Political donations law needs reform

Written By: - Date published: 2:44 pm, August 1st, 2022 - 7 comments
Categories: elections, electoral systems, nz first, politicans, uncategorized, winston peters - Tags:

Last week the two persons who are subject to name suppression were acquitted of fraud charges by Judge Jagose in the High Court.

The decision is technical and the language is dense.  The defendants were acquitted of the fraud charges that they faced and I am certain the result was technically correct.  But the implications are that the judgment identifies a rather big hole in our electoral law.

You may remember that way back in 2008 Winston Peters faced not dissimilar allegations after donations from Owen Glen were shuffled into a trust and Peters did not declare that the donations were made even though they were used to pay legal bills that Peters had. I thought at the time that the payment may have been made to a trust and that Winston was not legally responsible for payment of his legal bills or obligated to disclose the donations because the contract of retainer was with a different entity and not him.  The funds were used to pay a bill but it was not his bill.

A majority of the Privileges Committee subsequently held that he should have declared the donation in his pecuniary interests register although Labour and New Zealand First did not.

Michael Cullen summed up Labour’s concern with the majority decision in these terms:

Even if all those facts follow, and Mr Peters should have found out about the donation or already knew about the donation, the real issue that comes at that point is whether he should have made a return. The registrar told us that if members approached her for advice about whether a matter required a return, she would advise them to ask their lawyer and seek legal advice, which is why the committee has recommended that the registrar should make more rulings on these matters. But what if Mr Peters had done that and had approached his lawyer for advice on this matter? Mr Henry submitted that in fact a return was not required, on two grounds: on the first ground, that it was not a gift to Mr Peters, because there was no obligation to pay, on Mr Peters’ part; and, on the second ground, that it was an electoral expense related to the electoral petition, and electoral expenses are specifically exempted from the requirement to make a return under the pecuniary interests register. The committee concluded that both those points were wrong, but that is not the point. The point is that that is the advice that Mr Peters would have had, had he followed what Dame Margaret Bazley said should be done. In other words, how can one conclude on the basis of this—and engage in a motion of censure on a member—that he knowingly made a false return, when in fact if he had followed what was recommended through this process, he would have been advised that he did not need to make a return on these matters?

The Serious Fraud Office became involved but along with other Government agencies declined to take any action and apart from the Privileges Committee finding Peters was essentially exonerated.

Fast forward to now and what appears to be similar techniques were used to again hide donations from public scrutiny.  Two individuals whose identities have been suppressed were charged by the Serious Fraud Office with two counts of obtaining by deception and without claim of right  nearly $750,000 alleged to be New Zealand First party donations.

Under the Electoral Act anyone receiving a party donation must either transmit it to, or deposit it into a bank account nominated by, the party secretary. The party secretary then is required to “keep proper records of all party donations received by him or her”. None of the money at issue was so transmitted, deposited, received or recorded and this formed the basis of the charge.

The decision relied on the definition of what is a party donation.  The Electoral Act defines a party donation as follows:

A donation (whether of money or of the equivalent of money or of goods or services or of a combination of those things) that is made to a party, or to any person or body of persons on behalf of the party who are involved in the administration of the affairs of the party.”

Reporting and administration requirements are clearly dependent on the funds being handled centrally so if there are any gaps in the rules they would pose rather large challenges to the reporting regime.

The background is that a trust called the New Zealand First Foundation was set up in 2017 with the intent that it would be the recipient of donations.  The trust objective was  “[t]o establish a capital protected trust to receive donations from persons who wish to achieve the objects of this trust where the capital cannot be distributed until vesting day”. The trust deed anticipated “the purchase of capital items (owned by the Trust)” for use “[t]o provide an income stream to further [specified] objects”, essentially being those of the principles of New Zealand First.

The party had set up a Nationbuilder website with donations being paid directly to the Trust’s bank account rather than the party’s account, even though the site was clearly New Zealand First’s official site.  And letters issued by the party seeking donations to wealthy donors included the trust’s bank account rather than the party’s account.

The set up meant that the donations did not have to be declared to the Electoral Commission in the normal way.

