Bregman: Socialism is a great product

Written By: - Date published: 8:08 am, August 21st, 2016 - 147 comments
Categories: quality of life, socialism - Tags: , ,

Extracts from a long piece by Rutger Bregman in The Guardian:

Socialism is a great product. When will the left give it the hard sell?

It’s a perplexing question: why has so little changed since 2008? If your recall is a little hazy, 2008 was the year the world woke up to a banking crisis of epic proportions, a crisis borne of blind faith in market wisdom and an utter lack of public oversight. But in a bizarre twist, the parties who benefited from the bust were the conservatives (the people who glibly told voters it was all the government’s fault) and the xenophobes (who blamed it all on terrorists and immigrants, who steal our jobs yet are too lazy to work).

So why isn’t the left coming up with some real alternatives? There are volumes to be written about this conundrum, but I’d like to venture one simple explanation: the eternal return of underdog socialism.

It’s an international phenomenon, observable among legions of leftwing thinkers and movements, from trade unions to political parties, from columnists to professors. The world view of the underdog socialist is encapsulated in the notion that the establishment has mastered the game of reason, judgment and statistics, leaving the left with emotion. Its heart is in the right place. The underdog socialist always has his or her back against the wall. Warily they watch the neoliberals, the multinationals and the Eurocrats advance, but can’t bring themselves to do much more than whimper: “Come on guys, do we have to?”

The underdog socialist has a surfeit of compassion and finds prevailing policies deeply unfair – seeing the achievements of the 20th century crumbling to dust, and rushing in to salvage what he can. But when push comes to shove, the underdog socialist caves in to the arguments of the opposition, always accepting the premise upon which the debate takes place. “National debt is out of control, but we can make more programmes income-dependent … Fighting poverty is terribly expensive, but it’s part of being a civilised nation … Taxes are high – but each according to his ability.”

But the underdog socialists’ biggest problem isn’t that they are wrong. They are not. Their biggest problem is that they’re dull. Dull as a doorknob. They’ve got no story to tell; nor even the language to convey it in. Having arrived at the conclusion that politics is a mere matter of identity, they have chosen an arena in which they will lose every time.

What the underdog socialist has forgotten is that the story of the left ought to be a narrative of hope and progress. By that I don’t mean a narrative that only excites a few hipsters who get their kicks philosophising about “postcapitalism” after reading some deadly dull tome. The greatest sin of the academic left is that it has become fundamentally aristocratic, writing in bizarre jargon that makes cliches seem abstruse. If you can’t explain your ideal to a fairly intelligent 12-year-old, it’s probably your own fault. What we need is a narrative that speaks to millions of ordinary people. It all starts with reclaiming the language of progress.

Plenty to disagree with perhaps, but plenty to ponder too. Go read the whole thing in The Guardian.

147 comments on “Bregman: Socialism is a great product ”

  1. Sanctuary 1

    The cognitive dissonance of the Guardian is a wonder to behold. That story is a bit rich coming from a paper that has smeared and relentlessly attacked Jeremy Corbyn.

    Perhaps they think the only thing better than socialism is middle class socialists who are safe in the knowledge their “socialist principles” will never actually be implemented or cost them anything.

    • Garibaldi 1.1

      +100 Sanctuary. Hey let’s not forget the Right love Socialism – they actively privatise the profits and socialise the losses.

    • Bill 1.2

      It’s an opinion piece. Many news papers carry them and they have nothing whatsoever to do with editorial positions.

      I see that the post here has focused on the negative analysis contained in the piece, but I really liked the way he turned the ‘accepted’ narrative on its head when it came to reform, meritocracy, innovation, inefficiency, the nanny state and how he re-introduced the central idea of freedom.

    • “We must be bold! No, wait, not that bold, it’s scary. Hold me, Owen Smith!”

  2. OneTrack 2

    The left just need to set out some empirical examples of socialism working in practice. Venezuela? Nope. North Korea? Nope. Sweden? Yes? Well, they were a good example, but then they went full retard progressive and are now the rape capital of the world. So, that’s also a nope. Any other contenders that have been missed?

    • Bill 2.1

      Statism and socialism are mutually exclusive political propositions. All the examples you gave and all the examples I suspect you seek are rooted in statism. So why you’d expect them to offer up examples of socialism working in practice is somewhat beyond me.

      It’s interesting that Chavez tried to use the power of the state to undermine the state though. And sure, he made mistakes and was bloody naive to think that a state/market dependent business community would eventually “do the right thing” and help construct a better future – a 21st C socialism.

      • OneTrack 2.1.1

        I have seen many reports of Venezuela and Sweden being examples of true socialism, admittedly before they went pear-shaped. Ok, if they aren’t really socialism, that leads back to what are the examples of socialism working in practice?

        • joe90 2.1.1.1

          I have seen many reports of Venezuela and Sweden being examples of true socialism, admittedly before they went pear-shaped.

          Best you post a sampling of those many reports you’ve seen.

          • OneTrack 2.1.1.1.1

            In other words, you don’t have any examples of socialism actually working in practice. Maybe Bill can come up with something.

        • Bill 2.1.1.2

          Any time any decision is made with regards production or distribution or even just social organisation, and that decision is made by society (ie – those affected) and without any unjustifiable asymmetry of power coming into play, then that decision will likely be an example of socialism in practice.

          If you’re looking for examples at the nation state level, you won’t find any. And the reason you won’t find any was outlined in my original comment – socialism and statism are mutually exclusive (as is socialism and market forces).

          The best you will find at the nation state level is examples that are less authoritarian/bureaucratic – which is to say less undemocratic.

      • maninthemiddle 2.1.2

        “All the examples you gave and all the examples I suspect you seek are rooted in statism.”

        The problem with this is that statism has many different definitions, however in the sense that statism is defined as “The practice or doctrine of giving a centralized government control over economic planning and policy” (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/statism), then statism and socialism go hand in hand.

        Socialism (in it’s true sense) has failed. It destroyed Soviet Russia. It destroyed the economy of Greece, and it is destroying Venezuela. In fact it has failed everywhere it has been tried. It is a recipe for poverty (China has turned to market economics to alleviate it’s massive poverty) and for tyranny.

        • Bill 2.1.2.1

          Well, fuck me dead, but by the very definition you give, statism and socialism …. look. What don’t you understand about the contradiction that exists between “centralised government” and democracy?

          Statism, not socialism, existed in the USSR – even Lenin announced the intention to construct “state capitalism” in the USSR. Greece was a kind of social democracy when it wasn’t governed by a junta. Venezuela was a corruptocracy before Chavez and the attempted Bolivarian Revolution.

          China? Well, that’s kind of state capitalism in action. Ironic that it’s Chinese economic activity that keeps market capitalism afloat, eh?

          Capitalism always creates poverty as a side effect the inevitable mal- distribution that results from having production and distribution determined by market mechanisms. And tyranny, or the potential for tyranny, comes with any and all forms of governance that embrace levels of authoritarianism.

          Given that socialism at heart is about democratic governance and (among other things) equitable distribution…yup, none of your claims about what would happen in a socialist society make any sense whatsoever.

          • maninthemiddle 2.1.2.1.1

            “What don’t you understand about the contradiction that exists between “centralised government” and democracy?”

            I understand it perfectly. I’m commenting on reality, not theory. Socialism struggles to exist anywhere without statism, simply because it requires the (at least) partial suppression of human intuitive, and the support of mediocrity.

            “Statism, not socialism, existed in the USSR’

            No, it was both, actually, see my point above. Lenin’s comment means nothing, because it was precisely what didn’t happen.

            “China? Well, that’s kind of state capitalism in action.”
            Well it isn’t state ‘socialism’ is it?

            “Ironic that it’s Chinese economic activity that keeps market capitalism afloat, eh?”
            Not sure you can really sustain that argument. But even if you can, it is only because of market policies.

            “Capitalism always creates poverty as a side effect the inevitable mal- distribution that results from having production and distribution determined by market mechanisms. ”
            All economic systems contain poverty, but market economics reduce poverty, as they are doing in China and many other places. Socialism produces poverty. Economic, social, moral, spiritual and intellectual.

            • Bazar 2.1.2.1.1.1

              Well spoken maninthemiddle

              I keep hearing from the left: If we only had true socialism, we’d all be much better off.
              But history is littered with the desiccated remains of countries that tried.
              They tell us It’s never the socialism that failed, but the corruption inside that caused it to fail.

              I only wish they’d acknowledge that when who is rich and who is poor is decided by bigwigs rather than by the market, corruption is going to be systemic.

              As for this article, its a joke.
              It’s proclaiming that socialism’s reason for being unpopular is that it tries to win debates with facts, and that is its downfall. That it should instead be trying to win arguments not with facts, but with emotions.

              Sounds like a snake oil salesman to me. Don’t provide actual facts about the oil, just tell ’em it’ll cure cancer, the common cold, and restore lost hair.

            • Stuart Munro 2.1.2.1.1.2

              Market economics have increased poverty in NZ MiM.

              We have a stupid, backward and corrupt government and are retreating on every significant social indicator.

              A properly regulated market can be constructive – but there is nothing inevitable about it. Housing would be a prime example.

              • maninthemiddle

                “Market economics have increased poverty in NZ MiM.”

                Do you have any evidence for this? Sure, you can demonstrate how the definition of poverty has changed to suit your left wing narrative (interesting that, in light of comments about the unemployment data, eh?) but the level of real need deprivation in NZ is negligible.

                • Stuart Munro

                  Of course, many of the indicators have been massaged by the despicable incompetents of the current government, like unemployment. Not paying benefits has not increased employment.

                  And, you will be at pains to deny the abundant evidence of failure in terms of the widespread poverty that results in massive increases in homelessness and suicide.

                  But they are of course confirmed by robust data like sharply decreasing home ownership, rising age at marriage, and so forth.

                  Market economics in tandem with widespread corruption never achieves anything of value. Only scrupulously regulated and honest markets are ever anything more than a curse.

                  Honest market practices do not generate sinecure opportunities for worthless vermin like Otakaro Limited.

                  • maninthemiddle

                    “…many of the indicators have been massaged by the despicable incompetents of the current government,”

                    So you can’t support your claim, without claiming the data is fake. You really are pathetic.

                    • Stuart Munro

                      Way to ad hom.

                      But your lies will achieve nothing – just like the lie than unemployment has fallen.

                      Home ownership has declined dramatically – this is not because NZers are wealthier.

                      Age at marriage went up ten years after Roger Douglas – pretty significant change – economically driven.

                      These even vicious and vindictive compulsive liars cannot deny.

                      But you should just fuck off, Man in the Middle – we are sick of your lies.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “Age at marriage went up ten years after Roger Douglas…”

                      You seriously are a fwit. I ask you to support your claim that “Market economics have increased poverty in NZ” and you come back with some bs about manipulation of data. You spend most of your time here making claims you cannot substantiate, and that, even on first reading, sound like utter bollocks.

                      Now you blame a rise in the age of people marrying on the (necessary) economic reforms of the 1980’s, reforms that have revitalised NZ. You really are a muppet.

