Written By:
notices and features - Date published:
6:00 am, June 28th, 2016 - 94 comments
Categories: open mike -
Tags:
The current rise of populism challenges the way we think about people’s relationship to the economy.We seem to be entering an era of populism, in which leadership in a democracy is based on preferences of the population which do not seem entirely rational nor serving their longer interests. ...
The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.
Another day in John Key’s neo-liberal nightmare.
We have become a cruel, greedy, uncaring and selfish nation under his wretched leadership.
It was 4 degrees in Christchurch last night.
Not very warm to be sleeping in a car.
Not very warm to be sleeping in a container.
Not very warm to be sleeping in a garage.
Not very warm to be sleeping on the street.
The mainstream media may think the Zac Guilford, Lydia Ko and Mark Todd are all important news items, but they are not.
The majority of the media is doing everything they can to support Paula Bennett and move homelessness off the headlines.
“Try walking in my shoes, it’s not actually that easy.”
This was the challenge TA set to Prime Minister John Key. But really it’s a challenge for us all.
Don’t forget Millie has found love in Greece.
This is the Herald’s lead story online…’Manager who stole $730k from Wanaka health centre had stolen before’
not Brexit
not homelessness.
What a joke!
You could write that headline any day and substitute minister for manager and abuse/disregard process for stolen.
But hey that would be journalism which has no place in granny’s celebrity, fear mongering, distraction agenda.
@Paul – Granny’s main focus is to warn the business owners and shareholders and the public against workers! Don’t trust them, they steal! Don’t trust anyone for that matter! The world is a scary place that only ‘The bachelor’ and ‘cops 4’ can lighten your day.
White collar criminals do little to not jail time, and pay back none of the money, as compared to the full conviction rate and claw back of any benefit fraud.
Zac Guildford, an overrated sports jock with issues. Did he have his pants on this time ?
Used to be one of the Herald’s favourite soap operas.
Looks like they’re hoping for a sequel.
Pity they don’t tackle the issue of alcohol in New Zealand seriously and instead do celebrity tittle tattle.
Should we be worried after Brexit?
Rachel Stewart thinks so…
What do you think?
http://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/opinion/9988749/OBR-policy-a-scary-bank-secret
James Shaw has been doing work on this too in the past few weeks. I think the concerns were there even without Brexit but I’m not sure why it’s come up now.
https://blog.greens.org.nz/2016/06/21/national-leaves-kiwi-savers-the-most-vulnerable-in-oecd/
Kiwi Saver, as an entire scheme, puts Kiwi wages into feeding the Wall St growth seeking investment animal. Thanks Labour, thanks Greens.
Feel free to post some alternatives including plans CV.
Yeah and this after seeing year after year after year these arsoles paying themselves massive bonuses after the BIG bailout in 2008.
As I have said on many occasions I would not trust this incompetent Double Dipping Dickhead from Dipton with the local Boy Scouts Jamboree money.
I find it amusing that the likes of Prat Henry thinks he’s so Wonderful. Not surprised the international elite like the IMF thinks he’s first class as he’s of the same ilk and is borrowing heaps to keep us in hock for ever.
The other thing is, In Australia all the major trading banks have to have a deposit guarantee for the customer deposits.
As the major banks in NZ are Australian owned we now have a situation that if the major banks fail and they bring in the OBR New Zealanders will be financing Australians
How about that for a fucking MIckey Mouse set up. As I have said on many occasion, This shower of shit as a government could not organise a piss up in a brewery.
“Every other country in the OECD protects savers’ deposits with deposit insurance. Australians saving with the parent banks of ANZ, BNZ, ASB, or Westpac all have their deposits guaranteed up to $250,000. Kiwis saving with these same banks get no protection whatsoever.”
blog.greens.org.nz/2016/06/21/national-leaves-kiwi-savers-the-most-vulnerable-in-oecd/
heh – I thought it was Cullen who had legislated for using customer deposits to bail the banks at the tail end of the last Labour led government. Guess I was a wee bit off the mark.