By hiding the true nature of the recipient did the two individuals commit fraud?

Judge Jagose did not think so, ruling that they were not involved in the administration of the party and therefore not subject to the various legal reporting requirements.  He said:

As to NZFF, they are payments to EF and FG only as trustees, in which capacity they were not “involved in the administration of the affairs of the party”. ‘Involvement in the administration of the affairs of the party’ is to be construed in the context of the party’s constitutional arrangements, for “governance and management oversight of all the Party’s affairs … [as] vested in the Board”, and thus derivative of the Board’s oversight. But the evidence here is of GH’s and NZFF’s determinedly separate status.””

You have to wonder at the decision not to lay charges under the Electoral Act although many of the offence penalties are fine only and the time for filing charges for these has expired.

And the offences are aimed at party officials.  This case involving two persons who were definitely not party officials has shown the difficulty with this approach.

Cabinet is considering the issue today.  I expect that they will decide to address the apparent hole.  A starting point could be to move to delete the words “who are involved in the administration of the affairs of the party”.

7 comments on “Political donations law needs reform ”

  1. Barfly 1

    I don't remember where I read it – but I do remember reading that the NZF structure for that was based on how the Nats did it (or used to do it in the past)

    • Belladonna 1.1

      From what I've read, National have been declaring all donations (above 15K – current limit) received by their Trusts under the terms of the Electoral Act.

      It seems as though only Peters envisaged that a Trust need not be covered under the disclosure requirements of the Act.

      National have been very clear that this is a loophole which needs to be closed.

  2. Belladonna 2

    Hope this isn't going to come through multiple times – the blog seems to be eating this comment, so am re-submitting.

    Another strategy could be to redefine 'donations' to include money, goods and services given to, or used by, a political party, elected representatives, officials or members to support the aims or operations of the party, or for the benefit of individuals or groups within the Party. Including both electioneering and operational support.

    I'm including goods and services here, to potentially stop the loophole of a donor leasing a bus for electioneering, and then gifting the lease to the party (no money has been given – but it's definitely a service). This would include goods for auction, websites, professional services (polling, etc.), right down to billboards.

    I think this would cover things like the Party Bus, the NZF membership database, and legal bills for Peters.

  3. Belladonna 3

    And, I definitely think that the penalties for evading this Electoral Law need to be much more severe – as are the penalties for Tax Evasion.

    One of the suggestions made earlier, was that the sum 'donated' should be confiscated (which would certainly get the attention of the Party).

    But I also believe that there need to be quite severe penalties for the individuals gaming the system (in this case the 2 'anonymous' people connected with NZF). Who were found guilty in 'substance' (i.e. they most definitely did carry out the actions with the intention of evading the requirement to report donations under Electoral Law), it's just that in the Judge's opinion, the law isn't sufficiently robustly worded to convict them, as they were not party officials.

  4. From a legal point of view, the acquittal was the correct decision. However, it certainly does not leave New Zealand First looking good. On the contrary, Justice Jagose found the scheme was inherently dishonest. He found for the defendants on two separate and quite distinct bases: (1) arguably, in terms of the law, the donations were not political party donations as that term is defined in the Electoral Act, and (2) the defendants had a "claim of right". None of that should obscure what the judge said about the scheme itself.

    I acknowledge that these are technical matters (I am a lawyer) but it is important to remember that everyone is presumed to be innocent until found guilty (or until a guilty plea) and that the prosecution bears the burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt on every element of the charge. The charge that was before the Court was obtaining by deception which means the Crown had to show that the defendants were guilty of "dishonestly and without claim of right… obtaining…"

    I detest New Zealand First and hope Winston and his motley band of conspiracy theorists, ultra-conservatives and general misfits shuffle off into the sunset never to be seen again. He is truly yesterday's man with last week's solutions to tomorrow's problems.