                    • ropata

                      it’s normal to get defensive and angry when your precious belief system is proven to be a sham MITM

                      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_class_in_New_Zealand#Rogernomics_and_Inequality

                    • Stuart Munro

                      I’d be really sorry MITM, that you are so obtuse that you don’t understand the significance of major life shifts between cohorts – were you not routinely abusive and insincere.

                      You give RWNJ a bad name and you lower the standard of discourse here on the Standard.

                      Roger Douglas’s record is one of theft and dishonesty, not performance. Like Chernomyrdin he created a thoroughly corrupt oligarchy that looted the state. NZ has gone backwards since he took power. I understand why, as a festering sore masquerading as a human being, you find him admirable, but as an MP, as a New Zealander, and as an economist Douglas failed. Prior to his palace revolution NZ maintained practical parity with Australia – something we have not approached since – again a robust objective datum that your spleen and microcephaly will move you to reject.

                      Weep for him Standardistas – this is actually the best the Right have to offer.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “it’s normal…”
                      …not to rely on an opinion piece on wikipedia to form your world view.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “Which of the measures you listed changes frequently?”

                      Not the MEASURES, the DEFINITION. The left use whichever measure suits their narrative. Many of the measures are meaningless (such as the 60% rule), and are actually having the effect of discouraging attempts to assist the less well off.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “Roger Douglas’s record is one of theft and dishonesty, not performance. ”

                      Stuart this is just the latest in a long line of false claims you have made.

                      The economic policies of the 1984+ Labour government transformed this country into one that competes above it’s weight within the world economy. We have more choice, more opportunities, and more collective wealth than we would ever have had under the protectionist policies you seem to support. You clearly were not resident in NZ in 1984 to see the impact such policies had had on NZ, the hours the country was from default, the economic disaster that had been wrought by the previous National and Labour governments, who had failed to prepare the economy for life beyond dependency on the commonwealth. I pity your ignorance, I really do.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      …I met Mr. Krüger, the Transvaal president. His Excellency received me cordially enough; but my friend Judge Beyers, the gentleman who presented me, by mentioning that I was on a voyage around the world, unwittingly gave great offense to the venerable statesman, which we both regretted deeply. Mr. Krüger corrected the judge rather sharply, reminding him that the world is flat. “You don’t mean round the world,” said the president; “it is impossible! You mean in the world. Impossible!” he said, “impossible!” and not another word did he utter either to the judge or to me. The judge looked at me and I looked at the judge, who should have known his ground, so to speak, and Mr. Krüger glowered at us both…

                      Captain Joshua Slocum.

                      Please try and keep up.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “Captain Joshua Slocum.”

                      Call the men in white coats.

                • One Anonymous Bloke

                  the definition of poverty has changed to suit your left wing narrative

                  Nope. The IMF and UNICEF and the World Bank are not generally considered to be of the Left, nor has the definition of poverty changed.

                  Nor, for that matter, has the fact that the right are on the wrong side of every issue from slavery to rheumatic fever.

                  • maninthemiddle

                    “…nor has the definition of poverty changed.”

                    Wrong. The definition changes frequently. There is extreme poverty, absolute poverty, the poverty limit, the poverty line, the poverty threshold. There is purchasing power parity, primary poverty, secondary poverty. And of course the poverty line, a concept that dates back to the early 20th century, and was defined as the minimum amount necessary for a family of 4 or 5 people to subsist on (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_threshold). Subsist. Not do without sky tv.

                    “Nor, for that matter, has the fact that the right are on the wrong side of every issue from slavery to rheumatic fever.”

                    Well you’ve got a serious contradiction with your claims the world is in some neo-liberal grip, because poverty is falling faster than ever before in human history (https://ourworldindata.org/world-poverty/).

                    “At present the percentage of the global population living under extreme poverty is likely to fall below 10% according to the World Bank projections released in 2015.”
                    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_threshold

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      “Changes frequently”.

                      Which of the measures you listed changes frequently?

                      I note that the IMF et al state that neo-liberalism stunts economic growth. When have I claimed that it is ubiquitous? Why do you tell so many lies?

                      I further note that when a measure is proposed, and used, say, by UNICEF, to measure the doubling of child poverty in percentage terms between 1984 and the present, you reject the measure and then deny the problem, so your word isn’t worth shit.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      Explain in your own words why the “60% rule” is meaningless. That ought to be good for a laugh.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “Explain in your own words why the “60% rule” is meaningless.”
                      Because poverty is not defined by income, but by deprivation.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      Meanwhile, on Earth, Treasury uses a similar measure.

                      The poverty line is set at 50% of the median equivalised income unit…

                      As previously noted, your word isn’t worth shit.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “Meanwhile, on Earth, Treasury uses a similar measure.”

                      So becasue Treasury us it it must be right? Nah, it’s rubbish as a measure of poverty.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      Nope, I think the fact that Treasury uses it indicates that it’s useful.

                      As a proxy for the level of deprivation, for example.

                      However, it has its limitations. In measuring individual income, for example, you might conclude that Treasury’s model shows that 100% of children are poor. That’s why household income is also a useful proxy for deprivation.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      ” I think the fact that Treasury uses it indicates that it’s useful.”

                      Really? So when Treasury spoke of a decade of deficits Labour left behind in 2008, do you consider that ‘useful’?

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      Why do you tell so many lies? National blamed Labour for a decade of deficits that hadn’t happened yet, which Treasury said were likely because of global economic conditions.

                      You may have swallowed National’s line, because you’re an idiot. Bill English didn’t: he spoke of “the rainy day the government has been saving up for”, but that was to an informed audience, which you’re not.

                      I note your abject failure to address the substance of my argument.

                    • maninthemiddle

                      “National blamed Labour for a decade of deficits that hadn’t happened yet, which Treasury said were likely because of global economic conditions.”

                      Of course they hadn’t, they were predicted. But what was the 2008/09 deficit? Labour’s lasting legacy to NZ? A 3bn deficit.

                      As to why…you’re making shit up.

                      http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=10536181

                      “Unfortunately our external accounts – large trade and current account deficits and net international liabilities of nearly 90 per cent of GDP – are really bad by international standards.”

                      “We are up to our nostrils in debt to the rest of the world at a time when creditors globally have become a lot less indulgent. And now the Crown accounts have turned red too.”

                      “Stronger growth in wages will be almost swallowed up by higher inflation and, with households focused on reducing debt, little will be left for firms chasing the consumer dollar. Private consumption growth is expected to be zero in the year to next March and feeble the two following years.”

                      That was written in October 2008. High inflation and a tanking economy. Remarkable incompetence, even by Labour Party standard.

    • Garibaldi 2.2

      Onetrack. There’s a fair bit of Socialism in NZ. It’s just that it has been derailed by Neoliberalism.

  3. b waghorn 3

    ”If you can’t explain your ideal to a fairly intelligent 12-year-old, it’s probably your own fault. What we need is a narrative that speaks to millions of ordinary people. It all starts with reclaiming the language of progress.”

    or an under educated 45 year old.

  4. david 4

    Politics and the English Language

    It appears that the author of the article is imploring socialists to sell their ideology better with more hopeful messages and manipulation of language.

    George Orwell said it well: “Consider for instance some comfortable English professor defending Russian totalitarianism. He cannot say outright, ‘I believe in killing off your opponents when you can get good results by doing so’. Probably, therefore, he will say something like this:
    ‘While freely conceding that the Soviet regime exhibits certain features which the humanitarian may be inclined to deplore, we must, I think, agree that a certain curtailment of the right to political opposition is an unavoidable concomitant of transitional periods, and that the rigors which the Russian people have been called upon to undergo have been amply justified in the sphere of concrete achievement.’”

    Sharing implies positive connatations: community, voluntary and charity. In reality socialism is an coercive system of redistrubution from the ‘undeserving’ to the ‘deserving’ but mainly to its leaders and its loyal followers. Stalin, Castro, Chavez, Mao never lived like the ordinary man. More like billionaires but with ultimate power.

    • Bill 4.1

      No option but to say this again – statism and socialism are incompatible. All the examples you give are examples of statism, not socialism.

      Let’s try it like this. Socialism implies decisions being made at the social level – by society (ie – democratically) Statism implies decisions being made at the state level – by the state (ie – bureaucratically) .

      You see how one contradicts or negates the other?

      • Damn Stalin for being such a good marketer, right?

        The problem is that people have to realise that Stalin talking about socialism is much like America today talking about Democracy. He built a bunch of socialist trappings to hide an authoritarian regime.

        That doesn’t mean that socialism implies authoritarianism. Quite the opposite, in the long term, it should reduce the need for centralised power structures if it can be pulled off. But what it does require is a surplus of resources.

        • Bill 4.1.1.1

          No point in finger pointing Stalin. He was a natural enough consequence of the Bolsheviks (under Lenin) seeking to establish state capitalism (Lenin’s term for it and also the critical term used by socialists outside the USSR who were condemning the Bolsheviks)

          Here’s a thing that’s never really touched on.

          Mussolini coined the phrase ‘fascism’ in the 30s. And all he really did was dilute the example given by the USSR – so that there was space for a modicum of democracy and, of course, space for the market to operate.

          If you read old socialist literature, the Bolsheviks are condemned for trying to establish, what they, the socialists of old called ‘state capitalism’. Had the term ‘fascism’ been around in the 20s, I’m not sure they wouldn’t have used that term instead to accurately describe what the Bolsheviks were up to.

          But whatever, Mussolini proposed and instituted a somewhat modified, but essentially lighter, more freed up version of what the Bolsheviks were doing, and yet a very large part of the political body that calls itself ‘left’ ran with the basic ideas proposed by the Bolsheviks while at the same time condemning Mussolini.

          Before you ask – I condemn both, being that they’re much of the same thing, and have condemned both ever since I sought any political understanding of the world.

          For what it’s worth, I think that what misleads many people who’d like to think of themselves as ‘left’, is a misplaced notion that anything aligning itself with the political left embodies some intrinsic benevolence … so the USSR could have done things better “if only”…whereas Italy was always going to be monstrous “just because”.

          • Matthew Whitehead 4.1.1.1.1

            That’s a lot more in-depth than I’ve gone into the reasons why authoritarianism and socialism are fundamentally incompatible, but it all rings true. 🙂

            Stalin is definitely the example most people are thinking of when they confuse authoritarianism with socialism, though.

      • BM 4.1.2

        So Labour and the Greens are statists not socialists?

        • Bill 4.1.2.1

          Correct.

        • I’m not sure I’d personally categorise the Greens as statist given that they believe in decentralised decision-making, and the primacy of representation over bureaucracy, but that’s certainly a fair description of Labour, who haven’t even really been effective social democrats since the 80s, let alone socialists. There’s a lot of very different political philosophy that goes into big-G Green movements that make them very distinct from other schools of thought.

      • Bazar 4.1.3

        “Socialism implies decisions being made at the social level”

        I don’t agree with that definition of socialism, and i don’t know any who would.