The Double Dipping Dickhead from Dipton (National) introduced that very quietly (not reported on TV or in Granny) in 2011.
The banks don’t make their customers aware of it either
I believe that these changes were mandated by the international central banking authority, the BIS (Bank of International Settlements). Another key institution of the power elite that most have not heard of.
Right, so we’re now witnessing a long-planned coup against Corbyn that was always scheduled to happen at some point in the immediate wake of the EU Referendum result, regardless of outcome.
Naturally enough, the PLP plotters needed to fabricate some sort of plausible-sounding pretexts and seed them in the MSM.
What I find interesting, though, is just how internally incoherent these pretexts are.
Despite the most authoritative polls taken on Referendum Day all suggesting Labour voters went heavily for Remain … 63/37 (Lord Ashcroft), 65/35 (YouGov), 60/32 (with 8% not voting) (Survation) … and the likelihood (based on the detail of the figures) that even Labour’s working and lower middle class C2DE voters (as a whole) either mildly favoured Remain or were relatively evenly split … Corbyn’s critics have pushed the notion that he has to go because “millions of Labour voters” defied his authority by ignoring his advice to support Remain. He clearly can’t command Labour voters’ respect, the argument goes.
At the same time, however, they’re also pushing the rather contradictory idea that he didn’t campaign hard enough for Remain, indeed appeared to be lukewarm and somewhat sceptical of the EU at best (in which case, the minority of Labour supporters who chose Leave did not, in fact, defy him !)
Utterly incoherent.
I mean, you could mount a reasonable argument that Corbyn got it pretty much right by keeping both types of Labour voter happy – going through the paces of formally supporting Remain while making it clear the EU needed significant reform.
It’s also a fact that Tory voters were rather more divided than Labour ones (42/58 in favour of Brexit – Lord Ashcroft Poll), (39/61 Brexit – YouGov). Does that mean Boris Johnson shouldn’t stand because he failed to exercise authority over a large-ish minority of Tory voters ?
And what about Nicola Sturgeon ? According to the Lord Ashcroft Poll, as many SNP supporters in Scotland voted Brexit (36%) as Labour supporters throughout the UK (37%). Should she also resign given that her Party is pro-Remain ?
The other implausible pretext comes courtesy of The Guardian:
It’s supposed to be some sort of Shock !, Horror ! King-Hit:
“Leaked internal Labour Party polling of people who voted for Labour in 2015 reveals that nearly a third (29%) would support a different party if a general election was held today … It shows that just 71% of those who voted for Ed Miliband’s party in May last year say they would vote Labour now.”
And, in another article from The Guardian:
“Leaked internal Labour party polling suggested that Labour would attract nearly 3 million fewer votes than it did in the 2015 general election if one were called today.”
On Kiwiblog, David Farrar approvingly quotes the article, commenting that: “Labour MPs know they’ll do even worse than in 2015.”
The Guardian, I suspect has read far too much into the figures, smuggling some highly questionable assumptions into their analysis.
For starters, they fail to realise just how much churn there always is in public opinion. 71% loyalty to a Party is pretty typical in the UK. Take, for example, the latest Survation Poll conducted just a few days ago, immediately following the Referendum (and almost certainly after Labour’s Internal Poll):
2015 Labour voters = 73% Loyal, 15% Other party, 12% Don’t Know
2015 Tory voters = 71% Loyal, 13% Other party, 16% Don’t Know
In this Poll, Lib Dem loyalty was just 60% and, among people who had either voted for Other parties in 2015 or Not Voted, there were significant swings to Labour (far greater than movement to the Tories). Which is why Labour and the Tories were neck-and-neck on 32% each.
And I can cite plenty of other polls over the last year that say the same. There’s nothing at all shocking about 71% loyalty.
That’s why this idea of Labour being 3 million voters down is such utter rubbish. Not only will a reasonable chunk of their currently “disloyal” 2015 voters be in the Don’t Know category (many of whom will end up choosing Labour again) but also the usual degree of churn means that Labour will be largely compensated (or, as the latest Survation suggests) more than compensated by significant swings from people who voted for other Parties in 2015.