    The electoral finance laws need teeth and they need to be clear that this type of behaviour is not acceptable. Unless there is transparency in respect of the funding of political parties and candidates for political office we run the risk that American-style political lobbying will become endemic and the public would never know, when a politician promotes a policy, whether the politician is merely acting as a de facto paid mouthpiece for a lobby group. That path leads to corruption and the undermining of our democratic system.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Decisions on Wellington City Council’s District Plan
    The Minister Responsible for RMA Reform, Chris Bishop, today released his decision on twenty recommendations referred to him by the Wellington City Council relating to its Intensification Planning Instrument, after the Council rejected those recommendations of the Independent Hearings Panel and made alternative recommendations. “Wellington notified its District Plan on ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    28 mins ago
  • Rape Awareness Week: Government committed to action on sexual violence
    Rape Awareness Week (6-10 May) is an important opportunity to acknowledge the continued effort required by government and communities to ensure that all New Zealanders can live free from violence, say Ministers Karen Chhour and Louise Upston.  “With 1 in 3 women and 1 in 8 men experiencing sexual violence ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    49 mins ago
  • Smarter lunch programme feeds more, costs less
    Associate Education Minister David Seymour has today announced that the Government will be delivering a more efficient Healthy School Lunches Programme, saving taxpayers approximately $107 million a year compared to how Labour funded it, by embracing innovation and commercial expertise. “We are delivering on our commitment to treat taxpayers’ money ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 hours ago
  • Report provides insights into marine recovery
    New research on the impacts of extreme weather on coastal marine habitats in Tairāwhiti and Hawke’s Bay will help fishery managers plan for and respond to any future events, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones says. A report released today on research by Niwa on behalf of Fisheries New Zealand ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 hours ago
  • NZ to send political delegation to the Pacific
    Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Winston Peters will lead a broad political delegation on a five-stop Pacific tour next week to strengthen New Zealand’s engagement with the region.   The delegation will visit Solomon Islands, Papua New Guinea, Vanuatu, New Caledonia, and Tuvalu.    “New Zealand has deep and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 hours ago
  • Low gas production threatens energy security
    There has been a material decline in gas production according to figures released today by the Gas Industry Co.  Figures released by the Gas Industry Company show that there was a 12.5 per cent reduction in gas production during 2023, and a 27.8 per cent reduction in gas production in the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    8 hours ago
  • Defence industry talent, commitment recognised
    Defence Minister Judith Collins tonight announced the recipients of the Minister of Defence Awards of Excellence for Industry, saying they all contribute to New Zealanders’ security and wellbeing. “Congratulations to this year’s recipients, whose innovative products and services play a critical role in the delivery of New Zealand’s defence capabilities, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    17 hours ago
  • Speech to the Minister of Defence Awards of Excellence for Industry
    Welcome to you all - it is a pleasure to be here this evening.I would like to start by thanking Greg Lowe, Chair of the New Zealand Defence Industry Advisory Council, for co-hosting this reception with me. This evening is about recognising businesses from across New Zealand and overseas who in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    17 hours ago
  • Speech to the Sixth Annual New Zealand Government Data Summit
    It is a pleasure to be speaking to you as the Minister for Digitising Government.  I would like to thank Akolade for the invitation to address this Summit, and to acknowledge the great effort you are making to grow New Zealand’s digital future. Today, we stand at the cusp of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    18 hours ago
  • Ceasefire agreement needed now: Peters
    New Zealand is urging both Israel and Hamas to agree to an immediate ceasefire to avoid the further humanitarian catastrophe that military action in Rafah would unleash, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says.   “The immense suffering in Gaza cannot be allowed to worsen further. Both sides have a responsibility to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Daily school attendance data now available
    A new online data dashboard released today as part of the Government’s school attendance action plan makes more timely daily attendance data available to the public and parents, says Associate Education Minister David Seymour.  The interactive dashboard will be updated once a week to show a national average of how ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Ambassador to United States appointed
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters has announced Rosemary Banks will be New Zealand’s next Ambassador to the United States of America.    “Our relationship with the United States is crucial for New Zealand in strategic, security and economic terms,” Mr Peters says.    “New Zealand and the United States have a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • New permit proposed for recreational gold mining