        The common definition of socialism is the distribution of wealth and services to everyone or the poor. This is usually achieved at the cost of great debt or transferred from the rich.

        ACC for example is a socialist policy. Everyone benefits, but it’s paid for by business owners.
        State housing is another social policy. The poor benefit, but everyone else, mostly the rich pay for it.

        The definition of statism is (from wikipedia):
        “statism is the belief that the state should control either economic or social policy, or both, to some degree”

        So when you say they are incompatible, i have no idea what the hell you’re talking about, because it’s literally impossible for socialist policies to be implemented without calling it statism.

        Personally i think you’re using some fancy mental gymnastics to work around the problem that recognizing that all socialist countries become inherently corrupt.

        • joe90 4.1.3.1

          Everyone benefits, but it’s paid for by business owners.

          So I don’t need to pay my ACC earner premiums or the ACC levy I pay as part of my motor vehicle registrations?.

  5. burt 5

    The sub prime mortgage crisis was caused by socialism. Government instructing state lenders to extend their lending to people who would not normally qualify to make social indicator stats look good. The intervention of good intentions in typically flawed socialist fashion. Then the lovers of social engineering claim it wasn’t their social engineering that wax the problem the same complete half thinkers that blame the US for the complete ( as expected based on every previous example ) failure of socialist Venezuela.

    You rampant social engineering socialists shpuld just once see the horrible failure in the mirror is the reflection of your ideology rather than perpetually blame others and just try one more time with an ideology that’s never worked.

    • joe90 5.1

      The sub prime mortgage crisis was caused by socialism.

      Yeah, nothing at all to do with greed.
      /

      Declaration: Summit on financial markets and the world economy

      […]

      Root Causes of the Current Crisis

      3. During a period of strong global growth, growing capital flows, and prolonged stability earlier this decade, market participants sought higher yields without an adequate appreciation of the risks and failed to exercise proper due diligence. At the same time, weak underwriting standards, unsound risk management practices, increasingly complex and opaque financial products, and consequent excessive leverage combined to create vulnerabilities in the system. Policy-makers, regulators and supervisors, in some advanced countries, did not adequately appreciate and address the risks building up in financial markets, keep pace with financial innovation, or take into account the systemic ramifications of domestic regulatory actions.

      4. Major underlying factors to the current situation were, among others, inconsistent and insufficiently coordinated macroeconomic policies, inadequate structural reforms, which led to unsustainable global macroeconomic outcomes. These developments, together, contributed to excesses and ultimately resulted in severe market disruption.

      http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:Pt8K9B2qqTMJ:www.ft.com/cms/s/0/984c4ee8-b383-11dd-bbc9-0000779fd18c.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=nz&client=firefox-b#axzz4Hv1g92Xn

    • No, the US “sub-prime mortgage crisis” was caused by a real estate bubble, it’s just that defaulting sub-prime borrowers made a convenient scapegoat. (The data backs this up- most lenders were prime lenders, and there should have been enough cushioning from prime lenders to cushion the defaults, if the banks had set up their investment portfolios with some resilience) The whole market was structured around the assumption that property prices would never go down- a moronic assumption that was crying out for a correction.

      People seem to have similar ideas about house values not deflating here in New Zealand. I’d caution them of the same thing: values falling from time to time is necessary to avoid bubbles, otherwise you invite a hard crash. We’re on the way to one right now.

      • burt 5.2.1

        Of course. The state lenders having been told to lend more to low socioeconomic people then just used them as a convienant excuse…, of course there was no political pressure for the socialist lenders to be more socialist and fail like all well meaning but fatally flawed social engineering always does.

        • Oh, I don’t deny that pressure to make subprime loans on Fannie May and Freddie Mac helped overleverage the two companies. The issue was the overleveraging, however, not the existance of subprime loans or even the rate of default, and would have happened even if they only made prime loans. Ergo, the policy of helping people in worse financial conditions into home ownership, while definitely the wrong way to go about things, was not to blame.

          (Incidentally, socialism generally goes wrong in one of two ways: either rich countries flirt with it and mix it into capitalism, getting the worst of both worlds, such as with sub-prime lending, or poorer countries go whole-hog with socialism and face shortages, an inevitable consequence of a political philosophy that’s contingent on an abundance of resources being implemented by those with a shortage. Neither of those doom socialism as a whole, nor justify the wrongs of capitalism. Socialism probably has its own wrongs somewhere, but as it’s not really been tried by the countries equipped to do it, we don’t know what they would be.)

          You seem somewhat confused between social engineering (which is about liberalism and conservatism, so things like allowing gay marriage could be termed “social engineering”, as equally could allowing religious schools) and socialism. (which is arguably the opposite to capitalism) This was a slightly more socialist approach to mortgages, not social engineering.

          • burt 5.2.1.1.1

            I completely disagree gay marriage is social engineering. Quite the opposite in my opinion. Having it illegal for same gender people to live together is social engineering. In the case of gay marriage the church used it leverage on law makers to legislate its agenda. That is sicial engineering. In my opinion you have this completely backward which somewhat explains why you think socialism works I guess.

            • Matthew Whitehead 5.2.1.1.1.1

              …I also disagree that gay marriage is social engineering, hence the scare quotes. What I’m saying is that what that criticism applies to (ie. social policy settings) has nothing to do with mortgage lending.

              You are clearly the one who’s confused.

              As to socialism, I make no judgements if it’s flawed or not, as it’s never been tried. Unlike other political philosophies, marxist socialism is an actual hypothesis that in an abundance of resources an eventual revolution will occur in which ownership of capital is disestablished. Nobody’s actually tried it yet as it was actually set out, so I can’t tell you if it’s successful. I’d be keen to see it tried and would have no objection to living in such an environment.

              What we’ve had instead is social democracy, which as I said, is basically flirting with socialism and usually you can point to the capitalist side of the equation as the reason it fails. (because we have a lot of experience with capitalism failing, such as poverty, inequality, boom and bust, and housing shortages)

              • burt

                Let’s put it to the crowd.

                Allowing two same gender adults to engage together in a legal partnership – social engineering ?

                Or

                Saying it’s illegal for same gender adults to engage together in a legal partnership – social engineering ?

                • Uh burt, nobody here is saying it actually is social engineering. I’m saying that’s the KIND of policy that people HAVE levied that criticism at, as an example to try and get it into your ears that economic policies aren’t “social engineering,” they’re market interventions.

                  • burt

                    You’re wrong again. I was saying having gay marriage is social engineering. You said I was confused – now you’re backing down.

                    But ok, back to the love of other people’s money koolaid. This socialism thing, make home ownership stats look good by intervening in the mortgage market causing a global financial crisis – are you sill saying that’s not socialism or are you going to back down on that too ?

                    • burt

                      Saying making gay marriage illegal is social engineering ….

                    • Colonial Viper

                      this socialism thing, make home ownership stats look good by intervening in the mortgage market causing a global financial crisis

                      Are you calling the shareholders and owners of the big banks and mortgage originators who made $$$hitloads from this mortgaged back security scam “socialists”?

                    • burt []

                      No, I’m calling the state lenders being instructed to lend to low socioeconomic people who wouldn’t get mortgages socialist intervention.

                    • I said that a government lender is “more” socialist. As in it edges vaguely into social democracy, which is basically Capitalism With Some Socialist Icing On Top. The whole thing is still based on capitalism, even if it has a little socialism mixed in to make it taste a little more bearable to the average voter.

                      Burt, I’m gonna assume your reply is clarifying that you think maintaining marriage as a straight-only institution was social engineering. Fine, I actually agree with that. But It’s not relevant to why you were confused. Your confusion is that you think economic intervention is inherently social engineering. It isn’t. Social engineering is about policies that are designed to change social values. Sub-prime mortgage lending was about conserving existing social values like house ownership for the entire middle class, without acknowledging the economic realities of soaring house prices, and it was essentially a purely economic policy with no social effect, to the degree that the two things can be seperated, at least.

                    • Colonial Viper

                      No, I’m calling the state lenders being instructed to lend to low socioeconomic people who wouldn’t get mortgages socialist intervention.

                      But the shareholders and managers of the financial industry massively profited from that decision and drove ahead causing all the fraud and fall out resulting.

                      The financial industry also believes in socialism as it received government bailouts and guarantees in the wake of the crash to the tune of trillions of dollars.

                    • burt []

                      The fact people made profit from lending has got zero to do with the fact it was a socialist intervention. A poorly managed one, like they all normally are.

                      And of course people make pigs of themselves with other people’s money. It’s human nature and the stupidity of socialists is pretending it won’t happen then blaming something other than their repeated stupidity when it happens.

                      But hey, how’s that list of sustainable economies this ‘great product’ has produced coming along.

                    • Stuart Munro

                      You’re just trying to get the freemarket crooks off the hook – the folk who rebundled subprimes as a product made a killing and created the conditions for the crash. The state should’ve gone after them with a vengeance – but a generation of weak regulators has got out of the habit of effectual government.

                      We see the same incompetence in housing – this government chooses not to be more than epiphenomenal. The public will not tolerate this kind of failure indefinitely.

                    • “People making profit off it” is indeed the basic objection. You see there was capital, (property capable of generating wealth) and it was bought using government backing, then the debts were repackaged and sold for a profit while removing the risk. The concept of saleable debt doesn’t even exist in a purely socialistic system- everyone is expected to be indebted to everyone else, because you’re all doing unmonetized favours and creating gift and obligation constantly, improving each other’s lives. Like charity, except nobody is expected to feel overly pious for giving, or ashamed for needing help. There is property rights, but only to things that don’t generate wealth. So you can own a raincoat, but not a tailor shop. A door, but not a house. An oven, but not a bakery. etc…

                      I would disagree that the financial services industry believes in socialism, though. They believe in corporatism, whose mantra is essentially “privatise the gains, socialise the losses.” Charter schools are a great example.

          • Nic the NZer 5.2.1.1.2

            I am afraid your understanding of the causes of the GFC is not good. The actual cause is not the sub-prime lending or leverage at all. It was the pervasive behaviour of fraudlent lending. The crisis occurred when the practice of writing liars loans (as they were known in the industry) meaning loans where the borrowers income is not verified (though it could have easily been verified) caught up with the major financial players involved.
            This looks like lending with excessive leverage (because if there was sufficient reserves put aside the accounts would show the institution losing money, the expected value of the loans was negative), but its the underlying fraud driving the problems.
            It doesnt make sense to think of this as excessive risk because there are a bunch of sure things involved,
            * the institution will in the short term report extreme profits
            * the executives will be rewarded by modern executive compensation with large bonuses
            * the institution will lose money when the true value of the loans becomes recognised.

    • Bill 5.3

      What strange expression of socialism is it that could exist in the context of a market economy Burt?

      I’m fascinated!

      • burt 5.3.1

        Big state lenders are not a result of the market economy. They are an instrument of state intervention. And they failed…. Gee, wow, it’s not like we’ve had More than a century of watching state intervention fail so we could never have know it would end that way.

        So funny you guys see big state lenders as a market driven thing. I bet you think NZ social welfare is a market force too.