Corbyn’s critics are selling a lie.
And his Preferred PM stats are still better than Little’s.
Rolling Corbyn is like Brexit itself: revolution always sounds good while you plot get everyone emotional and even while you do it.
Then you wake up and reach for the plan. And there isn’t one.
Corbyn screams instability, which is the last thing you want while the country is about to go through a period of instability.
I don’t think the UK economy would survive Brexit and Corbyn as PM, so he’s out the door.
@BM – I think the screams are from the Labour supporters as their preferred leader is knifed in the back by his own party, at a time where the instability of the Conservatives could be utilised by looking like Labour is the stable safe haven. Apparently Labour’s personal careerists politicians and hungry warmongers are more interested in their own dramas and career climbing and appeasing their lobbyists to actually do something like shutting up, 9months in about their leader and actually helping win the next election.
Funny enough voters can easily work it out and learn politics in not worth it, and not vote.
At a time where the instability of the Conservatives could be utilised by looking like Labour is the stable safe haven.
Never happen while Corbyn is at the wheel, which is why he has to go.
If Corbyn stays, the Labour party won’t be able to capitalise on the disarray within the conservatives.
The man is voter poison.
When was the last time you were in the UK BM?
Talking from your arse or from living there?.
“The man is voter poison.”
This is a big Fat complete lie and the opposite of actual reality.
London is not the whole UK BM.
It’s mostly London MP’s too who resigned, good riddance to champagne socialists IMHO
As for the people who live in the UK and vote labour, the majority want Corbyn the stupid posh soft southern part of Labour thinks it knows better
Corbyn screams of the end of the neo-liberal accomodation. The voters love him.
name me one other time in recent history when a potential party leader got queues out the door at a meeting
Smart choices on his new Shadow Cabinet, heavy on Northerners and a few Scots.
Is this the beginnings of the Blairite/Mandelson purge?
Bryan Gould made some surprising comments in the NZ Herald today, but perhaps not all that surprising if you know the man, which I don’t:
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/opinion/news/article.cfm?c_id=466&objectid=11664386
Yes he got that completely wrong Incognito-see my comment below the article.
swordfish
Thanks for that, I was wondering percentage of that alleged (cherry-picked?) 29% had gone to undecided rather than another party. This seems to me to be the coup that was scheduled for after the local body elections earlier in the year, which then had to be rainchecked when Labour’s vote heldup (except in Scotland). This line seems to neatly sum up the antidemocratic mindset of the Labour traitors:
The Guardian have always hated Corbyn, favouring the Blairlite candidates from the start
“Corbyn’s critics are selling a lie.”
They’ve had so much practice at it. They have no credibility with the electorate, imo. But meanwhile the Tory’s are managing the Brexit fallout (they’ve had a lot of practice at that!) and are looking composed (relatively speaking).
All over for Labour thanks to the Blairites. Shouda held off… but then they have July 6th to worry about…
Owen Jones on the plight of UK Labour
The conclusion provides food for thought.
This in Politico is hardly unbiased (being based on a leak from an MP who has obviously chosen their side already), but I found this interesting:
http://www.politico.eu/article/inside-account-of-labour-mps-attacks-on-jeremy-corbyn-shadow-cabinet-resignations-brexit/
It seems incredible that the revolting Labour MPs would sacrifice their careers in this fashion. Given the UK’s FPP system, two Labour parties splitting the vote would be electoral suicide. Perhaps they’ve got lucrative “consultancy” positions lined up for when they are turfed out of parliament?
Speaking of breakups, this is interesting in light of the Plaid Cymru suggestion of Welsh independence (though that’s generally their answer to anything). Perhaps a Celtic confederation is on the cards? You could could argue that Scotland and Northern Island have more in common than the Republic of Eire and NI (though you’d have a lot of argument from catholic Ulstermen).