    The Government is considering creating a new tier of minerals permitting that will make it easier for hobby miners to prospect for gold. “New Zealand was built on gold, it’s in our DNA. Our gold deposits, particularly in regions such as Otago and the West Coast have always attracted fortune-hunters. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • NZ and the UAE launch FTA negotiations
    Minister for Trade Todd McClay today announced that New Zealand and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) will commence negotiations on a free trade agreement (FTA). Minister McClay met with his counterpart UAE Trade Minister Dr Thani bin Ahmed Al Zeyoudi in Dubai, where they announced the launch of negotiations on a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • New Zealand Sign Language Week an opportunity for anyone to sign
    New Zealand Sign Language Week is an excellent opportunity for all Kiwis to give the language a go, Disabilities Issues Minister Louise Upston says. This week (May 6 to 12) is New Zealand Sign Language (NZSL) Week. The theme is “an Aotearoa where anyone can sign anywhere” and aims to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Next stop NASA for New Zealand students
    Six tertiary students have been selected to work on NASA projects in the US through a New Zealand Space Scholarship, Space Minister Judith Collins announced today. “This is a fantastic opportunity for these talented students. They will undertake internships at NASA’s Ames Research Center or its Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), where ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • $1.9 billion investment to keep NZ safe from crime
    New Zealanders will be safer because of a $1.9 billion investment in more frontline Corrections officers, more support for offenders to turn away from crime, and more prison capacity, Corrections Minister Mark Mitchell says. “Our Government said we would crack down on crime. We promised to restore law and order, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • OECD reinforces need to control spending
    The OECD’s latest report on New Zealand reinforces the importance of bringing Government spending under control, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The OECD conducts country surveys every two years to review its members’ economic policies. The 2024 New Zealand survey was presented in Wellington today by OECD Chief Economist Clare Lombardelli.   ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Agreement delivers Local Water Done Well for Auckland
    The Government has delivered on its election promise to provide a financially sustainable model for Auckland under its Local Water Done Well plan. The plan, which has been unanimously endorsed by Auckland Council’s Governing Body, will see Aucklanders avoid the previously projected 25.8 per cent water rates increases while retaining ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Gaza and the Pacific on the agenda with Germany
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters discussed the need for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza, and enhanced cooperation in the Pacific with German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock during her first official visit to New Zealand today.    "New Zealand and Germany enjoy shared interests and values, including the rule of law, democracy, respect for the international system ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Decision allows for housing growth in Western Bay of Plenty
    The Minister Responsible for RMA Reform, Chris Bishop today released his decision on four recommendations referred to him by the Western Bay of Plenty District Council, opening the door to housing growth in the area. The Council’s Plan Change 92 allows more homes to be built in existing and new ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Speech to New Zealand China Council
    Thank you, John McKinnon and the New Zealand China Council for the invitation to speak to you today.    Thank you too, all members of the China Council. Your effort has played an essential role in helping to build, shape, and grow a balanced and resilient relationship between our two ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Modern insurance law will protect Kiwi households
    The Government is modernising insurance law to better protect Kiwis and provide security in the event of a disaster, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly announced today. “These reforms are long overdue. New Zealand’s insurance law is complicated and dated, some of which is more than 100 years old. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government recommits to equal pay
    The coalition Government is refreshing its approach to supporting pay equity claims as time-limited funding for the Pay Equity Taskforce comes to an end, Public Service Minister Nicola Willis says.  “Three years ago, the then-government introduced changes to the Equal Pay Act to support pay equity bargaining. The changes were ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Transforming how our children learn to read
    Structured literacy will change the way New Zealand children learn to read - improving achievement and setting students up for success, Education Minister Erica Stanford says.  “Being able to read and write is a fundamental life skill that too many young people are missing out on. Recent data shows that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • NZ not backing down in Canada dairy dispute
    Trade Minister Todd McClay says Canada’s refusal to comply in full with a CPTPP trade dispute ruling in our favour over dairy trade is cynical and New Zealand has no intention of backing down. Mr McClay said he has asked for urgent legal advice in respect of our ‘next move’ ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Stronger oversight for our most vulnerable children