        • Colonial Viper 5.3.1.1

          stop kowtowing at the temple of the free market gods. They are false gods promulgated by the 0.1% and their top 10% professional servants.

          • burt 5.3.1.1.1

            So, no chance you can list the sustainable socialist economies them – just take a shot at me it’s easier and you don’t need to admit you’ve got not one single example to hold up for this ‘great product’ you’ve seen fail over and over but want to believe in.

            • Colonial Viper 5.3.1.1.1.1

              It’s not about following historical examples, it is about realising that your kowtowing at the temple of capitalist free markets is destroying every ecosystem in the world.

              The wealthy power holders of the worlds have gutted the financial and monetary markets of the world simply to pump up the numbers games for their own portfolios.

              Stop embarrassing yourself pleading on behalf of this venal priesthood.

            • Matthew Whitehead 5.3.1.1.1.2

              Tell you what Burt, next time you come up with an idea, how about we all come along and follow you around, ensuring nobody really tries to do it how you intended to do it, take over anyone making serious headway and turn your idea into something completely different, oh, and illegally detain anyone who makes any progress towards actually achieving it despite those challenges.

              That’s basically what’s happened to attempts at socialist governments throughout history. If people had screwed over early capitalists so much, there wouldn’t have been any functioning examples of a capitalist society, either.

        • State lenders are absolutely part of a market economy if they follow the market rules. It doesn’t matter where their setup capital comes from if they operate as a lender as opposed to a social welfare agency. They would have made the same mistakes even if they weren’t biased towards subprime lending due to the capitalist policy that even helping people into homes needs to be managed through loans, as opposed to building cheaper homes!

          • burt 5.3.1.2.1

            State lenders are part of the market economy because … Oh I know why – because they lend to people the market wouldn’t then they wonder why their loans were being defaulted on – just like people would do with their own money… You don’t get the distinction between people using their own money and the state using other people’s money to intervene in the market.

            • Matthew Whitehead 5.3.1.2.1.1

              The state IS us. The state investing in something is us collectively as a nation deciding, through our representatives, to invest in something.

              There’s a distinction, sure. It’s government involving itself in markets, sure. But it doesn’t cease being a market just because one of the competitors is owned by the government, so long as it follows at least as many rules and regulations as everyone else. And if a few more are added, so what? The same could happen at any corporate strategy meeting or by the direction of an owner in an single-owner business. What it does become is a social-democratic market instead of a purely libertarian market, but here’s the thing, both of those are capitalist markets, because social democracy is a subset of capitalism, not a subset of socialism, primarily because it still believes in market capitalist solutions like mortgage lending.

              • burt

                We’re making progress. We’ve gone from state lenders being the market to acknowledgement they are an intervention in the market. A few more small steps and the reality that intervention was actually the root cause of the crisis will start to become clear. See, if political pressure to improve home ownership stats in low income groups didn’t force the lenders to lend to them – there wouldn’t have been catastrophic levels of default. Furthermore, giving people who couldn’t afford to buy a house mortgages would, and did, inflate the market compounding the problem.

                • An intervention in the market is still participating in a market-based system, Burt. You’re not making any progress at all. It only ceases being a market-based system when the government achieves monopoly over a service. (and arguably, it still is a market-based system if it’s still user-pays when provided by the government, like say Telecom or the postal service were)

                  Our government intervenes in the market in any number of ways, (and I mean specifically the National Government here, not “all New Zealand governments”) and it’s usually only the most corporatist interventions that cause market failures or exacerbate booms and busts. Leaving a market unregulated or untaxed to too high a degree absolutely causes its own problems, for instance the housing market in Auckland and Wellington is overheated, in part due to a lack of taxation on capital, financial transactions, and a set of rental regulations that’s reasonably friendly to and flexible for landlords.

                  That said, I do agree with you that subprime lending helped inflate the market. But the same crash would have happened without subprime lending- it was merely an accelerating factor on a market that was about to crest the hill and head back downwards, not the straw that broke the camel’s back. It basically just pushed up prices even faster for the prime lending that had been done assuming no property deflation ever, which was the real problem.

        • Bill 5.3.1.3

          You miss the comments I’ve made on this thread where I point to the incompatibility of socialism with both statism and market economies?

          Maybe I need to don the mod cap and get rid of all the trolling smash you’ve scattered over this thread and fling you into the sin bin? Or maybe you’ll start to actually read stuff and respond to what’s being said instead of marching out that army of wee straw men?

          Choose.

          • burt 5.3.1.3.1

            You don’t like it when people disagree with you. Sorry about that.

            • Bill 5.3.1.3.1.1

              No Burt. What I don’t like is when people insist on peddling half baked bullshit off the back of deliberate mis-representations.

              I quite like disagreement – things can get learned or understandings can get improved off the back of disagreement.

              • burt

                Bill

                If you don’t like people peddling half baked bullshit then please explain how there is a post calling socialism a great product when nobody seems willing to list all the sustainable economies it has produced.

                By all means trash the thread and remove my comments, I seldom come here now and having some jumped up lprent style mod throw the threats around is what I expect. Happy to stay away for another year or 2 when that sort of bully crap happens here after half a dozen comments in a single thread.

                • Bill

                  There are informal “socialist” economies in operation around you right now Burt – they’ve persisted in spite of tweedle dee and tweedle dum (the state and the market) essentially capturing almost all avenues of economic activity across the entire globe.

              • stigie

                Pity you didn’t read Burts comments properly, you may have learnt something.

          • mikesh 5.3.1.3.2

            “You miss the comments I’ve made on this thread where I point to the incompatibility of socialism with both statism and market economies?”

            Market economies are economies in which economic decisions are made in accordance with market forces. I suppose one might imagine a continuum with full central planning at one end and complete laissez faire at the other, but with most countries lying somewhere in between. Of course these in between countries would be ones with regulated economies, with some things provided collectively while other things are left to the market. The trouble is that if we get rid of market forces altogether and move to central planning we end up with statism; and a move in the other direction is a move towards anarchy.

            I don’t know where socialism lies on the continuum, but I suspect it’s something we would feel our way towards in small steps. I suspect the first step would be to try and eliminate unearned income, or rentier income.

            • Bill 5.3.1.3.2.1

              Socialism doesn’t lie anywhere on that state/market continuum.

              Like I say, I’m of the opinion that many good people who would think of themselves as ‘left’ endorse some quite misanthropic political propositions on the mistaken belief that if the propositions are labeled as being ‘left’, then some intrinsic benevolence or goodness must be a part of the mix.

              But the only thing ‘left’ about statism is the label that’s gets attached to it – there is nothing intrinsically benign or worthy about it.

              • mikesh

                “But the only thing ‘left’ about statism is the label that’s gets attached to it – there is nothing intrinsically benign or worthy about it.”

                Perhaps not, but we are not going to wake up one morning – the morning after an election, perhaps – and say to ourselves that while we were capitalist yesterday, from today we are socialists. This means we would be operating within the continuum for a while, and making small changes.

                It is difficult to imagine any sort of society, socialist or otherwise, operating outside the continuum. Even Cuba, which is probably the nearest thing we have to socialism, has a government. And unless we can imagine a non-capitalist, non-statist society it is difficult to see how we would get there.

    • The New Student 5.4

      Socialism does not permit sub-prime mortgages. These people would have been better supported to home ownership, negating any need for such risky traps.

      • Bill 5.4.1

        With socialism we’d probably seek to ensure that we all had homes. But home ownership? Nah.

        Home ownership implies some type of market economy, and as pointed out in a few comments, we can’t have both a market economy and socialism.

        On the same note, we don’t have socialism if some state run apparatus is providing everyone with a home.

        • burt 5.4.1.1

          Can you explain how the state proving people homes isn’t socialism.

          • Bill 5.4.1.1.1

            States operate through bureaucrats. The asymmetry of power that defines the relationship between an individual or a community and a bureaucracy is pretty marked and flies directly in the face of socialist principles of democracy.

            So, you’re ‘favoured’ or have ‘connections’ in a society managed and ordered by a state? You’re home arrives quicker or is better located etc, etc.

            Want a more marked example?

            • Phil 5.4.1.1.1.1

              he asymmetry of power that defines the relationship between an individual or a community and a bureaucracy is pretty marked and flies directly in the face of socialist principles of democracy.

              This is great ‘n’ all, but we live in 2016. Life is complicated and choice (for some more than others) abounds.

              How on earth are you going to implement any kind of socialist system that co-ordinates and delivers acceptable (to you) outcomes without a bureaucracy?!

    • Nic the NZer 5.5

      If that is actually your belief Burt (as opposed to a position you take to troll left wingers) then you have been bull shitted by people actually responsible for the crisis in a self interested arse covering exercise.

      http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2011/12/fannie-and-freddie-fantasies.html

  6. burt 6

    If socialism is a great product then list the sustainable economies that are proof. Perhaps use Twitter because 140 characters will still leave plenty of room for smiley faces etc.

  7. coffee connoissuer 7

    And change the paradigm.
    There have been debt jubilies in the past.

    Forgive debt.

    Change from a debt based currency system to a non debt based or positive monetary system.

    get the system Generate an income for every person

    enable everyone to
    product hubs and service hubs using mobile app based technology (Ensure everyone has the right to a smartphone)

    develop a single user interface to connect to existing product hubs (Trademe, ebay, amazon, Ali Expressand servicehubs for every person. (make it personalisable).

    Connect suppliers to a single User Interace that easily enavbles them to upload stock intems and manage orders.

    expand DOC.
    have unemployed trained in horticulture and permaculture
    epand recycling
    build parks
    grow food.
    make the food available for free.

    automate and expand the transport system.

    Focus the system on delivering personal freedom for everyone

    Have the system enable people to live the lives they want to live

    actively automate peoples jobs but enable people to still be able to do them as well should they desire.

    Life is about experience! What is the experience you want to have….?

    There’s no rules people. Theres only those you choose to follow.

    Its time to build a better world.

    Imagine a would with no borders no boundries just freedom and the time to explore.

    Imagine the world as our playground.

    Free

    • burt 7.1

      Just let me know when you plan this social engineering of forgiving debt because I’d like to borrow a few billion just before that.

      • coffee connoissuer 7.1.1

        I’m sure everyone would.

        See the thing is Money is simply the system we use to live.
        but it is a barrier to being able to obtain the things we want and more importantly need.

        To overcome the barrier in the current system you have to get a job and give up your time. Your life to make money. To pay for simply living.
        To lead a normal lifeyou have to be enslaved by costs that keep you working.
        If you do well even more is taken from you.

        Its probably the dumbest system you could design for mankind in this day and age with the technology we have.

        Noone said it (The monetary system) has to be derived through debt and the redistribution of wealth.

        Or would you rather work s a slave for the rest of your life. And your children too.

        As there are more people on the planet and the cost of Labour goes down whilst automation continues to increase. each future generation will become more enslaved through debt than the last.

        Wake up to the reality you live in.

        Everyone has a choice live the rest of your lives like you are now. Or make the changes that enable you to be free.