With regard to what is going on in Labour, I think that the results of 2008 are coming to a head in the UK, triggered by the Brexit. I was interested in this comment by RedLogix on last night’s daily Review: http://thestandard.org.nz/daily-review-27062016/#comment-1195717
It is a comment on Labour’s right wingers, dated 1981, and it occurred to me that prior to Thatcher, etc. Labour right wingers did actually a have a devil’s advocate role to play, and they also helped to keep Labour policy from jeopardising the fortunes of the country as a whole, as well as protecting the party from accusations of communism. The third way period placed this lot in ascendancy, but since 2008 the right have held such economic sway that not rocking the boat has come to mean supporting austerity and not doing a single meaningful thing that a Labour Party exists to do. Now I see an unholy panic in UK Labour at the thought that the actual left might get mileage out of the Brexit. But the thing is, there is actually nothing attractive now for a market-centred Labour to convincingly pitch to the voters. If they cannot represent their abandoned constituents they have no further purpose.
“It seems incredible that the revolting Labour MPs would sacrifice their careers in this fashion. Given the UK’s FPP system, two Labour parties splitting the vote would be electoral suicide
Yes. This is a very high stakes play from the Blairite wing. The UK (un-united kingdom) really does need to convert to to proportional representation. The limits of FPP are glaring with this break-up on the left. The trouble is, the Conservatives are comfortable with the status quo. Meanwhile, citizens with the most difficult living conditions are unrepresented (again!) if Corbyn is ousted.
On a lighter note – a celtic confederation has been sorted! … 🙂
https://twitter.com/hashtag/UnionOfCraic?s=04
This vacuum is rapidly & easily filled by the far-right, which is all too keen to offer leadership and obviously has strong views on how to deal with present and future turmoil.
Here in New Zealand we worry and complain about the lack of a strong opposition but it ain’t nothing compared to what goes on and has been going on for some time in Europe.
If the UK or the World indeed goes into recession (again) all Hell could break loose (again).
Key is getting a lot of publicity with so called wonderful opportunities in a FTA with England/Britain, its like wow, its two years away, and they cant even negotiate a deal as of yet.
Constant claims by National claim more trade will raise wages and improve our living costs is unproven.
Its a fiction because the complete opposite happens.
Has employment costs increased for apple growers, since the Aussie market was opened up,
Prices for apples have tripled in the supermarket for low quality fruit.
Is there any evidence any primary producers have increased their employment costs on the back higher export volumes
FYI, I grew up on an a 3 acre apple orchard in the Tron.
Exactly – it is pretty clear that so called ‘trade deals’ do not work for consumers or workers.
In the UK supermarkets own everything, so that when you get an apple it has been picked before it is ripe so tastes horrible and has hundreds of food miles.
Most get put into cold storage here before being shipped.
I am waiting for anyone to post some proof how increases in trade volumes have added to employment costs,
which would happen if wages increase, wouldnt it?
Free market seems to work only theoretically. Most of it’s admirers do all their work paper pushing and making a killing on ‘the markets’ rather than growing or producing real stuff. Now we have the GFC because some banks got some maths whizzes to make up some new products with debt to ‘produce’ something theoretical. No lessons learnt there by the look of it.
Given that the petition to keep Mike Hosking has just over 2,700 signatures, as against the approximately 21,700 signed up to get rid of him, and given that the pace at which the latter is gathering supporters still far outstrips the former, the question must be asked as to whether getting rid of him is really enough, or whether the only appropriate option might not be to sack him, proclaim his sacking in a special announcement across all channels to the musical backdrop of What a Wonderful World, revoke his passport, prohibit his dining at any restaurant or public bar, or purchasing any edible produce fresher than twenty-one weeks old, and legislate to replace the overnight programme of all free-to-air channels with uninterrupted repeats of his least flattering moments in broadcasting, mostly drowned out by pre-recorded flatulence.
A big thank you to all of the right-leaning Standard readers who advocated increasing the merriment of the rest of us by creating a counter-petition for keping him. Your contributions are always appreciated.
its really just stroking his ego, either which way, he will be loving it.
