the Easter weekend. While it didn't have the numbers to pass, it was a chance to get a rare glimpse of the fact ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago
The Friday Poem: ‘Bejeweled log’ by Holly Fletcher

A new poem by Holly Fletcher. bejeweled log i was dreaming about wasps / wee darlings that followed me / ducking under objects / that i was fated to pickup / my fingers seeking / and meeting with tiny proboscis’s / but instead / i wake up / roll sideways ...

The SpinoffBy Holly Fletcher

2 days ago
Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right p...

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Flora Hui, Research Fellow, Centre for Eye Research Australia and Honorary Fellow, Department of Surgery (Ophthalmology), The University of Melbourne Versta/Shutterstock Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we ...

Evening ReportBy The Conversation

2 days ago
How does franchising work?

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Andrew Terry, Professor of Business Regulation, University of Sydney Michael von Aichberger/Shutterstock Even if you’ve no idea how the business model underpinning franchises works, there’s a good chance you’ve spent money at one. Franchising is essentially a strategy for cloning ...

Evening ReportBy The Conversation

2 days ago
The one episode of Shortland Street you need to watch this year

If something big is going to happen in Ferndale, it’s going to happen at Christmas. This is an excerpt from our weekly pop culture newsletter Rec Room. Sign up here. If there’s one episode of Shortland Street you should watch each year, it’s the annual Christmas cliffhanger. The final episode of ...

The SpinoffBy Tara Ward

2 days ago
As China expands its cyber espionage and sabotage operations, how will the Trump administration resp...

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By William A. Stoltz, Lecturer and expert Associate, National Security College, Australian National University US President-elect Donald Trump has named most of the members of his proposed cabinet. However, he’s yet to reveal key appointees to America’s powerful cyber warfare and intelligence institutions. ...

Evening ReportBy The Conversation

2 days ago
The Unity Books bestseller chart for 2024

Announcing the top 10 books of the the year at Unity Books’ stores in High St, Auckland, and Willis St, Wellington. AUCKLAND 1 Intermezzo by Sally Rooney (Faber & Faber, $37) The phenomenal Irish writer is the unsurprising chart topper for 2024 with her fourth novel that, much like her first ...

The SpinoffBy The Spinoff Review of Books

2 days ago
Government confirms plan to dismantle Te Pūkenga, re-establish polytechs

The government has confirmed its plan to break up Te Pūkenga / New Zealand Institute of Skills and Technology and re-establish independent polytechnics. ...

Radio NZ – political

2 days ago

On Freedom

Related Posts

122 comments on “On Freedom ”

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Related Posts

Related Posts

Related Posts

Related Posts

On Freedom

Share this:

Related Posts

122 comments on “On Freedom ”

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Share this:

Related Posts

Share this:

Related Posts

Share this:

Related Posts

Share this:

Related Posts