        Imagine only needing to work 3 days on and having four days off,
        Its possible now with available technology and would increase over time with a focus on automation.

        but to do it. you need to ensure everyone can have the things they need in order to live.

        If your goal is to free people why keep them enslaved by debt

        • BM 7.1.1.1

          but to do it. you need to ensure everyone can have the things they need in order to live.

          That’s the tricky part there.

          • mauī 7.1.1.1.1

            I don’t think it’s hard at all. If we wanted to we could provide basic housing for everyone very cheaply. We could do the same with food, with people growing their own and removing barriers to get the rest of our food for next to nothing. With those needs met people can do something more constructive with their lives than the current work they’re in. Which in most cases is wasting resources and destroying our environment for some negligible feelings of wealth.

        • burt 7.1.1.2

          Did you recently leave the minister of finance role in Venezuela ?

          Your idealism is good and hang onto it, but do try and remember we live in a real world not an ideological fantasy where everybody can have everything they need if we just write ourselves a few cool rules.

          The state of humanity didn’t just arrive at today based on some silly rules your hated 1% made up for themselves – they too climbed the framework that was in place and it’s not something we can just rework based on ideals that have never previously produced sustainable economies or social order.

          • Stuart Munro 7.1.1.2.1

            Makes a superficially plausible story – but the current world economy isn’t sustainable anyway – hence collapsing trade volumes and negative interest rates. It’s going to have to change.

          • Matthew Whitehead 7.1.1.2.2

            Actually many of them merely inherited their wealth, so no climbing involved, most of them never produced or even substantially contributed to producing anything sustainable in their life, so go troll about sugar shortages in Venezuela somewhere else.

        • In Vino 7.1.1.3

          Just asking, Coffee, is there a reason why ‘Connoisseur’ is misspelt?

      • bwahahaha

        Forgiving debt isn’t social engineering, it’s economic policy. Please crack open a textbook or an encyclopaedia if you want to sit at the big kids’ table, you’re embarassing yourself.

        Good luck persuading anyone to loan you a billion anything, with or without debt forgiveness on the table. Especially if you can’t tell the difference between social policy and economic policy.

  8. Paul 8

    Does anyone else see striking similarities between the followers of fundamental religion and the slavish supporters of neo-liberalism who come on this site?

    • Reddelusin 8.1

      Oh the irony in your comment Paul, I think the difference between RWNJ and LWNJ is that by far the majority of righties have probably been lefty at some time, young and stupid as they say but eventually grow up and have a bit of balance and contrast, hard left unfortunately not so , the indoctrination, stupidity, institutionalisation, hate and green monster is just to strong. saying that you do get sense from the likes of Cv and Bill ( statism vs socialism is thought provoking)

      • RedLogix 8.1.1

        I must be wired wrong. I started out quite the little Tory snot and been heading left ever since.

        • burt 8.1.1.1

          Wealthy parents ?

        • Reddelusion 8.1.1.2

          There are always outliers red, as per burt maybe wealthy parents (thus rebel syndrome) and possibly catholic guilt complex ? 😀

          • b waghorn 8.1.1.2.1

            Or maybe he opened his heart as well as his brain, to be a good right winger you have to believe that the poor deserve it .

            • Paul 8.1.1.2.1.1

              He’s trolling.

              • b waghorn

                trolls are a great opportunity to wack them around their heads with their own belief systems, never let them offend you or the dicks will think they are winning.

            • Reddelusion 8.1.1.2.1.2

              Citation please beyond self serving lefty poop literature Righties care about the poor more so than Chardonnay socialist hence their fight to keep as such away from the levers of power as to not increase the cohort of poor through idiotic discredited iideology, social and economic policy, while at the same time helping out but not hand out to those who need it . The we care moral arguement, with other name calling ( facist, troll ) is lefty default argument when the absurdity of thier views become apparent

              • b waghorn

                At least that comments slightly more coherent than yesterday’s , sober sunday is it?

                • ropata

                  RD thinks record levels of child poverty and homelessness is actually good for society. He thinks we should do nothing because he “cares for the poor”.

                  We are so blessed to have RD’s words of wisdom.

          • BM 8.1.1.2.2

            You’re on the money there, RedLogix has been quite open with the fact that he’s never had to struggle.

            • RedLogix 8.1.1.2.2.1

              Yes … and for that I’ve always been aware of how fortunate I am.

              My parents were never wealthy. My father lived the first few years of his life in a tent in Ranfurly Rd, Epsom. Yes a tent. And then went on to be orphaned not once, but twice. My mother’s life was no easier, and when they married they had less than 10 quid between them.

              But both were intelligent and responsible people who worked to gain a sound education. Both started out as teachers and were able to work their way modestly up the middle-class ladder. But never was there any money to splash around.

              I grew up in Epsom with all that educational and social head-start that implies. Yet it was never Remuera either. Anglican church, scouting, tramping, sports and few adventures. It was in many ways a sheltered upbringing; but not an insulated one either.

              While University was relatively cheap, I still cleaned my way through most of the toilets in downtown Auckland to pay my way. A stint at Westfield, a summer working in shearing sheds, another drilling holes in printed circuit boards. Little was ever handed to me on a plate, and enough to gain a respect for real working class people who have to do these hard, shitty jobs all their lives.

              weka would say I’m privileged, and from her perspective I can see why she’d say that. But it rarely felt that way. And this small safe world I was lucky to grow up in is mostly gone now, but I’ll bet it’s one that is very familiar to many of the lefties here. It was a world where the social gradients were nowhere near so steep, and there were still ladders with rungs close enough to work your way up. Twice in my adult life I’ve been reduced to virtually nothing, but neither could I say I struggled. I’ve enjoyed good health and a skill set I that would find me an income if I worked at it.

              Here’s the PencilSword which precisely encapsulates this for me:

              http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/the-pencilsword-on-a-plate

              So no to struggle. But equally yes I was brought up with empathy for those who do and when I got to the last panel of this it hurt.

              • Ad

                You need not apologize to anyone for your life.
                Terriffic to hear there are still stories of upward social mobility out there.

                Great link.

                • RedLogix

                  I really didn’t see it as an apology. It would be too easy to reply to redelusion, BM or burt in kind. We’ve all indulged in that plenty. I just don’t feel like so much of that point scoring at the moment.

                  The last para from the original Guardian article the OP references nails it for me:

                  But first, the underdog socialists will have to stop wallowing in their moral superiority. Everyone who reckons themselves progressive should be a beacon of not just energy but ideas, not only indignation but hope, and equal parts ethics and hard sell. Ultimately, what the underdog socialist lacks is the most vital ingredient for political change: the conviction that there truly is a better way.

                  • BM

                    With two parents as teachers you had no chance of being anything but left.

                    Hard to overcome that sort of ingraining, you poor sod. 😛

                    • RedLogix

                      Actually no … the big leftie influence in my life was another man. Someone probably wealthier than John Key in purely cash terms.

                      Your stereotypes aren’t serving you that well.

                    • In Vino

                      Well done RedLogix. You have illustrated a healthier society that we used to have. The cynicism of those who accused you of always having been well off is exposed, and they expose themselves as shallow spin-artists. Trolls, in fact. But we all knew that…

              • weka

                “weka would say I’m privileged”

                Would she? Everyone has privilege (it being relative) but it’s not the first thing that comes to mind reading your story.

          • burt 8.1.1.2.3

            Neither of those. Quite the opposite.

  9. Ad 9

    “The biggest problem is that they are dull.
    Dull as a doorknob.”

    That is a really dumb comment.

    Dullness is often rewarded in politics, because people rarely want a lot of change in their lives. Just to speak for New Zealand, the reason we have MMP is to ensure our politics is dull – it’s a system designed to ensure that another Structural Adjustment never ever happens again. We are consigned to mild politics, by design.

    Dull people gravitate to politics on the left because they have an inevitable worthy sense of their own righteousness. That makes them dull before they even exhale. (Make no mistake the world would not become good without such dull people). But don’t expect Elvis the Comeback Special out of Labour. (In Canada last time the socialists were a sitter, but then Elvis Trudeau arrived)

    Corbyn is dull. Hillary is dull. LIttle and the Australian guy is dull. Hollande is dull dull dull.
    Their collective dullness has little to do with whether they will win or lose.

    Analogue reverse: Trump is exciting, and that new nut-job in the Philippines is exciting. But their exciting nut-job-ness is simply not appropriate on the left.

    Better question: can they lead people? Do people follow them?
    Watch them lead, then watch them win.

    As for Socialism, if all you want to do is boil that into a bromide of “share with people”, then anyone who gives up their seat on a train is a Socialist. Dull and dumb.

    IMHO the left would do better if it concentrated whole lot less on policy engines like “socialism”, and started putting into practise some leadership skills inside its own party.

    • Bill 9.1

      Smithy!!!

    • ropata 9.2

      You should be pretty happy with the current level of clickbait politics then. You could be the next Mike Hosking with such deep insight.

      Meanwhile boring old Steve Hansen keeps the AB’s ticking over and winning everything in sight

      • Ad 9.2.1

        Dullness has nothing to do with success in anything in politics.
        The columnist is wrong.

        Little is winning, despite being dull, because he can lead people.

  10. Siobhan 10

    “Ultimately, what the underdog socialist lacks is the most vital ingredient for political change: the conviction that there truly is a better way.’…such an odd comment.
    Corbyn for one is all about ‘conviction that there truly is a better way’. And he is convincing. The last hustings illustrated that, when exposed to his so called ‘dullness’ the majority of undecideds moved to his side.