Of course he will:
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/news/article.cfm?c_id=1501119&objectid=11663786
Without Hosking where else would I get my daily reminder of what a dismal, desperate, callous, corrupt, hateful, heartless and truly horrible place New Zealand will become if the national party and it’s cronies remain in power ?
^That’s one of the top comments on the Keep Mike Hosking petition. I think its really a taking the piss petition.
I would have added , deserving of at least two of the three strike rule?
Dam-ning article on the Ruataniwha dam. Exposes, yet again, Nick Smith’s deliberate negligence and incompetence. An interesting read. http://www.nzherald.co.nz/the-country/news/article.cfm?c_id=16&objectid=11664300
Another National ideological driven gambit to make the taxpayers pay for it,
while privatizing the profit, so who will own the water rights?
oh the irony…
London Young Labour have just blamed Corbyn for not mobilising more Labour voters to vote against Brexit
– with only 30% of young voters turning up to vote, you’ve got to wonder whether LYL are just spoilt kids of Blairite era dinosaurs
http://www.politico.eu/article/inside-account-of-labour-mps-attacks-on-jeremy-corbyn-shadow-cabinet-resignations-brexit/
The lazy buggers don’t turn up to vote and then blame Corbyn.
In fact 3.5 million people aged under 35 were not registered to vote in the UK. If most of these people had got their act together and voted 70% Remain, Remain would have won.
There is an inherent contradiction with those in their 20’s at the moment; on one hand they say F%^& It I’m not going to vote, the whole system is rigged/crap; on the other hand they whinge when old people vote and so get what they want. My niece in England is a classic example.
Priorities ? People raising 16 million, 11 already found thank you generous NZ, for some Art Centre while people are homeless.
Yes, because it was artists who attacked workers’ rights and refused to ensure that wages kept pace with inflation, and failed to build enough state housing.
These false dichotomies (we can have housing or art and not both) are the very stuff of witless populism that made such a dog’s breakfast of the Brexit debate.
Bravo.
Just checked this comment at KB ” Vote: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 11″ 🙂
Perhaps the art centre donors could run a bake sale and give the poor people cake
CV 🙂
AND England got beat by ICELAND in the soccer euro cup.
A lesson for political parties here. Don’t take the game seriously, underestimate the opposition, lose focus with distractions, and finally, blame the manager and not the players themselves.
And lose.
as Monty Python said…..”and Iceland are bringing their spin-dryer on to bowl”
Papa Crimblecheeks FTW!.
Brian Bilston
@brian_bilston
If you ever wondered why the Icelanders are so tough, it’s because they are raised on lullabies like this.
https://twitter.com/brian_bilston/status/747522413043322880
https://brianbilston.files.wordpress.com/2015/12/papa-crimblecheeks.jpg?w=620
Iceland beat England!
Iceland, same population as Wellington!
Leeeeeeeewserrrrrrrs!
Stand by as Jeremy Corbyn gets the blame …
I thought it was john Keys fault…
no, he has no responsibility for anything, how could he be blamed?
He’s claiming not to have even read the Shewan Report in the House & he commissioned it!
Calling my mum a lewsser eh?
Iceland.. lol She got up to watch it, huddled in her blanky, poor thing.
Big mistake widening the competition to 24 teams to let in the lesser football nations like England.
1 hours ago:
“Jeremy Corbyn has vowed to dig in as Labour leader despite the resignations of 46 members of his front bench and an expected vote of no-confidence from the vast majority of his MPs.
Mr Corbyn is facing the biggest rebellion against a party leader in modern UK history, brutal in its scale and determination, yet he has refused to budge. Propped up by a hard core of loyal MPs and by the unions, he said on Monday that he would not leave until he was defeated in a leadership contest. ”
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/568a85c0-3c87-11e6-8716-a4a71e8140b0.html#axzz4Cox2Qvki
If he doesn’t go the Labour party will split.
A Lexit could be on the cards.
Or emerge stronger and more focussed. The pseudo Labour Blarites will be gone.