    The rights of our children and young people will be enhanced by changes the coalition Government will make to strengthen oversight of the Oranga Tamariki system, including restoring a single Children’s Commissioner. “The Government is committed to delivering better public services that care for our most at-risk young people and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Streamlining Building Consent Changes
    The Government is making it easier for minor changes to be made to a building consent so building a home is easier and more affordable, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says.      “The coalition Government is focused on making it easier and cheaper to build homes so we can ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Minister acknowledges passing of Sir Robert Martin (KNZM)
    New Zealand lost a true legend when internationally renowned disability advocate Sir Robert Martin (KNZM) passed away at his home in Whanganui last night, Disabilities Issues Minister Louise Upston says. “Our Government’s thoughts are with his wife Lynda, family and community, those he has worked with, the disability community in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Speech to New Zealand Institute of International Affairs, Parliament – Annual Lecture: Challenges ...
    Good evening –   Before discussing the challenges and opportunities facing New Zealand’s foreign policy, we’d like to first acknowledge the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs. You have contributed to debates about New Zealand foreign policy over a long period of time, and we thank you for hosting us.  ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Accelerating airport security lines
    From today, passengers travelling internationally from Auckland Airport will be able to keep laptops and liquids in their carry-on bags for security screening thanks to new technology, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “Creating a more efficient and seamless travel experience is important for holidaymakers and businesses, enabling faster movement through ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Community hui to talk about kina barrens
    People with an interest in the health of Northland’s marine ecosystems are invited to a public meeting to discuss how to deal with kina barrens, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones says. Mr Jones will lead the discussion, which will take place on Friday, 10 May, at Awanui Hotel in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Kiwi exporters win as NZ-EU FTA enters into force
    Kiwi exporters are $100 million better off today with the NZ EU FTA entering into force says Trade Minister Todd McClay. “This is all part of our plan to grow the economy. New Zealand's prosperity depends on international trade, making up 60 per cent of the country’s total economic activity. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Mining resurgence a welcome sign
    There are heartening signs that the extractive sector is once again becoming an attractive prospect for investors and a source of economic prosperity for New Zealand, Resources Minister Shane Jones says. “The beginnings of a resurgence in extractive industries are apparent in media reports of the sector in the past ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Ō-Rākau Remembrance Bill passes first reading
    The return of the historic Ō-Rākau battle site to the descendants of those who fought there moved one step closer today with the first reading of Te Pire mō Ō-Rākau, Te Pae o Maumahara / The Ō-Rākau Remembrance Bill. The Bill will entrust the 9.7-hectare battle site, five kilometres west ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government to boost public EV charging network
    Energy Minister Simeon Brown has announced 25 new high-speed EV charging hubs along key routes between major urban centres and outlined the Government’s plan to supercharge New Zealand’s EV infrastructure.  The hubs will each have several chargers and be capable of charging at least four – and up to 10 ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Residential Property Managers Bill to not progress
    The coalition Government will not proceed with the previous Government’s plans to regulate residential property managers, Housing Minister Chris Bishop says. “I have written to the Chairperson of the Social Services and Community Committee to inform him that the Government does not intend to support the Residential Property Managers Bill ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Independent review into disability support services
    The Government has announced an independent review into the disability support system funded by the Ministry of Disabled People – Whaikaha. Disability Issues Minister Louise Upston says the review will look at what can be done to strengthen the long-term sustainability of Disability Support Services to provide disabled people and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Justice Minister updates UN on law & order plan
    Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith has attended the Universal Periodic Review in Geneva and outlined the Government’s plan to restore law and order. “Speaking to the United Nations Human Rights Council provided us with an opportunity to present New Zealand’s human rights progress, priorities, and challenges, while responding to issues and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Ending emergency housing motels in Rotorua
    The Government and Rotorua Lakes Council are committed to working closely together to end the use of contracted emergency housing motels in Rotorua. Associate Minister of Housing (Social Housing) Tama Potaka says the Government remains committed to ending the long-term use of contracted emergency housing motels in Rotorua by the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-05-08T01:28:43+00:00