    Seems to me the only people who lack conviction that there is a better way are the endlessly compromising so called lefties of the neo-liberal variety. They seem to suffer total panic attacks when someone with a new plan comes along.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • At a glance – Does CO2 always correlate with temperature?
    On February 14, 2023 we announced our Rebuttal Update Project. This included an ask for feedback about the added "At a glance" section in the updated basic rebuttal versions. This weekly blog post series highlights this new section of one of the updated basic rebuttal versions and serves as a ...
    4 hours ago
  • Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6.06 pm on Tuesday, March 19
    TL;DR: In today’s ‘six-stack’ of substacks at 6.06pm on Tuesday, March 19:Kāinga Ora’s dry rot The Spinoff DailyBill McKibben on ‘Climate Superfunds’ making Big Oil pay for climate damage The Crucial YearsPreston Mui on returning to 1980s-style productivity growth NoahpinionAndy Boenau on NIMBYs needing unusual bedfellows Urbanism SpeakeasyNed Resnikoff's case ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 hours ago
  • Relentlessly negative
    Negative yesterday, negative today. Negative all year, according to one departing reader telling me I’ve grown strident and predictable. Fair enough. If it’s any help, every time I go to write about a certain topic that begins with C and ends with arrrrs, I do brace myself and ask: Again? Are ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    7 hours ago
  • Scoring 4.6 out of 10, the new Government is struggling in the polls
    Bryce Edwards writes –  It’s been a tumultuous time in politics in recent months, as the new National-led Government has driven through its “First 100 Day programme”. During this period there’s been a handful of opinion polls, which overall just show a minimal amount of flux in public support ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    7 hours ago
  • Promiscuous Empathy: Chris Trotter Replies To His Critics.
    Inspirational: The Family of Man is a glorious hymn to human equality, but, more than that, it is a clarion call to human freedom. Because equality, unleavened by liberty, is a broken piano, an unstrung harp; upon which the songs of fraternity will never be played. “Somebody must have been telling lies about ...
    8 hours ago
  • Don’t run your business like a criminal enterprise
    The Detail this morning highlights the police's asset forfeiture case against convicted business criminal Ron Salter, who stands to have his business confiscated for systemic violations of health and safety law. Business are crying foul - but not for the reason you'd think. Instead of opposing the post-conviction punishment and ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    8 hours ago
  • Misremembering Justinian’s Taxes.
    Tax Lawyer Barbara Edmonds vs Emperor Justinian I - Nolo Contendere: False historical explanations of pivotal events are very far from being inconsequential.WHEN BARBARA EDMONDS made reference to the Roman Empire, my ears pricked up. It is, lamentably, very rare to hear a politician admit to any kind of familiarity ...
    8 hours ago
  • Bryce Edwards: Scoring 4.6 out of 10, the new Government is struggling in the polls
    It’s been a tumultuous time in politics in recent months, as the new National-led Government has driven through its “First 100 Day programme”. During this period there’s been a handful of opinion polls, which overall just show a minimal amount of flux in public support for the various parties in ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    9 hours ago
  • Bishop scores headlines with crackdown on unwelcome tenants – but Peters scores, too, as tub-thump...
    Buzz from the Beehive Housing Minister Chris Bishop delivered news – packed with the ingredients to enflame political passions – worthy of supplanting Winston Peters in headline writers’ priorities. He popped up at the post-Cabinet press conference to promise a crackdown on unruly and antisocial state housing tenants. His ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    10 hours ago
  • Will it make the boat go faster?
    Ele Ludemann writes – The Reserve Bank is advertising for a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion advisor. The Bank has one mandate – to keep inflation between one and three percent. It has failed in that and is only slowly getting inflation back down to the upper limit. Will it ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    13 hours ago
  • Bryce Edwards: Is Simon Bridges’ NZTA appointment a conflict of interest?
    Last week former National Party leader Simon Bridges was appointed by the Government as the new chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi (NZTA). You can read about the appointment in Thomas Coughlan’s article, Simon Bridges to become chair of NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi The fact that a ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    13 hours ago
  • Is Simon Bridges’ NZTA appointment a conflict of interest?
    Bryce Edwards writes – Last week former National Party leader Simon Bridges was appointed by the Government as the new chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi (NZTA). You can read about the appointment in Thomas Coughlan’s article, Simon Bridges to become chair of NZ Transport Agency ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    13 hours ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' at 10:10am on Tuesday, March 19
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Gavin Jacobson talks to Thomas Piketty 10 years on from Capital in the 21st Century The SalvoLocal scoop: Green MP’s business being investigated over migrant exploitation claims Stuff Steve KilgallonLocal deep-dive: The commercial contractors making money from School ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    14 hours ago
  • Bernard's six newsy things on Tuesday, March 19
    It’s a home - but Kāinga Ora tenants accused of “abusing the privilege” may lose it. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The Government announced a crackdown on Kāinga Ora tenants who were unruly and/or behind on their rent, with Housing Minister Chris Bishop saying a place in a state ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    15 hours ago
  • New Life for Light Rail
    This is a guest post by Connor Sharp of Surface Light Rail  Light rail in Auckland: A way forward sooner than you think With the coup de grâce of Auckland Light Rail (ALR) earlier this year, and the shift of the government’s priorities to roads, roads, and more roads, it ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    16 hours ago
  • Why Are Bosses Nearly All Buffoons?
    Note: As a paid-up Webworm member, I’ve recorded this Webworm as a mini-podcast for you as well. Some of you said you liked this option - so I aim to provide it when I get a chance to record! Read more ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    18 hours ago
  • Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6.06 pm on March 18
    TL;DR: In my ‘six-stack’ of substacks at 6.06pm on Monday, March 18:IKEA is accused of planting big forests in New Zealand to green-wash; REDD-MonitorA City for People takes a well-deserved victory lap over Wellington’s pro-YIMBY District Plan votes; A City for PeopleSteven Anastasiou takes a close look at the sticky ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • Peters holds his ground on co-governance, but Willis wriggles on those tax cuts and SNA suspension l...
    Buzz from the Beehive Here’s hoping for a lively post-cabinet press conference when the PM and – perhaps – some of his ministers tell us what was discussed at their meeting today. Until then, Point of Order has precious little Beehive news to report after its latest monitoring of the ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    1 day ago
  • Labour’s final report card
    David Farrar writes –  We now have almost all 2023 data in, which has allowed me to update my annual table of how  went against its promises. This is basically their final report card. The promise The result Build 100,000 affordable homes over 10 ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    2 days ago
  • “Drunk Uncle at a Wedding”
    I’m a bit worried that I’ve started a previous newsletter with the words “just when you think they couldn’t get any worse…” Seems lately that I could begin pretty much every issue with that opening. Such is the nature of our coalition government that they seem to be outdoing each ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    2 days ago
  • Wang Yi’s perfectly-timed, Aukus-themed visit to New Zealand
    Geoffrey Miller writes – Timing is everything. And from China’s perspective, this week’s visit by its foreign minister to New Zealand could be coming at just the right moment. The visit by Wang Yi to Wellington will be his first since 2017. Anniversaries are important to Beijing. ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    2 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell on Dune 2, and images of Islam
    Depictions of Islam in Western popular culture have rarely been positive, even before 9/11. Five years on from the mosque shootings, this is one of the cultural headwinds that the Muslim community has to battle against. Whatever messages of tolerance and inclusion are offered in daylight, much of our culture ...
    2 days ago
  • New Rail Operations Centre Promises Better Train Services
    Last week Transport Minster Simeon Brown and Mayor Wayne Brown opened the new Auckland Rail Operations Centre. The new train control centre will see teams from KiwiRail, Auckland Transport and Auckland One Rail working more closely together to improve train services across the city. The Auckland Rail Operations Centre in ...
    2 days ago
  • Bernard's six newsy things at 6.36am on Monday, March 18
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: Retiring former Labour Finance Minister Grant Robertson said in an exit interview with Q+A yesterday the Government can and should sustain more debt to invest in infrastructure for future generations. Elsewhere in the news in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy at 6:36am: Read more ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: Wang Yi’s perfectly-timed, Aukus-themed visit to New Zealand
    Timing is everything. And from China’s perspective, this week’s visit by its foreign minister to New Zealand could be coming at just the right moment. The visit by Wang Yi to Wellington will be his first since 2017. Anniversaries are important to Beijing. It is more than just a happy ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    2 days ago
  • The Kaka’s diary for the week to March 25 and beyond
    TL;DR: The key events to watch in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy in the week to March 18 include:China’s Foreign Minister visiting Wellington today;A post-cabinet news conference this afternoon; the resumption of Parliament on Tuesday for two weeks before Easter;retiring former Labour Finance Minister Grant Robertson gives his valedictory speech in Parliament; ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Bitter and angry; Winston First
    New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters’s state-of-the-nation speech on Sunday was really a state-of-Winston-First speech. He barely mentioned any of the Government’s key policies and could not even wholly endorse its signature income tax cuts. Instead, he rehearsed all of his complaints about the Ardern Government, including an extraordinary claim ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    2 days ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #11
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 10, 2024 thru Sat, March 16, 2024. Story of the week This week we'll give you a little glimpse into how we collect links to share and ...
    2 days ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #11
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 10, 2024 thru Sat, March 16, 2024. Story of the week This week we'll give you a little glimpse into how we collect links to share and ...
    2 days ago
  • Out of Touch.
    “I’ve been internalising a really complicated situation in my head.”When they kept telling us we should wait until we get to know him, were they taking the piss? Was it a case of, if you think this is bad, wait till you get to know the real Christopher, after the ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    3 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • The bewildering world of Chris Luxon – Guns for all, not no lunch for kids
    .“$10 and a target that bleeds” - Bleeding Targets for Under $10!.Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.This government appears hell-bent on either scrapping life-saving legislation or reintroducing things that - frustrated critics insist - will be dangerous and likely ...
    Frankly SpeakingBy Frank Macskasy
    3 days ago
  • Expert Opinion: Ageing Boomers, Laurie & Les, Talk Politics.
    It hardly strikes me as fair to criticise a government for doing exactly what it said it was going to do. For actually keeping its promises.”THUNDER WAS PLAYING TAG with lightning flashes amongst the distant peaks. Its rolling cadences interrupted by the here-I-come-here-I-go Doppler effect of the occasional passing car. ...
    3 days ago
  • Manufacturing The Truth.
    Subversive & Disruptive Technologies: Just as happened with that other great regulator of the masses, the Medieval Church, the advent of a new and hard-to-control technology – the Internet –  is weakening the ties that bind. Then, and now, those who enjoy a monopoly on the dissemination of lies, cannot and will ...
    3 days ago
  • A Powerful Sensation of Déjà Vu.
    Been Here Before: To find the precedents for what this Coalition Government is proposing, it is necessary to return to the “glory days” of Muldoonism.THE COALITION GOVERNMENT has celebrated its first 100 days in office by checking-off the last of its listed commitments. It remains, however, an angry government. It ...
    3 days ago
  • Can you guess where world attention is focussed (according to Greenpeace)? It’s focussed on an EPA...
    Bob Edlin writes –  And what is the world watching today…? The email newsletter from Associated Press which landed in our mailbox early this morning advised: In the news today: The father of a school shooter has been found guilty of involuntary manslaughter; prosecutors in Trump’s hush-money case ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    3 days ago