Aye to that
Lexit – sounds like a trade name for a laxative – you know, getting rid of all the shit.
Good riddance to the Blairites.
There is another excellent but extremely depressing post from Owen Jones on the current state of the Labour Party in the UK.
https://medium.com/@OwenJones84/my-thoughts-on-the-plight-of-labour-38413229f88#.rjpdpzeuw
You’re right Karen. Depressing.
MMP would allow the different factions of the Left to participate.
Wonder if the Conservative Party will splinter?
Nah, if there’s one things that tories the world over know it’s how to swallow dead rats to stay in power.
it’s the only thing they have, but it seems to work for them, like a panza unit.Unfortunately, Labour being a democratic party, allowing for debate, gets interpreted as being rudderless, rather than respectful of others opinions
There’s democratic and then there is stupid which uk labour seems to be.
They had the option of shutting up looking united and pushing for a snap election instead they go for the nuclear option that will likely end in a drawn out bitter leadership challenge.
I wouldn’t be surprised if the tories shuffle in a new leader and call an election while labour is in disarray in the midst of a leadership election.
I agree, self serving Blairites could be the ruin of Labour
There is definitely something wrong with the climate. Apart from being the warmest winter so far, my Garlic which I plant on the shortest day and pick on the longest, normally would not show it’s head until mid/end of July, and that would only be poking just above the surface.
It is now the 28Th June 7 days after the shortest day and it is about 30 mm in growth out of the ground. Worrying times, not for the Garlic but for the planet.
Interesting +1
That suggests your soil temp this year has been 1 deg to 2 deg warmer than normal over this period. Which is utterly massive. And it’s 15 deg C down here at the moment. Which for Dunedin is warm spring time weather.
WTF is wrong with people.
//
http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/06/sanders-staffers-tried-to-rig-the-game-in-nevada.html
Oh boy! An hour ago:
“Britain should have a second referendum on the terms of leaving the European Union if it can secure a deal to control its borders, a Cabinet minister says.
Writing in the Daily Telegraph, Jeremy Hunt, the Health Secretary, becomes the first minister to suggest Britain could hold another vote on Brexit, despite the Leave victory last week.
He says the new prime minister must be allowed to “negotiate a deal” with Brussels and “put it to the British people” either by calling a general election or having another referendum…..”
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=11664894
Privatisation and profiteering strike again:
When will we learn that privatisation always costs us more and thus stop voting for the psychopaths hell bent on selling our stuff?
“Captain Cook Highway”, I dunno if someone has it in for Foster-Bell but he’s pretty good at sticking his head above the parapet. How about Kupe Highway?
“The first the PM knew about Paul Foster-Bell’s idea to rename SH1 ‘Captain Cook Highway’ was today. He’s not keen.” – Newshub
They really needed Paul to hit the news a few weeks ago when either Panama came out or the homeless hit the news. Useful distraction.
10% of NZrs own more than 60% of the wealth, 40% of NZrs own less than 4%. Though Foster-Bell hardly going to distract us from that surely?
It’s OK though, John Key said it was the same under Labour, yup Labour did it too.
Key says it is OK because he reckons it was about the same as when Labour was in power. So it is Labour’s fault.
OOps. gangman snap.
Astounding isn’t it ianmac, so why vote National when you get the same as Labour, so much dissonance & white noise. When shown a problem Key just shrugs his shoulders & sings “It wasn’t me”.
Foreign Minister McCulley fronts up on Checkpoint tonight to explain at length the story of a lowly Embassy staffer was wanted for discussion with S Korean police over a minor matter.
What! You might find that odd given McCulley’s total absence over very serious issues like sheep and Ombudsman reports. Mmmm!
Mmmm alright.
I asked yesterday if… anyone knows what Murray McCully has been up to lately?
I have a suspicion it might be something to do with an Ombudsman, and some minor ‘Kiwi businessman’ in Korea is a convenient distraction?
Yes my point Anne. Very visible on the miniscule. Missing on the big stuff. Typical of them all.