  • Further integrity problems for the Greens in suspending MP Darleen Tana
    Bryce Edwards writes – Is another Green MP on their way out? And are the Greens severely tarnished by another integrity scandal? For the second time in three months, the Green Party has secretly suspended an MP over integrity issues. Mystery is surrounding the party’s decision to ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    3 days ago
  • Jacqui Van Der Kaay: Greens’ transparency missing in action
    For the last few years, the Green Party has been the party that has managed to avoid the plague of multiple scandals that have beleaguered other political parties. It appears that their luck has run out with a second scandal which, unfortunately for them, coincided with Golraz Ghahraman, the focus ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    4 days ago
  • Bernard’s Dawn Chorus with six newsey things at 6:46am for Saturday, March 16
    TL;DR: The six newsey things that stood out to me as of 6:46am on Saturday, March 16.Andy Foster has accidentally allowed a Labour/Green amendment to cut road user chargers for plug-in hybrid vehicles, which the Government might accept; NZ Herald Thomas Coughlan Simeon Brown has rejected a plea from Westport ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • How Did FTX Crash?
    What seemed a booming success a couple of years ago has collapsed into fraud convictions.I looked at the crash of FTX (short for ‘Futures Exchange’) in November 2022 to see whether it would impact on the financial system as a whole. Fortunately there was barely a ripple, probably because it ...
    PunditBy Brian Easton
    4 days ago
  • Elections in Russia and Ukraine
    Anybody following the situation in Ukraine and Russia would probably have been amused by a recent Tweet on X NATO seems to be putting in an awful lot of effort to influence what is, at least according to them, a sham election in an autocracy.When do the Ukrainians go to ...
    4 days ago
  • Bernard’s six stack of substacks at 6pm on March 15
    TL;DR: Shaun Baker on Wynyard Quarter's transformation. Magdalene Taylor on the problem with smart phones. How private equity are now all over reinsurance. Dylan Cleaver on rugby and CTE. Emily Atkin on ‘Big Meat’ looking like ‘Big Oil’.Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6pm on March 15Photo by Jeppe Hove Jensen ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Buzz from the Beehive Finance Minister Nicola Willis had plenty to say when addressing the Auckland Business Chamber on the economic growth that (she tells us) is flagging more than we thought. But the government intends to put new life into it:  We want our country to be a ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    4 days ago
  • National’s clean car tax advances
    The Transport and Infrastructure Committee has reported back on the Road User Charges (Light Electric RUC Vehicles) Amendment Bill, basicly rubberstamping it. While there was widespread support among submitters for the principle that EV and PHEV drivers should pay their fair share for the roads, they also overwhelmingly disagreed with ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • Government funding bailouts
    Peter Dunne writes – This week’s government bailout – the fifth in the last eighteen months – of the financially troubled Ruapehu Alpine Lifts company would have pleased many in the central North Island ski industry. The government’s stated rationale for the $7 million funding was that it ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • Two offenders, different treatments.
    See if you can spot the difference. An Iranian born female MP from a progressive party is accused of serial shoplifting. Her name is leaked to the media, which goes into a pack frenzy even before the Police launch an … Continue reading ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    4 days ago
  • Treaty references omitted
    Ele Ludemann writes  – The government is omitting general Treaty references from legislation : The growth of Treaty of Waitangi clauses in legislation caused so much worry that a special oversight group was set up by the last Government in a bid to get greater coherence in the public service on Treaty ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • The Ghahraman Conflict
    What was that judge thinking? Peter Williams writes –  That Golriz Ghahraman and District Court Judge Maria Pecotic were once lawyer colleagues is incontrovertible. There is published evidence that they took at least one case to the Court of Appeal together. There was a report on ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 15
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Climate Scorpion – the sting is in the tail. Introducing planetary solvency. A paper via the University of Exeter’s Institute and Faculty of Actuaries.Local scoop: Kāinga Ora starts pulling out of its Auckland projects and selling land RNZ ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • The day Wellington up-zoned its future
    Wellington’s massively upzoned District Plan adds the opportunity for tens of thousands of new homes not just in the central city (such as these Webb St new builds) but also close to the CBD and public transport links. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: Wellington gave itself the chance of ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • Weekly Roundup 15-March-2024
    It’s Friday and we’re halfway through March Madness. Here’s some of the things that caught our attention this week. This Week in Greater Auckland On Monday Matt asked how we can get better event trains and an option for grade separating Morningside Dr. On Tuesday Matt looked into ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    5 days ago
  • That Word.
    Something you might not know about me is that I’m quite a stubborn person. No, really. I don’t much care for criticism I think’s unfair or that I disagree with. Few of us do I suppose.Back when I was a drinker I’d sometimes respond defensively, even angrily. There are things ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • The Hoon around the week to March 15
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The five things that mattered in Aotearoa’s political economy that we wrote and spoke about via The Kākā and elsewhere for paying subscribers in the last week included:PM Christopher Luxon said the reversal of interest deductibility for landlords was done to help renters, who ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • Labour’s policy gap
    It was not so much the Labour Party but really the Chris Hipkins party yesterday at Labour’s caucus retreat in Martinborough. The former Prime Minister was more or less consistent on wealth tax, which he was at best equivocal about, and social insurance, which he was not willing to revisit. ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    5 days ago
  • Skeptical Science New Research for Week #11 2024
    Open access notables A Glimpse into the Future: The 2023 Ocean Temperature and Sea Ice Extremes in the Context of Longer-Term Climate Change, Kuhlbrodt et al., Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society: In the year 2023, we have seen extraordinary extrema in high sea surface temperature (SST) in the North Atlantic and in ...
    5 days ago
  • Melissa remains mute on media matters but has something to say (at a sporting event) about economic ...
     Buzz from the Beehive   The text reproduced above appears on a page which records all the media statements and speeches posted on the government’s official website by Melissa Lee as Minister of Media and Communications and/or by Jenny Marcroft, her Parliamentary Under-secretary.  It can be quickly analysed ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    5 days ago
  • The return of Muldoon
    For forty years, Robert Muldoon has been a dirty word in our politics. His style of government was so repulsive and authoritarian that the backlash to it helped set and entrench our constitutional norms. His pig-headedness over forcing through Think Big eventually gave us the RMA, with its participation and ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Will the rental tax cut improve life for renters or landlords?
    Bryce Edwards writes –  Is the new government reducing tax on rental properties to benefit landlords or to cut the cost of rents? That’s the big question this week, after Associate Finance Minister David Seymour announced on Sunday that the Government would be reversing the Labour Government’s removal ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: What Saudi Arabia’s rapid changes mean for New Zealand
    Saudi Arabia is rarely far from the international spotlight. The war in Gaza has brought new scrutiny to Saudi plans to normalise relations with Israel, while the fifth anniversary of the controversial killing of Jamal Khashoggi was marked shortly before the war began on October 7. And as the home ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    5 days ago
  • Racism’s double standards
    Questions need to be asked on both sides of the world Peter Williams writes –   The NRL Judiciary hands down an eight week suspension to Sydney Roosters forward Spencer Leniu , an Auckland-born Samoan, after he calls Ezra Mam, Sydney-orn but of Aboriginal and Torres Strait ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • It’s not a tax break
    Ele Ludemann writes – Contrary to what many headlines and news stories are saying, residential landlords are not getting a tax break. The government is simply restoring to them the tax deductibility of interest they had until the previous government removed it. There is no logical reason ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • The Plastic Pig Collective and Chris' Imaginary Friends.
    I can't remember when it was goodMoments of happiness in bloomMaybe I just misunderstoodAll of the love we left behindWatching our flashbacks intertwineMemories I will never findIn spite of whatever you becomeForget that reckless thing turned onI think our lives have just begunI think our lives have just begunDoes anyone ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • Who is responsible for young offenders?
    Michael Bassett writes – At first reading, a front-page story in the New Zealand Herald on 13 March was bizarre. A group of severely intellectually limited teenagers, with little understanding of the law, have been pleading to the Justice Select Committee not to pass a bill dealing with ram ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell on National’s fantasy trip to La La Landlord Land
    How much political capital is Christopher Luxon willing to burn through in order to deliver his $2.9 billion gift to landlords? Evidently, Luxon is: (a) unable to cost the policy accurately. As Anna Burns-Francis pointed out to him on Breakfast TV, the original ”rock solid” $2.1 billion cost he was ...
    6 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 14
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Jonathon Porritt calling bullshit in his own blog post on mainstream climate science as ‘The New Denialism’.Local scoop: The Wellington City Council’s list of proposed changes to the IHP recommendations to be debated later today was leaked this ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • No, Prime Minister, rents don’t rise or fall with landlords’ costs
    TL;DR: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said yesterday tenants should be grateful for the reinstatement of interest deductibility because landlords would pass on their lower tax costs in the form of lower rents. That would be true if landlords were regulated monopolies such as Transpower or Auckland Airport1, but they’re not, ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • Cartoons: ‘At least I didn’t make things awkward’
    This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Tom Toro Tom Toro is a cartoonist and author. He has published over 200 cartoons in The New Yorker since 2010. His cartoons appear in Playboy, the Paris Review, the New York Times, American Bystander, and elsewhere. Related: What 10 EV lovers ...
    6 days ago
  • Solving traffic congestion with Richard Prebble
    The business section of the NZ Herald is full of opinion. Among the more opinionated of all is the ex-Minister of Transport, ex-Minister of Railways, ex MP for Auckland Central (1975-93, Labour), Wellington Central (1996-99, ACT, then list-2005), ex-leader of the ACT Party, uncle to actor Antonia, the veritable granddaddy ...
    Greater AucklandBy Patrick Reynolds
    6 days ago
  • I Think I'm Done Flying Boeing
    Hi,Just quickly — I’m blown away by the stories you’ve shared with me over the last week since I put out the ‘Gary’ podcast, where I told you about the time my friend’s flatmate killed the neighbour.And you keep telling me stories — in the comments section, and in my ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    6 days ago
  • Invoking Aristotle: Of Rings of Power, Stones, and Ships
    The first season of Rings of Power was not awful. It was thoroughly underwhelming, yes, and left a lingering sense of disappointment, but it was more expensive mediocrity than catastrophe. I wrote at length about the series as it came out (see the Review section of the blog, and go ...
    6 days ago
  • Van Velden brings free-market approach to changing labour laws – but her colleagues stick to distr...
    Buzz from the Beehive Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden told Auckland Business Chamber members they were the first audience to hear her priorities as a minister in a government committed to cutting red tape and regulations. She brandished her liberalising credentials, saying Flexible labour markets are the ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    6 days ago
  • Why Newshub failed
    Chris Trotter writes – TO UNDERSTAND WHY NEWSHUB FAILED, it is necessary to understand how TVNZ changed. Up until 1989, the state broadcaster had been funded by a broadcasting licence fee, collected from every citizen in possession of a television set, supplemented by a relatively modest (compared ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    6 days ago
  • Māori Party on the warpath against landlords and seabed miners – let’s see if mystical creature...
    Bob Edlin writes  –  The Māori Party has been busy issuing a mix of warnings and threats as its expresses its opposition to interest deductibility for landlords and the plans of seabed miners. It remains to be seen whether they  follow the example of indigenous litigants in Australia, ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    6 days ago

  • Government moves to quickly ratify the NZ-EU FTA
    "The Government is moving quickly to realise an additional $46 million in tariff savings in the EU market this season for Kiwi exporters,” Minister for Trade and Agriculture, Todd McClay says. Parliament is set, this week, to complete the final legislative processes required to bring the New Zealand – European ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 hours ago
  • Positive progress for social worker workforce
    New Zealand’s social workers are qualified, experienced, and more representative of the communities they serve, Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston says. “I want to acknowledge and applaud New Zealand’s social workers for the hard work they do, providing invaluable support for our most vulnerable. “To coincide with World ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    11 hours ago
  • Minister confirms reduced RUC rate for PHEVs
    Cabinet has agreed to a reduced road user charge (RUC) rate for plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs), Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. Owners of PHEVs will be eligible for a reduced rate of $38 per 1,000km once all light electric vehicles (EVs) move into the RUC system from 1 April.  ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    13 hours ago
  • Trade access to overseas markets creates jobs
    Minister of Agriculture and Trade, Todd McClay, says that today’s opening of Riverland Foods manufacturing plant in Christchurch is a great example of how trade access to overseas markets creates jobs in New Zealand.  Speaking at the official opening of this state-of-the-art pet food factory the Minister noted that exports ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    14 hours ago
  • NZ and Chinese Foreign Ministers hold official talks
    Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters met with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi in Wellington today. “It was a pleasure to host Foreign Minister Wang Yi during his first official visit to New Zealand since 2017. Our discussions were wide-ranging and enabled engagement on many facets of New Zealand’s relationship with China, including trade, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Kāinga Ora instructed to end Sustaining Tenancies
    Kāinga Ora – Homes & Communities has been instructed to end the Sustaining Tenancies Framework and take stronger measures against persistent antisocial behaviour by tenants, says Housing Minister Chris Bishop. “Earlier today Finance Minister Nicola Willis and I sent an interim Letter of Expectations to the Board of Kāinga Ora. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Speech to Auckland Business Chamber: Growth is the answer
    Tēna koutou katoa. Greetings everyone. Thank you to the Auckland Chamber of Commerce and the Honourable Simon Bridges for hosting this address today. I acknowledge the business leaders in this room, the leaders and governors, the employers, the entrepreneurs, the investors, and the wealth creators. The coalition Government shares your ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Singapore rounds out regional trip
    Minister Winston Peters completed the final leg of his visit to South and South East Asia in Singapore today, where he focused on enhancing one of New Zealand’s indispensable strategic partnerships.      “Singapore is our most important defence partner in South East Asia, our fourth-largest trading partner and a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Minister van Velden represents New Zealand at International Democracy Summit
    Minister of Internal Affairs and Workplace Relations and Safety, Hon. Brooke van Velden, will travel to the Republic of Korea to represent New Zealand at the Third Summit for Democracy on 18 March. The summit, hosted by the Republic of Korea, was first convened by the United States in 2021, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Insurance Council of NZ Speech, 7 March 2024, Auckland
    ICNZ Speech 7 March 2024, Auckland  Acknowledgements and opening  Mōrena, ngā mihi nui. Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Nor Whanganui aho.  Good morning, it’s a privilege to be here to open the ICNZ annual conference, thank you to Mark for the Mihi Whakatau  My thanks to Tim Grafton for inviting me ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Five-year anniversary of Christchurch terror attacks
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Lead Coordination Minister Judith Collins have expressed their deepest sympathy on the five-year anniversary of the Christchurch terror attacks. “March 15, 2019, was a day when families, communities and the country came together both in sorrow and solidarity,” Mr Luxon says.  “Today we pay our respects to the 51 shuhada ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Speech for Financial Advice NZ Conference 5 March 2024
    Speech for Financial Advice NZ Conference 5 March 2024  Acknowledgements and opening  Morena, Nga Mihi Nui.  Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Nor Whanganui aho. Thanks Nate for your Mihi Whakatau  Good morning. It’s a pleasure to formally open your conference this morning. What a lovely day in Wellington, What a great ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Early visit to Indonesia strengthens ties
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters held discussions in Jakarta today about the future of relations between New Zealand and South East Asia’s most populous country.   “We are in Jakarta so early in our new government’s term to reflect the huge importance we place on our relationship with Indonesia and South ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • China Foreign Minister to visit
    Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters has announced that the Foreign Minister of China, Wang Yi, will visit New Zealand next week.  “We look forward to re-engaging with Foreign Minister Wang Yi and discussing the full breadth of the bilateral relationship, which is one of New Zealand’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Minister opens new Auckland Rail Operations Centre
    Transport Minister Simeon Brown has today opened the new Auckland Rail Operations Centre, which will bring together KiwiRail, Auckland Transport, and Auckland One Rail to improve service reliability for Aucklanders. “The recent train disruptions in Auckland have highlighted how important it is KiwiRail and Auckland’s rail agencies work together to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Celebrating 10 years of Crankworx Rotorua
    The Government is proud to support the 10th edition of Crankworx Rotorua as the Crankworx World Tour returns to Rotorua from 16-24 March 2024, says Minister for Economic Development Melissa Lee.  “Over the past 10 years as Crankworx Rotorua has grown, so too have the economic and social benefits that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government delivering on tax commitments
    Legislation implementing coalition Government tax commitments and addressing long-standing tax anomalies will be progressed in Parliament next week, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The legislation is contained in an Amendment Paper to the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2023–24, Multinational Tax, and Remedial Matters) Bill issued today.  “The Amendment Paper represents ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Significant Natural Areas requirement to be suspended
    Associate Environment Minister Andrew Hoggard has today announced that the Government has agreed to suspend the requirement for councils to comply with the Significant Natural Areas (SNA) provisions of the National Policy Statement for Indigenous Biodiversity for three years, while it replaces the Resource Management Act (RMA).“As it stands, SNAs ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government classifies drought conditions in Top of the South as medium-scale adverse event
    Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has classified the drought conditions in the Marlborough, Tasman, and Nelson districts as a medium-scale adverse event, acknowledging the challenging conditions facing farmers and growers in the district. “Parts of Marlborough, Tasman, and Nelson districts are in the grip of an intense dry spell. I know ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government partnership to tackle $332m facial eczema problem
    The Government is helping farmers eradicate the significant impact of facial eczema (FE) in pastoral animals, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced.  “A $20 million partnership jointly funded by Beef + Lamb NZ, the Government, and the primary sector will save farmers an estimated NZD$332 million per year, and aims to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • NZ, India chart path to enhanced relationship
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters has completed a successful visit to India, saying it was an important step in taking the relationship between the two countries to the next level.   “We have laid a strong foundation for the Coalition Government’s priority of enhancing New Zealand-India relations to generate significant future benefit for both countries,” says Mr Peters, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Ruapehu Alpine Lifts bailout the last, say Ministers
    Cabinet has agreed to provide $7 million to ensure the 2024 ski season can go ahead on the Whakapapa ski field in the central North Island but has told the operator Ruapehu Alpine Lifts it is the last financial support it will receive from taxpayers. Cabinet also agreed to provide ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Govt takes action to drive better cancer services
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the launch of a new mobile breast screening unit in Counties Manukau reinforces the coalition Government’s commitment to drive better cancer services for all New Zealanders. Speaking at the launch of the new mobile clinic, Dr Reti says it’s a great example of taking ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Govt takes action to drive better cancer services
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the launch of a new mobile breast screening unit in Counties Manukau reinforces the coalition Government’s commitment to drive better cancer services for all New Zealanders. Speaking at the launch of the new mobile clinic, Dr Reti says it’s a great example of taking ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Work begins on SH29 upgrades near Tauriko
    Unlocking economic growth and land for housing are critical elements of the Government’s plan for our transport network, and planned upgrades to State Highway 29 (SH29) near Tauriko will deliver strongly on those priorities, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “The SH29 upgrades near Tauriko will improve safety at the intersections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Work begins on SH29 upgrades near Tauriko
    Unlocking economic growth and land for housing are critical elements of the Government’s plan for our transport network, and planned upgrades to State Highway 29 (SH29) near Tauriko will deliver strongly on those priorities, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “The SH29 upgrades near Tauriko will improve safety at the intersections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Fresh produce price drop welcome
    Lower fruit and vegetable prices are welcome news for New Zealanders who have been doing it tough at the supermarket, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. Stats NZ reported today the price of fruit and vegetables has dropped 9.3 percent in the 12 months to February 2024.  “Lower fruit and vege ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Statement to the 68th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women
    Tēnā koutou katoa and greetings to you all.  Chair, I am honoured to address the sixty-eighth session of the Commission on the Status of Women. I acknowledge the many crises impacting the rights of women and girls. Heightened global tensions, war, climate related and humanitarian disasters, and price inflation all ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the 68th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women (CSW68)
    Tēnā koutou katoa and greetings to you all.  Chair, I am honoured to address the 68th session of the Commission on the Status of Women. I acknowledge the many crises impacting the rights of women and girls. Heightened global tensions, war, climate related and humanitarian disasters, and price inflation all ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government backs rural led catchment projects
    The coalition Government is supporting farmers to enhance land management practices by investing $3.3 million in locally led catchment groups, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced. “Farmers and growers deliver significant prosperity for New Zealand and it’s vital their ongoing efforts to improve land management practices and water quality are supported,” ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Speech to Auckland Business Chamber
    Good evening everyone and thank you for that lovely introduction.   Thank you also to the Honourable Simon Bridges for the invitation to address your members. Since being sworn in, this coalition Government has hit the ground running with our 100-day plan, delivering the changes that New Zealanders expect of us. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Commission’s advice on ETS settings tabled
    Recommendations from the Climate Change Commission for New Zealand on the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) auction and unit limit settings for the next five years have been tabled in Parliament, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. “The Commission provides advice on the ETS annually. This is the third time the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government lowering building costs
    The coalition Government is beginning its fight to lower building costs and reduce red tape by exempting minor building work from paying the building levy, says Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk. “Currently, any building project worth $20,444 including GST or more is subject to the building levy which is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Trustee tax change welcomed
    Proposed changes to tax legislation to prevent the over-taxation of low-earning trusts are welcome, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The changes have been recommended by Parliament’s Finance and Expenditure Committee following consideration of submissions on the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2023–24, Multinational Tax, and Remedial Matters) Bill. “One of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister’s Ramadan message
    Assalaamu alaikum. السَّلَام عليكم In light of the holy month of Ramadan, I want to extend my warmest wishes to our Muslim community in New Zealand. Ramadan is a time for spiritual reflection, renewed devotion, perseverance, generosity, and forgiveness.  It’s a time to strengthen our bonds and appreciate the diversity ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister appoints new NZTA Chair
    Former Transport Minister and CEO of the Auckland Business Chamber Hon Simon Bridges has been appointed as the new Board Chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) for a three-year term, Transport Minister Simeon Brown announced today. “Simon brings extensive experience and knowledge in transport policy and governance to the role. He will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to Life Sciences Summit
    Good morning all, it is a pleasure to be here as Minister of Science, Innovation and Technology.  It is fantastic to see how connected and collaborative the life science and biotechnology industry is here in New Zealand. I would like to thank BioTechNZ and NZTech for the invitation to address ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Progress continues apace on water storage
    Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says he is looking forward to the day when three key water projects in Northland are up and running, unlocking the full potential of land in the region. Mr Jones attended a community event at the site of the Otawere reservoir near Kerikeri on Friday. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government agrees to restore interest deductions
    Associate Finance Minister David Seymour has today announced that the Government has agreed to restore deductibility for mortgage interest on residential investment properties. “Help is on the way for landlords and renters alike. The Government’s restoration of interest deductibility will ease pressure on rents and simplify the tax code,” says ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister to attend World Anti-Doping Agency Symposium
    Sport and Recreation Minister Chris Bishop will travel to Switzerland today to attend an Executive Committee meeting and Symposium of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). Mr Bishop will then travel on to London where he will attend a series of meetings in his capacity as Infrastructure Minister. “New Zealanders believe ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-03-19T10:40:16+00:00